It was a single-story structure with boarded windows, a collapsed porch rail, and gray paint peeling from the wooden siding. The roof sagged slightly near the back. A broken rain gutter hung from one corner, dripping steadily into a patch of weeds.
It was the kind of place time forgot because somebody had paid for it to be forgotten.
Evelyn stared through the windshield.
“I've been here.”
Logan turned toward her.
“You're sure?”
“Yes.”
There was no hesitation in her answer.
“I know that porch.”
She raised one trembling hand toward the windshield.
“I painted it blue.”
Duke looked at the peeling gray wood.
“When?”
“Before Samuel disappeared.”
Her voice cracked.
“We came here in summer. Arthur, Daniel, Samuel, and me.”
She stared at the cabin as though she could see the people they had been standing on the porch thirty years earlier.
“We were a family.”
The last word nearly broke her.
Logan got out first. The others followed, checking the property and the surrounding tree line before allowing Evelyn to approach the door.
The lock was old, but the key fit.
For a moment, she could not turn it.
Her hand hovered over the brass handle. Rain collected on the sleeve of her cardigan.
Logan stood beside her without touching her.
“You don't have to do this alone.”
Evelyn looked at him.
“I know.”
She inserted the key and turned it.
The lock clicked.
The door opened with a long, dry groan.
Inside, dust covered every surface. Furniture sat beneath white sheets, and the air smelled of damp wood, old paper, and the faint mustiness of a building that had remained closed through too many seasons. A clock hung above the fireplace, its hands frozen at 4:17.
Evelyn stepped into the living room.
She moved slowly, but she did not appear lost.
“Kitchen there,” she said, pointing without looking.
“Samuel used to hide cookies behind the flour.”
Jax crossed to the kitchen and opened a cabinet. Behind an ancient flour tin, he found a small green plastic dinosaur.
Its tail was scratched. One of its teeth had broken off.
Evelyn stopped breathing.
Jax turned toward her.
“Is this…?”
She took the toy from his hand.
“Mr. Teeth.”
Her voice dissolved into a whisper.
“Samuel called him Mr. Teeth.”
She held the dinosaur against her chest and began crying silently. The tears simply appeared, one after another, without the drama of a sob.
Logan stood close enough to catch her if she fell, but he did not try to take the toy away.
Evelyn ran her thumb over the broken tooth.
“He carried this everywhere. He took it to school. He took it to bed. Once, he put it in the refrigerator because he said Mr. Teeth wanted to know what cold felt like.”
Duke turned away.
Jax studied the kitchen counter as though the old wood had suddenly become fascinating.
Even Reeves, who had spent years training himself to observe distress without becoming involved in it, looked toward the floor.
Evelyn pressed the dinosaur to her cheek.
“I forgot his laugh,” she whispered. “I forgot that he used to laugh.”
Logan felt his throat tighten.
“You haven't forgotten everything.”
She shook her head.
“No. I forgot the things that made him a person. I remembered the blood. I remembered the bridge. I remembered people shouting. But I forgot the cookies and the dinosaur and the way he laughed when I pretended not to understand his jokes.”
She wiped her face.
“What kind of mother forgets that?”
“The kind who was hurt,” Logan said. “The kind whose mind was trying to survive something she couldn't bear to remember.”
She looked at him.
For a moment, he thought she might argue.
Instead, she nodded.
Then she placed Mr. Teeth carefully in her purse, wrapped in a tissue.
“I want to see the rest.”
They moved down the hallway.
Three bedrooms opened off it. The first held an empty bedframe. The second contained old boxes stacked against the wall. The third was locked.
Evelyn stopped before it.
Her eyes moved to the brass key.
“This one.”
Logan checked the door and the frame. There were no signs of recent damage, but the lock was newer than the others.
“You remember this room?”
“No.”
“Then how do you know?”
She touched the key.
“Because I remember Arthur telling me never to open it.”
The answer was enough.
She inserted the key.
It turned.
The door opened.
The room beyond was not a bedroom.
It was an office, windowless and narrow, with shelves lining every wall. Boxes filled the shelves from floor to ceiling. A desk stood in the center, its surface cleared except for a lamp, a rusted stapler, and a stack of papers held together with a black binder clip.
Arthur Mercer had built an archive.
Jax stepped inside and stared.
“What the hell?”
Labels covered the boxes.
BANK RECORDS.
PROPERTY.
DANIEL.
SAMUEL.
Evelyn stopped moving.
Her hand rose toward the label.
Samuel.
Logan pulled the box down and placed it on the desk.
Inside were photographs, birth certificates, medical records, school drawings, letters, and hundreds of pages of documents. Some were carefully organized. Others had been shoved into folders as though their owner had been in a hurry.
Evelyn sat heavily in the chair.
“Why would Arthur keep this hidden?”
Jax lifted a folder and opened it.
His expression changed.
“Because Samuel's birth certificate isn't what you told us.”
Evelyn looked up.
“What?”
Jax placed the document in front of her.
Mother: Evelyn Marie Vale.
Father: Arthur Raymond Mercer.
Evelyn stared at the page.
“No.”
Logan leaned closer.
“You told us Samuel's father left before he was born.”
“He did.”
“You said his name was Thomas?”
Evelyn shook her head.
“No. I said Thomas left. I thought he had left the country.”
Jax turned another page.
A DNA report lay behind the birth certificate.
Probability of paternity: 99.97%.
Arthur Mercer was Samuel's biological father.
Evelyn stared as if the letters belonged to another language.
Then she stood so suddenly that the chair crashed backward.
“He knew.”
“Who?” Logan asked.
“Arthur. He found out Samuel was his.”
She pressed a hand to her mouth.
“He found out after we were married.”
Jax frowned.
“How could you not know?”
“Because the man I thought was Samuel's father…”