She Walked Into Her Neighbor’s House Over a Leaf Blower — Then the Officer Asked Her to Put Her Hands Behind Her Back

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

It was a Saturday, and Nancy had been on the phone with her daughter Laura — Laura in Oak Park, who worried, who called every other day now — and the blower had started up mid-sentence, and Laura had said, "What's that noise?" with a laugh, and Nancy had felt something heat up in her chest. She had walked over without the muffins.

"You're making too much noise," Nancy had said. "There's a rule about excessive noise in the community guidelines."

Elena had been wearing hearing protection, the orange earmuff kind, pushed up on her head like a crown. She had said, "The equipment rules say eight p.m. It's four-thirty."

"There's also a paragraph about noise that's excessive or persistent," Nancy had said, and she had been proud of the word persistent, the way it landed. She had looked it up.

"Then contact the board," Elena had said. She hadn't been rude. That was the terrible thing — she hadn't been rude at all. She had been finished. "The board can tell me if I'm breaking a rule."

Nancy had gone home and read the community guidelines twice, pencil in hand. She found the paragraph about equipment hours — quiet hours beginning at 8 PM — and the paragraph about excessive or persistent noise, and she underlined both in different colors, feeling the particular satisfaction of a person holding a document that proved something.

She called Richard Coleman on a Tuesday morning. Richard was the board president, a retired bank manager, a man whose diplomacy was so well practiced it sometimes took a full minute to realize he hadn't answered your question. He agreed to meet her in the community room.

"Nancy," he said, folding his hands, "I understand the blower is a frustration."

"It's not a frustration, Richard. It's a violation." She had the guidelines with her, tabbed. She read the noise paragraph aloud.

Richard nodded the way he did, the slow nod that meant I hear you and also please continue so I can hear all of it before I say no. "I've looked into this," he said. "The equipment-hours rule permits gas blowers until eight p.m. The noise paragraph — and I checked with the management company on this — is written for sustained disturbances. The blower at Unit 58 runs for ten, fifteen minutes at a stretch, during the day. That's within the rule as it's written."

"But it's excessive," Nancy said. "Several times a week—"

"I hear you," Richard said, and this time the nod was shorter, and Nancy understood that the hearing was almost over. "What I'd suggest — and this is just my suggestion, neighbor to neighbor — is that you talk to her calmly, directly. People respond to that more than they respond to the board. And if you believe an actual law is being broken — a noise ordinance, say — the proper channel is the non-emergency police line. They can tell you where the line is."

The proper channel. Nancy had seized on those three words the way a person seizes a handrail. She had said thank you, and Richard had said, "Anytime, Nancy, that's what we're here for," and she had walked home believing that the board had confirmed she was right — that somewhere, in some channel, the complaint would be received and honored. She did not remember the part about the blower being within the rule. Or rather, she remembered it the way one remembers a sentence read in a language one is still learning: the shapes were there, but the meaning had not taken.

She began the surveillance log that week. It was not called that, of course. It was called "Notes," dated like lab entries.

Sunday, 4:42 p.m. — 14 min.

Monday, 10:15 a.m. — 12 min.

Tuesday, 12:04 p.m. — 12 min.

The blower had a schedule, or Elena did, or the leaves did — whatever the cause, Nancy learned its rhythm the way she had once learned the rhythm of her classroom. The knowledge did not calm her. Knowledge, Nancy was discovering, was not the same as control, and the gap between the two had begun to itch.

The week of the confrontation was a bad week in other ways, the kind of week that arrives already tired. The terrier in Unit 44 had found a new squirrel. The bread truck had come at 6:20 instead of 6:40, as if personally offended by the concept of consistency. And on Sunday morning — the Sunday — Harold fell in the bathroom.

Nancy had been making tea. She heard the sound first: not a crash, exactly, but a wrongness, a thump followed by a sharp intake of breath, and then Harold's voice, thin and furious, saying, "I'm fine," before she had even asked.

He was on the tile, one hand on the edge of the tub, his right leg folded under him at an angle that made her stomach drop. Eight months since the stroke. Eight months of the walker, the exercises, the right side that lagged half a beat behind the left. He had been getting better. That was what Laura said, and the physical therapist, and the doctor with the kind eyes.

"You need the walker," Nancy said.

"I don't need the walker in my own bathroom."

"You fell."

"I slipped. There's a difference, and you know it."

They had sold the house outside Evanston seven months ago — thirty-two years of house, the garden Harold had built bed by bed, the workshop with the pegboard wall — because Laura had said, "Mom, what if something happens," and Nancy had said, "Nothing's going to happen," and then something had happened, the stroke, the hospital with its beeping nights, and Laura had said it again, and this time Nancy had listened. Hawthorne Ridge was supposed to be the answer. One floor. Grab bars. Neighbors close by. It was supposed to be easier.

Nancy got the walker. Harold refused it, pulling himself up on the towel bar with his good arm, his jaw set in the particular line it took when he had decided to be impossible.

"Should I call Laura?" Nancy asked.

"Absolutely not." He said it the way he said most things now: flat, final, with a dryness that could have been humor once. "I'm not calling my daughter because I sat down too fast in the bathroom."

"You fell, Harold."

"I reclined unexpectedly. There's a difference."

She made him sit at the kitchen table. She made tea she didn't drink. She checked his hip, his head, his right hand, which he held out for inspection with the exaggerated patience of a man tolerating a nurse he had not requested. Nothing broken. Nothing bleeding. Just the fall, and the refusal, and the walker standing in the hallway like an accusation.

Nancy did what she always did when her nerves were scraped raw: she made order. She wiped the counter. She put the tea things away. She turned on the radio, low, the classical station, and sat with her second cup and looked out at the courtyard, where the maple at Unit 58 was shedding in the October wind.

At 5:03, the blower started.

She knew it was 5:03 because she looked at the clock — the clock above the stove, the one Harold had hung slightly crooked and she had never straightened, because some things you leave alone. The motor caught, sputtered, caught again, and settled into its whine: that high, insectile pitch that rose and fell as Elena worked the patio, herding leaves into piles.

News in the same category

She Walked Into Her Neighbor’s House Over a Leaf Blower — Then the Officer Asked Her to Put Her Hands Behind Her Back

20 Part