bring a dozen men up the slope with picks and shovels and to keep them working through the summers. But the silver had run out by 1879, and the men had gone down the mountain one by one, and the mine had been left open, with its timbers standing and its shaft going down sixty feet into the dark, and the man before him had stayed on at the station, because the station was his living, and the mine was only a hole in the ground behind it.
In the autumn of 1880, the man had gone down into the mine. Ezra did not know for certain why he had gone down. The mail carrier, who had brought the news up the mountain that winter, had said the man had gone down to fetch a set of tools he had left below, and the storekeeper in the town below had said he had gone down to shore up a timber he thought was giving way, and the truth was probably a little of both, because a man who has lived beside a hole in the ground for six years goes down into it for reasons that seem plain enough to him at the time. What was certain was that he had gone down in the late afternoon, and that he had not come back up, and that when the mail carrier came through three days later and found the station empty, he had gone to the mouth of the shaft and called down into it, and no one had answered.
Ezra had not been there. He had come to Spruce Hollow in the spring of 1881, six months after the man died, and he had taken the station because the county had no one else to keep it, and because he had nowhere else to go. The man's things were still in the station when Ezra arrived: his coat on a peg by the door, his pipe on the shelf, his ledger on the table, open to the last page he had written. Ezra had read that last page, and he had never forgotten it. The man had written down the weather, and the travelers who had come through that week, and the money he had taken in, and then, at the bottom of the page, in the same plain hand, he had written: *The timber in the shaft is rotten. I will go down tomorrow and look at it.* He had gone down the next day, and the timber had given way under him, and he had fallen sixty feet to the bottom of the shaft, and the water that stood at the bottom of the shaft in the spring had been standing there in the autumn too, cold and black, and he had drowned in it before anyone knew he was gone.
Beatrice listened to all of it without speaking, and when Ezra had finished, she looked at the stove, and then she looked at the floor, and then she looked at him, and she said that she was sorry, and that she had not known, and that the man had deserved better than to die alone in the dark. Ezra nodded, and he said that the man had deserved better, and that he had thought about it every winter since, because the winter was when the shaft spoke loudest, and the winter was when a man had time to think about the dead.
After that night, Beatrice understood something she had not understood before. The mine was not only a hole in the ground. It was a place where a man had died, and it was a thing Ezra had lived beside for nine years without telling anyone about it, because there had been no one to tell, and because telling it would not have changed anything. He had kept the station, and he had kept the mine's secret, and he had kept the road open for travelers, and he had done it all alone, year after year, and now she was here, and she knew it too, and the knowing of it was a thing they shared, whether they had chosen to share it or not.
The shaft groaned in the cold. That was the other thing the winter taught her. On the coldest nights, when the temperature dropped until the air itself seemed to crack, the timbers in the shaft would shift and settle, and the sound would come up through the ground and through the floorboards of the back room, a low groaning that rose and fell like a thing breathing. The first time she heard it, she sat straight up