Sheriff Tried to Shut Down Their Charity Run — Hells Angels Struck Back Brutally

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The sheriff's lawyer's name was Paul Mercer, and he spoke the way men speak when they have been given a difficult case and a short time to prepare it: quickly, and with more confidence than the papers in front of him could support.

Your Honor, Mercer said, "the sheriff's office acted on credible gang threat intelligence received in good faith. The decision was made to protect public safety. The county cannot be expected to wait for a tragedy before it acts."

Judge Whitfield did not interrupt. He let Mercer speak for several minutes, his eyes on the file, his pen resting on the desk. When Mercer finally stopped, the judge looked up.

Mr. Mercer, he said, "you have used the word credible three times. I would like to see the credibility. Produce the threat."

Mercer hesitated. He opened his own folder, turned two pages, and lifted a single sheet of paper.

This is the tip, Your Honor, he said. "It was received anonymously. It states that the ride would be used as cover for gang activity."

Whitfield took the paper, read it, and set it down with a care that was more damning than any anger would have been.

Three sentences, he said. "No name. No date. No place. No act. Is there anything else? A report? A witness statement? A prior incident?"

Mercer cleared his throat again.

The county also relies on the public record, Your Honor. The television coverage of the club's activities has raised legitimate concern.

Television coverage, Whitfield repeated, flatly.

Yes, Your Honor. A clip was shown on the evening news.

Chen stood, but the judge raised a hand, and Chen sat again without a word.

Mr. Mercer, Whitfield said, "is the county's position that a news clip, edited for broadcast, is a substitute for evidence in this court?"

It is part of the context, Your Honor.

It is not evidence, Whitfield said. "It is not a witness. It cannot be cross-examined. It cannot be sworn. If the county wishes to rely on it, the county may call the person who filmed it, and the person who edited it, and the person who decided what to leave out. Until then, I will treat it as what it is: a clip."

The room was very quiet. Mark Jensen, in the back, wrote faster, his pen scratching across the page, and Jack could see the man's shoulders rise slightly, as if he were trying not to lean forward.

Whitfield turned another page in the file, and then another, and the silence stretched until it became a thing in itself.

Mr. Mercer, he said at last, "I have read the revocation file in full. I have read your response. I have read Mr. Chen's petition and its exhibits. I find no incident report. I find no arrest record. I find no prior revocation. I find nine years of clean operation, and I find a fax, sent thirty minutes before the clerk opened, revoking a permit for four hundred riders, for medical stations, for a highway route, for a children's fund, without a hearing."

He looked at Mercer, and his voice did not rise, but it hardened.

Is that how the county now revokes permits, Mr. Mercer? By fax, without a hearing, on the strength of three anonymous sentences?

Mercer opened his mouth, closed it, and opened it again.

The sheriff acted in good faith, Your Honor.

Good faith is not a substitute for a record, Whitfield said. "And a record is what this court requires."

Whitfield leaned back in his chair and looked at Mercer for a long moment, and the courtroom seemed to grow quieter still, as if the walls themselves were listening.

Mr. Mercer, he said, "let me tell you what troubles me, so that you may address it directly. I am troubled by the time. Thirty minutes. That is how long it took, by your own account, for this office to receive a tip, assess it, decide that it was credible, draft a revocation, fax it to the clerk, and send copies to the state highway patrol. Thirty minutes, for a decision that cancels nine years of lawful operation. I have seen judges take longer to decide a parking dispute."

Mercer flushed.

Your Honor, in an emergency—

Was there an emergency, Mr. Mercer? Whitfield interrupted, and his voice was still even, but there was steel under it now. "Was there a rider on the road? Was there a crowd gathering? Was there a threat made, in person, to a named person, at a named place, at a named time? Or was there a fax, sent before sunrise, on a Tuesday morning, when the people it affected were still asleep?"

Mercer looked down at his papers, and Jack could see the man's hands trembling slightly, and he felt, unexpectedly, a flicker of sympathy for him, because Mercer had not written the fax, and he had not made the decision, and he was standing in a courtroom trying to defend a record that would not defend itself.

There was no incident on the road, Your Honor, Mercer said, quietly.

Thank you, Whitfield said. "That is an honest answer, and I appreciate it. Honesty is the beginning of a record, even when the record itself is thin."

He turned to Chen.

Mr. Chen, is there anything further you wish to add before I make my order?

Chen stood.

Only this, Your Honor, he said. "The petitioners have complied with every condition the county has ever set. They have filed their roster. They have filed their route. They have filed their medical plan. They have done so, year after year, without being asked twice. They ask only to be judged by that compliance, and not by a clip on a television, and not by a fax sent in the dark."

News in the same category

Sheriff Tried to Shut Down Their Charity Run — Hells Angels Struck Back Brutally

45 Part