The woman standing before him in a faded calico dress had done better, cleaner, and more precise work than half the seasoned trappers who had passed through Redemption Creek in the last decade.
“Where are you coming from, Mrs. Fletcher?” Chester asked slowly.
“Cottonwood Bend,” she replied without hesitation. “About forty miles north, up the Pecos.”
Chester’s bushy gray eyebrows rose a fraction of an inch. “That’s hard country, ma’am. Comanche range, mostly. Full of scrub brush, bad water, and rock.”
“I know.”
“You trapped those cold waters alone?”
For half a second—a tiny fraction of a moment that vanished almost before it could be registered—something passed through Catherine’s clear green eyes. It was not fear. It was not weakness. It was the dark, heavy shadow of memory.
“My husband trapped with me,” she said, her voice remaining perfectly steady. “Until last fall.”
She paused, taking a slow, deep breath through her nose.
“He died in November.”
The heavy store became entirely quiet. Outside, the distant ringing of Elijah Miller’s hammer seemed to fade away into the vast, open silence of the prairie.
Agnes Billings took a step forward, her hands folded tightly over her apron. “Fever?” she asked, her voice dropping into a soft, sympathetic murmur.
Catherine looked at Agnes. Her gaze was direct, cool, and entirely unyielding.
“Yes.”
Agnes lowered her eyes, uncomfortable beneath the intensity of that steady stare.
Catherine did not lower her eyes. She did not look away. She stood beside the counter with the expression of a woman who had already wept every single tear she intended strangers to see, and had left the rest buried beneath the frozen soil of Cottonwood Bend.
Chester cleared his throat, breaking the heavy tension that had settled over the pine floorboards.
“I can give you the standard local rate for the beaver and the otter,” Chester said, pulling a brass-bound ledger from beneath the counter. “Four dollars a skin for the beaver, five for the otter. Cash down. But the mountain lion hide is another matter entirely. Hides this clean are rare. I know a high-end fur buyer down in San Antonio who caters to wealthy eastern collectors. He may pay near double if the pelt reaches him in this exact condition.”
Catherine looked at him carefully. “How long?”
“Three weeks,” Chester estimated, dipping his steel nib pen into an inkwell. “Perhaps four, depending on when the freight wagon rolls through.”
“And your commission?”
Chester nearly smiled. Most people who came into his store asked what the hide was worth to them right now, eager to grab a fistful of silver and spend it at the saloon. Catherine didn't ask what she would get; she asked what he would take.
“Ten percent,” Chester said.
“Seven.”
Behind them, Hector Monroe coughed violently into his fist to hide a sharp burst of laughter.
Chester folded his heavy arms over his canvas apron, leaning his broad chest against the edge of the counter. “Nine.”
“Eight,” Catherine said instantly, her eyes not flicking once. “And I will bring you six more beaver pelts and two prime otter before the end of June.”
Chester stared at her for three long seconds. Then he threw his head back and laughed—a rich, boisterous sound that filled the high-ceilinged store. He reached across the mountain lion hide and extended his large, calloused hand.
“Mrs. Fletcher, you negotiate like a Fort Worth cattle broker.”
“Catherine Fletcher,” she corrected him softly, wrapping her fingers around his hand. Her grip was surprisingly firm, dry, and strong. “Eight percent.”
“Eight percent it is,” Chester agreed, turning to his cash drawer.
He counted out the silver coins for the beaver and otter skins, laying the shiny silver dollars in neat stacks of five on the smooth pine surface. Catherine did not pick them up immediately. She picked up each heavy silver piece individually, weighed it on her palm, checked the edge, and counted the total twice.
Only when she was completely satisfied did she sweep the silver into a leather draw-string pouch. From her skirt pocket, she produced a folded piece of rough brown wrapping paper, smoothed it flat against the counter with the heel of her hand, and pushed it toward Chester.
“I need supplies,” she said.
Chester put on his spectacles and read the sharp, clear script written in charcoal on the paper:
Cornmeal — 50 lbs.
Dried pintos — 30 lbs.
Green coffee beans — 10 lbs.
Coarse rock salt — 20 lbs.
Hemp rope — 50 feet.
Clean beeswax — 2 blocks.
Triangular sharpening file — 2.
Kerosene oil — 2 gallons.
Quinine sulfate — 1 bottle.
Chester scanned down to the very bottom of the list. His eyes stopped on the last line.
Two boxes .44-caliber centerfire rifle cartridges.
Chester looked up over the rims of his spectacles, his blue eyes narrowing slightly. “Winchester?”
“Model Seventy-Three,” she answered smoothly.
“You expecting trouble out at Cottonwood Bend, Mrs. Fletcher?”
“I live forty miles from the nearest law, Mr. Callaway.”
“That wasn’t an answer.”
Catherine’s thin, pale lips twitched at the corner, almost—but not quite—curving into a quiet smile.
“It was enough of one,” she said.
Agnes Billings, who had been watching Catherine’s every move with growing fascination and horror, could hold her curiosity no longer. She smoothed her skirt and stepped all the way to the counter.
“You truly live out there alone?” Agnes asked, her voice high with disbelief. “In that wild country?”
“I do.”
“No family?”
“None nearby.”
“No children?”
Catherine’s busy fingers stopped dead on the edge of the supply list.
The warmth in the room vanished. The soft light catching her auburn hair seemed to turn cold. For two long heartbeats, she did not move, her hand frozen against the paper, her breath catching silently in her throat.
Catherine did not look up at Agnes Billings.
She kept her eyes fixed on the handwritten supply list, her thumb rubbing mechanically against the rough fiber of the paper.
“I had a son,” Catherine said. Her voice was flat, hollowed out of all tone, like water running over dry sand. “He would have been four years old this past spring. He died of the scarlet croup three winters ago.”
Agnes gasped, her hand flying to her throat. “Oh... oh, my dear Lord... I am so sorry...”
“Don't be,” Catherine said softly, her eyes finally rising to meet Agnes’s panicked, pitying gaze. “The ground in the canyon was frozen two feet deep. My husband and I had to break it with an iron pick and firewood. Pity doesn't soften hard ground, ma’am. And it doesn't bring back small boys.”
She turned back to Chester, her posture instantly re-stiffening into iron. “I’ll need those supplies loaded onto my pack mule, Mr. Callaway. How long will it take you to put the order together?”
Chester looked at the list, then at the strong, unbroken woman standing before him. He felt a deep, quiet ache in his chest—a profound respect for a soul that had been hammered on the anvil of the wilderness and had refused to shatter.
“Give me twenty minutes, Mrs. Fletcher,” Chester said gently. “I’ll have my boy Tommy haul the sacks out to your animal and tie them down tight.”
“Thank you. I have business at the land office down the street.”
She gathered her leather coin pouch, slipped her bone-handled knife back into her skirt pocket, and pulled her brown felt hat lower over her eyes. Without another word to anyone in the store, she turned and stepped out onto the sunlit boardwalk, the brass bell ringing once behind her.
Deputy Roy Sutter watched her walk past the front glass window. He waited until her horse and mule were tethered securely before turning to Chester.
“She’s out of her mind,” Sutter muttered, spitting a bit of biscuit crust onto the floorboards near the stove. “A lone woman livin’ up at Cottonwood Bend? That’s pure insanity, Chester. Silas Vance and his brothers have been grazing their cattle up along the Pecos bottomlands since March. Vance claims everything north of the Little Red River.”
Chester stopped fetching a fifty-pound sack of cornmeal from the back storage rack. He turned his head, his eyes cold behind his spectacles.
“Silas Vance doesn't own Cottonwood Bend, Roy,” Chester said sharply. “That land was homesteaded by Thomas Fletcher four years ago. He filed the paperwork in Austin himself. I saw the yellowed receipt with my own eyes.”