She Asked Him to Pretend to Be Her Husband. By the Time the Truth Came Out, Nothing About Their Marriage Was Pretend

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Hargrove looked at Clara.

"Mrs. Reed, you should remain here. The journey is dangerous, and your testimony will be needed later."

Clara stood.

"No."

"Mrs. Reed—"

"My mother spent her life protecting the truth. I will not stay behind while someone else risks everything to defend it."

Nathaniel looked at her.

"Clara, I don't want you in danger."

She met his eyes.

"Neither do I. But I am already in danger. The difference is that now I have a choice."

For a long moment, Nathaniel said nothing.

Then he nodded.

"All right. We go together."

The next morning, the three of them left Mercy Creek with Hargrove. Thomas remained behind to help the townspeople secure the documents and prepare for the legal proceedings.

The journey to Denver took two days.

They traveled through mountain passes and open prairie, stopping at small settlements along the way. Nathaniel rarely left Clara's side. He checked the horses, watched the road, and slept lightly whenever they stopped for the night.

On the second evening, they reached a small hotel outside Denver.

Clara and Nathaniel were given a room with two narrow beds.

She stood beside the window, watching the lights of the city.

"Do you ever wish you hadn't married me?" she asked.

Nathaniel looked up from cleaning his rifle.

"Why would you ask that?"

"Because your life was simple before I came along."

He set the rifle aside.

"My life was quiet. That isn't the same as being happy."

Clara turned toward him.

"You're risking everything because of me."

"I'm risking everything because of what is right."

"And if there were no land? No forged documents? No danger? Would you still have married me?"

Nathaniel stared at her.

He could have told her the truth.

He could have said that he had loved her long before she entered the general store that rainy evening.

But he was afraid.

Afraid that she would think he had agreed to the marriage for selfish reasons. Afraid that she would feel obligated to return feelings she did not share.

So he answered carefully.

"I would still have wanted to help you."

Clara lowered her eyes.

"That isn't what I asked."

Before he could respond, a knock sounded at the door.

Hargrove stood outside.

"Martha Ellison is ready to meet us."

The following morning, they met Martha in a small office above a bookshop.

She was an elderly woman with white hair, sharp eyes, and a walking stick. She studied Clara for a long time before speaking.

"You look like your mother."

Clara swallowed.

"You knew her?"

"I worked in the county courthouse for thirty years. Margaret Whitmore was one of the few people who ever treated me with kindness."

Martha opened a locked drawer and removed a large ledger.

"This is the original register of land transfers from the year your mother inherited the property."

Clara leaned forward.

Martha turned to a page marked with a red ribbon.

"There. The original deed. Your mother's signature."

Then she turned another page.

"And here is the transfer Vale claims she signed."

Clara looked closely.

The signatures were almost identical.

Almost.

But the second signature was missing a small mark that her mother had always made beneath the final letter of her name.

Clara pointed to it.

"My mother never signed her name without that mark."

Martha nodded.

"I noticed the same thing. I made a copy before the records disappeared."

Hargrove examined the ledger.

"This is enough to challenge the transfer."

"Not without testimony," Martha replied. "And I am prepared to give it."

Nathaniel exhaled slowly.

For the first time, the truth was within reach.

But as they left the office, a black carriage stopped at the curb.

Edmund Vale stepped out.

He wore a dark suit, a polished hat, and a smile that never reached his eyes.

"Mrs. Reed."

Clara froze.

Vale removed his hat.

"Mr. Reed. I believe we have unfinished business."

Nathaniel stepped between him and Clara.

"There is nothing left to discuss."

Vale smiled.

"On the contrary. I have a proposal."

He glanced at Hargrove.

"I'll pay five times the value of the property. Enough for Mrs. Reed to live comfortably for the rest of her life."

Clara stared at him.

"My mother is dead because of you."

Vale's smile disappeared.

"Be careful what you accuse me of."

"I know about the spring. I know about the forged deed. I know what you did to Thomas Reed."

For the first time, something like fear crossed Vale's face.

Then it vanished.

"You know nothing."

Nathaniel stepped forward.

"Walk away, Vale."

The rancher looked at him.

"You think you've won? You have a few papers and a witness. I have friends in every courthouse between here and Washington."

Hargrove raised the ledger.

"Not anymore."

Vale stared at the document.

Then he turned to Clara.

"You should have taken my offer."

He climbed into the carriage and disappeared into the crowded street.

Clara watched him go.

Nathaniel took her hand.

"Are you all right?"

She nodded.

But she knew that Edmund Vale would not surrender easily.

And neither would the man who had married her.

The trial began three weeks later in the federal courthouse in Denver.

By then, the story had spread across the territory. Newspapers reported that a wealthy rancher had been accused of stealing land from settlers, forging legal documents, and conspiring with a county sheriff to silence witnesses.

Edmund Vale arrived with three lawyers and a dozen men who stood outside the courthouse.

Clara arrived with Nathaniel, Thomas, Samuel Hargrove, and Martha Ellison.

She wore a simple gray dress and carried her mother's letter inside her coat.

When she entered the courtroom, every conversation stopped.

Vale sat at the defense table, his expression calm and confident. Sheriff Bell was brought in under guard to testify. He looked smaller than Clara remembered, his once-proud shoulders bent beneath the weight of his own crimes.

The judge entered.

Everyone stood.

The hearing began.

Hargrove presented the land records, the correspondence between Margaret Whitmore and Thomas Reed, and the documents recovered from the strongbox near the spring.

He called Martha Ellison to testify.

She explained how the original deed had been altered, how she had copied the land register, and how she had preserved the evidence after Vale took control of the courthouse.

Vale's lawyers questioned her for hours.

They suggested that she was confused, that she had misremembered dates, and that she had been paid by Clara to lie.

Martha answered every question calmly.

Then Thomas Reed took the stand.

For fourteen years, Thomas had carried the burden of being called a thief. Now, before the court, he told the story of his disappearance.

He described the night he and Elias Mercer discovered the forged records. He explained how Vale's men attacked them near the spring and how Sheriff Bell threatened his family.

When the lawyers asked why he had never returned home, Thomas looked toward Nathaniel.

"Because I believed my presence would put my wife and son in danger. I thought staying away was the only way to protect them."

Nathaniel sat motionless.

His father had finally spoken the truth before the world.

But the hardest testimony was yet to come.

Clara took the stand.

She held her mother's letter in both hands.

Hargrove asked her to describe Margaret's final weeks.

Clara told the court about the threatening letters, the suspicious visits, and the night she found her mother lying on the floor.

She spoke of the forged deed and the attempts to force her into a private settlement.

Then she read her mother's final letter aloud.

Her voice trembled, but she did not stop.

When she finished, the courtroom was silent.

The judge asked whether she believed Edmund Vale had been responsible for her mother's death.

Clara looked directly at the rancher.

"I cannot tell this court who delivered the final blow. But I know my mother was frightened because she had discovered the truth about him. I know she was threatened. I know she died before she could bring the evidence to light. And I know that Edmund Vale tried to take everything she left behind."

Vale's lawyer stood.

"Objection. The witness is making accusations without direct evidence."

The judge nodded.

"That portion of the testimony will be limited to the facts she personally observed."

Clara accepted the ruling.

She had not come to court to invent a story.

She had come to tell the truth.

Then Sheriff Bell was brought forward.

At first, he denied everything.

He claimed that Vale had never instructed him to threaten Margaret Whitmore, that he had never received money, and that Thomas Reed had disappeared voluntarily.

But Hargrove presented a ledger recovered from Vale's ranch.

News in the same category

She Asked Him to Pretend to Be Her Husband. By the Time the Truth Came Out, Nothing About Their Marriage Was Pretend

7 Part