I am not afraid of you, Evelyn said, and then, because lies helped no one, she added, "Not the way I was. I am afraid of what you will do to other people if I give you what you want. That is not the same thing."
Pike studied her for a long moment. Outside, a wagon passed, and the sound of its wheels seemed very far away. "I want the original ledger," he said. "Not your copies. The book itself. The one you and Roark took from my safe. Bring it to me, or have Roark bring it to me, and this ends here. You walk out of this room. Your father keeps what is left of his name. The town goes back to being quiet."
And if I refuse? Evelyn asked.
Then you stay here, Pike said. "And your father learns what it feels like to watch someone he loves pay for his silence, twice. And Roark learns that there are places even a fast gun cannot walk into without starting a war in the middle of town."
Evelyn looked down at the hands holding her wrists. Brannan's grip was steady. Tanner's fingers trembled slightly. She thought of the ledger, heavy and real, hidden now where Pike could not reach it. She thought of the copies in their oilcloth bundle, smoke-stained from the church fire, and of the pages she had copied by lantern light over so many nights, her hand cramping, her heart hammering every time a floorboard creaked in the jailhouse above her. She thought of Tomas Herrera, who had lost his land. She thought of Jonah Pierce, arrested on a charge that had never been true. She thought of Eli Calloway, who had vanished three years ago, and of Ruth standing on the plaza that morning with her head up while Pike tried to sell her home out from under her.
No, she said.
Pike's expression did not change. "You will think again," he said. "You have until nightfall to think again. After that, I stop asking nicely."
He turned to Brannan. "Keep her here. No one comes in except her father or Roark, and if Roark comes, he comes without that gun in his hand or he does not come in at all." He looked back at Evelyn once more. "Your father sat in this room once and watched, Miss Mercer. Do not count on him to be braver tonight than he was then."
The door closed behind him, and the jailhouse settled into its familiar smells and its unfamiliar quiet. Evelyn sat very still between the two men, her wrists held, her papers scattered on the desk where her father's papers had always been scattered, and she waited. She did not cry. She did not beg. She counted her own breaths and listened for boots on the step, and she told herself, again and again, that the town had already changed once that day, on the plaza, in the open, where everyone could see it. It could change again.
Outside, the sun sank lower, and the shadows in the jailhouse grew long across the floor.
Amos Mercer found out the way bad news always found him in that town: a boy running, a door left open, a sentence spoken too fast on the street. He had been at the back of the store with Abe Whitfield, trying to look like a sheriff doing sheriff's work, when young Ben Calloway came in, breathless, his hat in his hands. Ben had seen Pike's men take Evelyn toward the jailhouse. He had seen the door close. He had run the whole way.
Amos did not ask Ben to repeat himself. He thanked the boy, told him to go straight back to his mother and stay there, and walked out into the heat with his boots loud on the boards. Whitfield called after him, but Amos did not turn. For years, he had turned away from hard things. He had turned away from Pike's first envelope of money, telling himself it was for Clara's medicine, and then he had turned away from the second and the third, telling himself it was for peace. He had turned away from the ledger, from the arrests, from the men who vanished, and finally, worst of all, he had turned away from his own daughter while she sat on his desk and begged him to help her.
He was not going to turn away this time. He did not know, as he walked, whether that made him brave or merely late. He knew only that his legs kept moving toward the jailhouse, and that his hands, which had shaken for years whenever Pike entered a room, were steady now in a way that frightened him almost as much as Pike did.
The jailhouse door was shut. Tanner stood outside it, leaning against the frame with his hand near his gun, trying to look casual and failing. When he saw Amos, his face tightened.
Sheriff, Tanner said. "Mr. Pike said nobody goes in."
This is my jailhouse, Amos said. His voice came out rough, as if he had not used it properly in a long time. "And that is my daughter in there. Step aside, Jeb."
Tanner did not move. "Mr. Pike will be angry."
Mr. Pike has been angry at me for years, Amos said. "I have been afraid of his anger for years. I am done being afraid of it today."