“Some are. Some are caused by employees learning the new system.”
“Then we fix the training.”
Thomas nodded.
“Richard believes the company should suspend several changes until the next financial quarter.”
Marcus looked at Rachel.
“What do you think?”
“I think he is trying to preserve the old system under a different name.”
Marcus was silent.
He had hoped that the lesson from Victor's branch would be understood without another confrontation.
But organizations rarely changed simply because their leaders announced that change was necessary.
People who benefited from the old system often found ways to preserve it.
Sometimes they did so openly.
More often, they described their resistance as practical management.
Marcus closed the folder.
“Invite Richard to the board meeting.”
Thomas looked surprised.
“Tomorrow?”
“Yes.”
“Do you want to discuss this with him privately first?”
“No.”
Marcus stood.
“I want everyone to hear the same facts.”
Richard Coleman arrived at headquarters the following afternoon wearing a charcoal suit and a confident smile.
He greeted several board members before entering the conference room.
He shook Marcus's hand.
“Marcus. Good to see you.”
“Richard.”
“I've been hoping we could discuss the reform program.”
“We will.”
Richard took his seat.
He placed a leather notebook in front of him and opened it.
The board chairman, William Prescott, called the meeting to order.
The first agenda item concerned the independent investigation.
Patricia Morgan presented an updated summary.
The investigation had identified misconduct or procedural failures in twelve branches.
The company had received 186 customer complaints requiring additional review.
Forty-one had been improperly classified.
Twenty-three customers had experienced unnecessary delays involving legitimate transactions.
Nine had incurred fees or financial losses that required reimbursement.
The investigators had also identified several employees who had attempted to report concerns but had not received adequate protection.
Patricia finished.
William looked around the table.
“Questions?”
Richard raised his hand.
“I have a concern.”
William nodded.
“Go ahead.”
Richard adjusted his glasses.
“I fully support the company's commitment to fair customer treatment. Nobody here disagrees with that. But I believe we need to distinguish between genuine misconduct and operational inefficiency.”
Marcus watched him.
Richard continued.
“Banks must manage risk. We cannot treat every customer request as an automatic approval. We have legal obligations. We have fraud exposure. We have regulatory requirements.”
“Agreed,” Marcus said.
Richard nodded.
“Then I think we should be careful not to create an environment where employees are afraid to exercise judgment.”
Marcus leaned forward.
“Are you saying employees are afraid?”
“Some are.”
“Why?”
“Because they believe every decision might become the subject of an investigation.”
Marcus considered the statement.
“Are they being investigated for following policy?”
“Not necessarily.”
“Then what are they afraid of?”
Richard shifted in his chair.
“Complaints.”
Marcus nodded slowly.
“Do you believe customers should be able to complain when they receive poor service?”
“Of course.”
“Do you believe complaints should be documented accurately?”
“Yes.”
“Then why did you instruct regional directors to avoid creating unnecessary documentation?”
Richard's smile disappeared.
He glanced toward William.
“I think that email is being taken out of context.”
Marcus opened his copy.
“Which part?”
“The phrase about avoiding unnecessary documentation.”
Marcus read it aloud.
“Managers should avoid creating unnecessary documentation for routine customer dissatisfaction. Escalate only when there is a clear financial or regulatory consequence.”
He looked up.
“What did you mean?”
Richard folded his hands.
“I was trying to prevent the new system from being overwhelmed.”
“With customer complaints?”
“With minor operational issues.”
“Who decides what is minor?”
“The branch managers.”
“Were they the people we just investigated?”
Richard's jaw tightened.
“Some of them.”
Marcus nodded.
“Then perhaps we should not give them the authority to decide which complaints deserve to exist.”
Several board members exchanged glances.
Richard leaned forward.
“Marcus, I think we're allowing one unfortunate incident to dictate company policy.”
Marcus looked directly at him.
“One unfortunate incident?”
Richard stopped.
Marcus opened another document.
“Victor Salazar's branch received twenty-seven complaints. Twenty-one were altered or improperly closed. Employees were discouraged from helping customers. People were treated differently because of their appearance and financial status.”
He placed another document on the table.
“Then we found similar practices in other branches.”
A third document followed.
“Then we found managers who were rewarded for keeping complaint numbers low.”
Marcus looked around.
“This is not one unfortunate incident. It is a pattern.”
Richard sighed.
“Nobody is defending Victor.”
“Your emails suggest that you're defending the conditions that allowed him to operate.”
“That is not fair.”
“Then explain your instructions.”
Richard looked toward Thomas Avery.
“I'd like legal counsel present.”
Thomas nodded.
“That's your right.”
Richard closed his notebook.
The meeting continued without him.