She Called 911 on Four Men Barbecuing Behind a New Neighbor’s Fence — Then the HOA Meeting She Demanded Went Silent

Chapter 41

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That felt right. A record is not revenge. A record is not a weapon. A record is a way of saying: this is what happened, and here is the paper that proves it, and anybody can read it, including the person it is about. That is all it ever was. That is all it needed to be.

Christmas came, and with it, the only honest way to settle the Die Hard debate.

The debate had started that first Saturday, at the grill, before Linda had come through the gate. Tyler had said Die Hard was a Christmas movie. Chris had said it was not, because it was an action movie that happened to take place at Christmas, which was not the same thing. Ramon had said nothing, because Ramon is smarter than both of them. I had said I was not getting involved, because I was cooking burgers, and because I knew that once Tyler and Chris started arguing about a movie, they would not stop until somebody changed the subject or the food ran out.

The debate had survived everything since then. It had survived the 911 call, and the fine, and the board meetings, and the plea, and the apologies. Tyler brought it up at the second grill. Chris brought it up at the block cookout. Ramon brought it up once, just to watch the other two argue, and then he went back to being quiet. It had become a joke, and then it had become a tradition, and then it had become a question that needed an answer, the way some jokes do.

"We should watch it," Tyler said, in November. "At Christmas. All four of us. At your place. We watch it, and then we decide."

"Decide what?" I asked.

"Decide if it is a Christmas movie," Tyler said, as if this were obvious.

"And if we cannot decide?" Chris asked.

"Then we watch it again next year," Tyler said.

That was the logic of a man who has never lost an argument in his own head.

So on the Saturday before Christmas, the four of us gathered in my living room, with the curtains drawn and the lights low and a bowl of popcorn that Ramon had made, and I put Die Hard on the television. It was the first time I had watched it all the way through in years. I had forgotten how much of it takes place at a Christmas party. I had forgotten the music. I had forgotten the jokes about Christmas. I had also forgotten how much of it is about a man in a vest crawling through vents and shooting people, which is not, strictly speaking, a traditional Christmas activity.

Tyler watched it with his arms folded, nodding at the Christmas parts. Chris watched it with his arms folded, nodding at the action parts. Ramon watched it the way Ramon watches everything: calmly, saying nothing, missing nothing. I watched it and thought about the fact that a year ago, almost to the day, I had been standing at a grill in my own backyard, arguing about this movie with these same three men, and a woman had walked through my gate and called us a gang.

Halfway through, Tyler said, "See? Christmas party. Christmas music. Christmas."

Chris said, "He is shooting people. In a vest. That is not Christmas."

Ramon said, "Only Marcus talks."

We all laughed at that, because it was the old line, from the old day, and it still worked, and it still meant the same thing: slow down, let one person talk, do not turn this into a scene.

When the movie ended, and the credits rolled, and John McClane walked out into the snow with his wife, Tyler turned to me and said, "Well?"

I thought about it. I thought about the Christmas party, and the music, and the vents, and the vest, and the fact that the movie ends with a man who has survived a terrible night walking out to the person he loves, in the snow, at Christmas.

"It is a Christmas movie," I said. "It is not a good Christmas movie. It is not a peaceful Christmas movie. But it takes place at Christmas, and it ends at Christmas, and the Christmas part is not an accident. It is a Christmas movie."

Tyler pumped his fist. Chris shook his head. Ramon smiled, which for Ramon is the same as cheering.

"Your verdict," Tyler said, pointing at me. "That is the verdict. It counts."

"It counts for this room," I said. "It does not count for the world. The world can argue about it forever."

News in the same category

She Called 911 on Four Men Barbecuing Behind a New Neighbor’s Fence — Then the HOA Meeting She Demanded Went Silent

45 Part