She looked into the fire.
"He used to bring me small gifts. A feather, a smooth stone, a piece of colored glass from a trader's wagon. He said each one was worth keeping because it reminded him of something."
"What did he give you last?"
"A blue stone. He found it near the river."
"Do you still have it?"
Atsila nodded.
She reached beneath her clothing and drew out a small leather pouch. From it, she took a smooth blue stone, no larger than the end of Maren's thumb.
The stone caught the firelight.
"He gave it to me the morning before he left."
"Where was he going?"
"He had heard that some men were stealing horses from camps farther south. He wanted to help find them. My mother told him not to go, but he said he would return before the next moon."
"And he never came back?"
"No."
Maren studied the stone.
"How long ago?"
"Almost two years."
He leaned back.
Two years was a long time. Long enough for a person to travel across several territories, disappear into unfamiliar country, or die without anyone knowing where to look.
But it was not proof of death.
"Did anyone search for him?"
"My mother sent men along the river. They found tracks, but the trail was confused. There had been many horses passing through. Later, people said he had gone north. Others said he had been taken by soldiers."
"Did you believe that?"
"I believed whatever allowed me to keep looking."
She closed her fingers around the stone.
"When they took me, I asked about him. The men laughed. One said they knew a young Apache who had caused trouble. Another said he was working for them."
Maren's attention sharpened.
"Working for them?"
"That is what he said. But I did not believe him."
"Why?"
"Chayton would never willingly help men who hurt our people."
"People can be forced to work."
"I know."
She lowered her gaze.
"Perhaps that is what happened."
Maren considered the possibility. A young man taken from his family might be threatened, beaten, or made to guide strangers through country he knew better than they did. It would explain why the men had used the blue cloth.
But there was another possibility.
They had simply learned her brother's name and discovered that it was the easiest way to make her obey.
"Tomorrow," he said, "we'll look at the tracks again. The men who left the cloth may have approached from the same direction as the rider."
Atsila nodded.
"And if we find something?"
"Then we'll decide what it means."
She slipped the blue stone back into its pouch.
"I want to believe he is alive."
"I know."
"I have tried not to hope. It hurts too much."
Maren looked at the fire.
"Hope can hurt. But so can giving it up."
For a while, neither spoke.
The next morning, Maren found Atsila already outside.
She stood near the gate, studying the ground around the fence. The blue strip of cloth was gone.
He approached quietly.
"Where is it?"
"I removed it."
"Why?"
"I thought about what you said."
She glanced toward the open desert.
"If they wanted me to see it, I have seen it. Leaving it there will not make it more true."
Maren nodded.
"Good."
She held out the cloth.
He examined it carefully. The material was old, but the cut was clean. It might have come from a sash, a shirt, or a piece of blanket.
"Do you recognize the weave?" he asked.
"Yes. It is the kind of cloth my mother bought from traders. Chayton's sash was made from it."
"That doesn't prove it belonged to him."
"No."
She said it firmly, as though repeating the words would make them easier to accept.
Maren put the cloth in his pocket.
"We'll keep it."
They spent the morning following the tracks around the cabin.
The first horse had approached from the east, as Maren had discovered the night before. Its prints were faint, but the direction was clear. The rider had come along a dry wash, crossed the rocky ground near the fence, and left by the same route.
The second set of tracks was harder to follow.
Atsila found them near a cluster of juniper trees.
"Here."
Maren crouched beside her.
The hoofprints were shallow, partly erased by wind. One horse had stood among the trees for some time. There were marks where its front hooves had shifted in the sand.
The rider had been waiting.
"How long?" Atsila asked.
"Long enough to watch the cabin."
She moved around the tree.
"Look here."
A small depression marked the ground beneath a low branch. Maren brushed away the loose sand and uncovered a fragment of tobacco paper.
He held it between two fingers.
"American tobacco."
"Does that tell you anything?"
"It tells me the rider was smoking."
Atsila looked unimpressed.
He smiled slightly.
"Sometimes the smallest things matter. The paper is dry, but the ground beneath it is damp. It may have been dropped recently."
He turned it over.
There was a dark stain along one edge.
"Blood?" she asked.
"Possibly."
Maren placed the fragment in his pocket beside the blue cloth.
They continued east.
The wash narrowed between two rocky slopes. Beyond it, the land opened into a broad basin scattered with stones and dry shrubs. A few miles away, the mountains formed a broken line against the sky.
Atsila stopped.
"What is it?" Maren asked.
She pointed toward the ground.
A small mark had been pressed into the dust. It looked like a boot heel, but the shape was unusual. The heel had a square notch near one edge.
Maren examined it.
"I've seen this before."
"Where?"
"On the man who came to the cabin."
"You recognized his boots?"
"I noticed the heel when he stepped off his horse. There was a piece missing."
Atsila studied the print.
"Then he came here."
"Or another man wears the same kind of boot."
She looked at him.
"You always find a reason not to believe what is in front of you."
The words were not spoken angrily, but they struck him.
Maren rose slowly.
"Sometimes what is in front of us is exactly what someone wants us to believe."
"And sometimes it is simply the truth."
He had no immediate answer.
She turned and walked farther into the basin.
Maren followed.
Near a low ridge, they found a place where several horses had gathered. The ground was churned with hoofprints, and a few scraps of grass had been crushed beneath their weight.
Atsila crouched and examined the tracks.
"Five horses."