The drive was the loneliest Rose had ever taken. The city fell away behind her, and the road ran straight and dark toward the river, and there was nothing on it but her own car and the sound of her own breathing. She thought of Nathaniel, following far behind her in the second car with Marcus, out of sight, exactly as they had planned. She thought of Leo, tied and frightened in the dark, waiting for someone to come. She thought of Victoria, and the pistol, and the rooftop where it had all begun. Her hands were steady on the wheel. She was afraid, and she did not hide it from herself, but the fear did not own her. She had been afraid on the rooftop, too, with a woman's weight in her hands and 26 floors of empty air below her, and she had not let go then.
The river appeared on her left, black and wide, and the pier reached out into it like a finger pointing at the dark. She slowed the car, and she stopped at the end of the approach road, and she sat for a moment with the engine running, gathering herself. Then she switched the engine off, and the silence came down around her, and she got out of the car and walked toward the pier alone.
Chapter 12: The Ghost of Pier 44
Pier 44 was a skeleton of rust and rotting wood reaching out into the Hudson. The river moved black and slow beneath it, and the fog came off the water in thin ribbons. The lamps along the pier burned with a sick yellow light, and the city stood behind Rose like a wall of glass and steel, too far away to help.
She stopped the car at the end of the approach road and got out. The wind came off the river and cut through her coat. She walked onto the pier alone, her hands where they could be seen, her shoes loud on the wet boards.
"Leo," she called. "Leo, it is Rose. I am here."
A voice answered her from the dark at the far end of the pier. "Keep walking, maid. Slowly. Hands where I can see them."
Victoria Thorne stepped out of the shadows. She was dressed in black leather, her hair pulled back, her face pale in the lamplight. She held a pistol in her right hand, and the pistol was pointed at Rose's chest. Behind her, at the very end of the pier, was a metal chute, the kind used to load cargo onto boats, and it sloped down from the pier into the black water. Tied to the chute, sitting on the cold metal with his legs dangling, was Leo.
He was 15 years old, and he looked younger in the lamplight, his school jacket soaked through, his hair plastered to his forehead. His hands were tied in front of him, and a rope ran from his waist to the frame of the chute. When he saw Rose, his face broke open.
"Rose!" he cried. "Rose, I am here! I am all right!"
"Hold on, Leo," Rose said. "Hold on. I am here now."
Victoria smiled. It was a thin, cold smile, and it did not reach her eyes. "The maid," she said. "The maid who stole my wedding, my future, my life. You stand there in your dark coat, and you think you are brave. You are not brave. You are a servant who got lucky, and tonight your luck runs out."
"I came alone," Rose said. "Exactly as you asked. Let him go."
"Not yet." Victoria gestured with the pistol toward the chute. "First, you are going to kneel. You are going to kneel on these boards, in front of the boy, and you are going to say it. Say you are nothing. Say you were never anything. Say you stole what was mine and you are sorry."
Rose looked at Leo. He was shaking his head at her, his eyes wide, telling her not to do it. She looked at Victoria. She thought of the rooftop, of Eleanor falling, of the night she had held a woman's dress in her hands and refused to let go.
"I will not kneel to you," Rose said.
Victoria's smile vanished. "Then the boy goes in the water."
She turned the pistol toward Leo, and in that moment, Nathaniel stepped out of the dark behind her.
He had come up the far side of the pier in silence, the way Marcus had taught him, moving through the fog like a shadow. He seized Victoria's gun hand with both of his and twisted it, hard, until the bones in her wrist gave way with a crack that sounded like a dry branch snapping. The pistol clattered to the boards and slid toward the edge.
Victoria screamed. She staggered backward, clutching her broken wrist, and her shoulder struck the frame of the chute. The metal jerked. The rope around Leo's waist slipped, the knot gave way, and the boy slid down the wet metal of the chute and dropped into the black water of the Hudson.
The splash was the loudest sound Rose had ever heard.
"Leo!" she screamed, and she was already running to the edge of the pier, her coat flying behind her, the river rising up to meet her.
Chapter 13: The Unthinkable Choice