She Grabbed a Stranger and Whispered "Just Play Along" - Then Her Ex's Lawyer Heard His Name and Went White

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"You have no idea what you are involving yourself in."

"No," Elias agreed, pleasantly. "But I know a frightened man performing certainty when I see one. I have seated them at tables for years. The performance gets better as the fear does. Yours is excellent."

Preston's jaw moved. "Careful."

"That is my line to you."

"Stop it." Marlo heard her own voice like a hand coming down flat on the counter, and both men stopped, which told her everything about the morning: they would perform around her for as long as she let them. "Both of you. This is my shop, and she is my daughter, and I have had a week of men arranging my life in voices just above a whisper. It ends here." She looked at Preston. "You want court. Fine. Court. Not because he says so and not because you are scared of what he is. Because I decide it. If a judge is going to decide where Poppy sleeps, then she is going to do it with me standing there, answering for myself."

"Marlo," Elias said, quietly, "that is not a decision to make standing in a bakery at four in the afternoon to prove a point to this man."

"It is not to prove a point. It is the only point." She lifted her chin. "You do not get to fix this, Elias. Not with a phone call, not with a check, not with whatever it is that makes lawyers go white. And you," she said to Preston, "do not get to win it by making me too frightened to show up. Ten o'clock. I will be there."

Preston picked up the envelope. He held it a moment, and then, in the way of a man returning a serve, he smiled the smile that had once made her say yes to a second date, all confidence and no warmth at all.

"With what attorney?" he asked. "You have twenty-four hours, Marlo. Less. The hearing is at ten, the filing is already moving, and good family lawyers in this city book out by the season. You could not retain one with what is in that register, and we both know it. Robert is very good. Who is yours?"

He did not raise his voice. He did not need to. He let the arithmetic of her life speak for him, the way it had been speaking for her at three in the morning for months: the deposit she could not pay, the mixer she had sold, the jar by the register.

"I will see you at ten," she said.

"You will see me win at ten."

He went out into the thin light. The door closed. For a moment neither Marlo nor Elias moved, and the bakery smelled of sugar and cooling ovens, ordinary smells, the smells of the place that had been her father's before it was hers.

"You have the card," Elias said at last.

"I have the card."

"Then the arithmetic he is so proud of is already wrong, and he does not know it, which is the one mercy of this entire day. Call her tonight. Not tomorrow. Tonight."

"I will call who I decide to call, when I decide to call them," Marlo said, but she said it gently, the way you speak to someone who has just handed you a door and sworn it was not a leash. "Thank you for the door, Elias."

He nodded once. At the door he paused, and did not turn around. "Ten o'clock," he said. "Whatever happens at ten o'clock, after it, you call me. Not for help. So that I know."

"So that you know," she said, and it was not a promise, and it was not a refusal, and he took it for what it was and went.

Chapter 9: Catherine Bell

She called at four in the morning.

Marlo had not intended to. She had intended, with great dignity, to sleep, and then to wake at six and be a person who made decisions in daylight. Instead she had lain in the dark of her small bedroom listening to the building settle and to Poppy breathing through the wall, that light, careful breathing that Marlo had learned to count the way other mothers counted money in a purse. One, two. One, two. At four she gave up, made tea she did not drink, and sat on the kitchen floor with the plain white card and her phone, and dialed before her courage could be consulted.

A woman answered on the second ring, fully awake, as if four in the morning were a time she kept for exactly this.

"Catherine Bell."

"Catherine Bell the lawyer? At four in the morning?"

"Catherine Bell the lawyer at any hour a person is desperate enough to call. You are desperate at four, which tells me the court date is close and the other side is confident. Name?"

"Marlo Hart. I was given your card by... by a customer."

"By Elias Marchetti," Catherine Bell said, not as a question. "He does not give my card to customers, Mrs. Hart. He gives it to very few people at all. Come at nine. Bring everything. And I mean everything: the petition exactly as served, every message between you and your ex-husband that you have ever kept, the doctor's letters, the hospital correspondence, your bank statements, all of it, in whatever untidy form it exists. Do not tidy it. People tidy away the truth."

The office was above the harbor, all glass and morning, with gulls working the wind below the windows and the water going iron-gray out to the islands. Catherine Bell was in her fifties, silver-haired, with sharp eyes that took in Marlo's coat, her folder, her sleeplessness, and filed all three without comment. She made coffee with the air of a woman performing a necessary ritual and no small talk whatsoever, and then she sat and read the petition in silence.

It took a long time. Marlo sat through it the way she had sat outside the principal's office as a girl, watching a face for weather.

"This is aggressive," Catherine said at last. "Understand me. Aggressive is not the same as strong. But it is carefully built, and you should know that. He has a story, Mrs. Hart. In his story you are an unstable woman who stole his child, obstructed his fatherhood for three years, and let a correctable heart condition become an emergency because you would not accept help. It is a well-made story. Parts of it are going to be painful to hear out loud."

"None of it is true."

"I did not say it was true. I said it was built." She turned a page with one finger. "Now. We take it apart, brick by brick, with documents. Tell me about the sixth birthday."

"He did not come. He sent a card ten days later with the wrong age on the cake." It came out of Marlo in a rush, three years of it. The messages she had kept, all of them, saved in a phone she could not afford to replace partly because the phone was the evidence. Preston promising to visit and cancelling. Preston promising money for the cardiologist and going quiet. Preston, the week the surgeon explained the six weeks and the deposit, writing I will help eventually, and then nothing, for fifty-one days, while Marlo read the hospital's deposit letter at the kitchen table every night like a psalm.

News in the same category

She Grabbed a Stranger and Whispered "Just Play Along" - Then Her Ex's Lawyer Heard His Name and Went White

30 Part