She Had Seven Dollars to Hire a Biker. By Nightfall, an Entire Motorcycle Club Was Standing Outside Her Mother’s Door

Chapter 12

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Four."

Ethan slowly lowered the photograph.

Something was wrong.

He could feel it.

Not one isolated inconsistency, but a pattern of missing pieces that seemed to form a shape whenever he looked at them from a different angle.

Samuel had survived Iraq.

He had kept evidence against Adrian Vale.

He had secretly watched Ethan for years.

He had photographed Lily shortly before the supposed accident.

He had written that he could not save her.

And now Claire was saying that Samuel had taken her in when she was four years old.

Ethan looked at her.

"Do you have any childhood photographs?"

"Some."

"Could you show me?"

Claire seemed uncertain, but she nodded.

She crossed to the dresser and opened the bottom drawer.

Inside lay several old albums, a collection of letters, and a small wooden box.

She removed the first album and opened it on the bed.

The early photographs showed a little girl with dark hair and round cheeks.

Claire at three.

Claire at four.

Claire standing beside Samuel's old truck.

Claire holding a stuffed rabbit.

The photographs continued through her childhood.

But something was missing.

There were no hospital photographs.

No birthday pictures before the age of four.

No images of Claire as a newborn.

No photographs of her mother.

The first records began abruptly, as if her life had started in the middle of a story.

Ethan looked at the dates.

"Do you remember anything before you were four?"

Claire shook her head slowly.

"Not much."

"What do you remember?"

She thought for a long time.

"A yellow kitchen."

Ethan looked up.

"What?"

"A kitchen. I remember a yellow wall. There was a little table near the window."

She touched her forehead.

"I remember a man kneeling beside a bicycle."

Ethan's heart began to pound.

"What man?"

"I don't know."

"Was he your father?"

"I don't know."

"Claire, think carefully."

She closed her eyes.

"I remember a song."

"What song?"

"I don't know the words."

Her voice began to tremble.

"But I remember someone singing it."

Ethan looked at Ray.

Ray had gone very still.

Claire opened her eyes.

"I remember coins."

"What?"

"Someone put coins in my hand. I think I was paying for something."

Ethan felt the room tilt.

A bicycle.

A yellow kitchen.

Three coins.

His daughter's memory.

He had spent years believing that Lily's childhood had ended with the funeral.

But perhaps it had not.

Perhaps the memories had simply been hidden somewhere neither he nor Claire had known how to reach.

He sat beside her.

"Claire, what was your birthday?"

"June fourteenth."

Ethan's face changed.

Lily had been born on June fourteenth.

Claire noticed his reaction.

"What?"

Ethan could not answer.

Ray took the album and examined the earliest photograph.

The date on the back was twenty years old.

Claire was standing beside Samuel beneath the pecan tree.

She looked about four.

There was a small scar near her left eyebrow.

Ethan remembered that scar.

Lily had received it when she fell against the edge of a wooden table while learning to walk.

He had been there.

He had carried her to the kitchen sink and held a damp cloth against the cut.

Rachel had told him not to panic.

Lily had cried for five minutes and then demanded ice cream.

Ethan stared at the photograph.

He could not explain the scar.

He could not explain the birthday.

He could not explain the bicycle or the yellow kitchen.

But the possibility forming in his mind was so terrible that he could barely stand to consider it.

"What if," he whispered, "the child who died wasn't Lily?"

Claire turned toward him.

"What?"

Ethan shook his head.

"No."

Ray looked at him.

"Ethan."

"No. I saw the funeral."

"Did you see her face?"

Ethan went silent.

The casket had been closed.

He had been told that the injuries were too severe.

He had been drinking heavily at the time. He remembered the funeral in fragments: rain on the church windows, Rachel sitting in the front row, the minister's voice, his own hands trembling as he tried to light a cigarette outside.

He remembered the casket.

He remembered the flowers.

He remembered the terrible certainty that his daughter was gone.

He did not remember seeing her face.

He had never seen her face.

Ray spoke carefully.

"Who identified the body?"

Ethan looked away.

"Rachel."

"Was anyone else there?"

"I don't know."

"Did the hospital give you records?"

"I don't remember."

"Ethan."

He stood and walked to the window.

Outside, the pecan tree moved gently in the wind.

The land stretched beyond it, quiet and ordinary.

He wanted to reject the possibility.

He wanted to put the photograph back in the box, close the lid, and return to the life he had known that morning.

But the evidence was there.

Samuel had known Lily.

Samuel had kept her photograph.

Samuel had written that she was safe.

News in the same category

She Had Seven Dollars to Hire a Biker. By Nightfall, an Entire Motorcycle Club Was Standing Outside Her Mother’s Door

45 Part