Chapter Five
The New Resident Who Did Not Know Her
Karen Bennett had lived in the building for less than a year, and she did not know Evelyn Carter, not really, not the way the longtime residents knew her. She knew the woman on the sixth floor only as a figure she passed in the hallway, a slow older woman with a small bag, a woman who nodded and said good morning in a low voice and then went on her way. Karen had nodded back, politely, the way new residents nod, and she had gone on with her own life, and she had never stopped to ask the woman's name or how long she had lived there. The building was large, and the faces in it were many, and Karen had her own worries, and the slow woman on the sixth floor was simply one more face among the many, neither friend nor stranger, until the morning when Karen looked out of her window and saw her near the bins and did not recognize her at all.
Karen worried about the changes in the area, the way people worry when the place they live begins to feel different from the place they chose. New people came and went. Cars she did not know parked in the parking area. Voices she did not recognize sounded in the courtyard at night. She read the notices in the hallway about break ins in the neighborhood, and she locked her door twice at night, and she told herself that she was being careful, not fearful, and that care was a sensible thing. She had moved to the building for its quiet and its order, and she wanted the quiet and the order to hold, and when something looked out of place, she noticed it, and she noticed it sharply. Her friends told her she was watchful, and she took it as a compliment, and she did not see that watchfulness, untrained and unguided, can turn quickly into suspicion, and suspicion into a call that cannot be taken back.
On that Tuesday morning, Karen woke early and stood at her window with her coffee, looking down at the courtyard while the building woke up around her. The morning was pale and cool, and the paving was damp, and the courtyard was mostly empty, the way it always was at that hour. Then she saw the woman. The woman was moving slowly along the edge of the courtyard, carrying a small bag, stopping now and then as if she were unsure of the way, and Karen watched her with the attention of a person who has decided that something is wrong and is looking for the proof of it. The woman did not look like the neighbors Karen knew. She was older, and slower, and she kept to the edge, and she looked at the fence and the bins as if she were studying them, and Karen felt a small cold feeling of certainty settle in her chest. She did not know the woman's name. She did not know how long the woman had lived there. She did not know that the woman had taught children in the building, or that she had walked that same route every morning for eleven years. She knew only that a stranger seemed to be lingering near the bins, and that the area had changed, and that she had read the notices in the hallway.
Karen thought about what to do, and her thoughts moved quickly, the way thoughts move when fear has hold of them. She thought about going downstairs and speaking to the woman herself, and she put the thought aside, because speaking to a stranger felt risky, and because she was not sure what she would say. She told herself that she was protecting the building, and that protecting the building was a good thing, and that a call was a small thing, a careful thing, a thing that would bring someone who knew how to handle it. She did not think about what the call would set in motion. She thought only about the stranger near the bins, and about the notices in the hallway, and about the feeling that something was wrong.
She picked up her phone and found the number, and her hand shook a little as she held it, and she told herself that the shaking was care, not fear. She looked out of the window once more, and the woman was still there, still slow, still at the edge of the courtyard, and Karen took that as confirmation, and she made the call. She spoke quickly, and her voice was tight, and she described a suspicious person near the trash bins, a woman she did not recognize, a woman who did not seem to belong there, and she answered the dispatcher's questions as best she could, and when the dispatcher asked whether she had seen anything criminal, Karen hesitated, and then she said that she had not seen a crime, exactly, but that the woman did not belong, and that someone should come and check. The call was short. The phone went quiet in her hand. Karen stood at the window and watched the courtyard, and she waited, and she did not yet know that she had set in motion a morning that would be remembered in the building for a long time, or that the woman she had called about had a name, and a history, and eleven years of mornings just like this one.