Miriam did not answer immediately. She looked out at the city, at the lights below, at the dark sky above, and she held her diamond earring between two fingers, turning it over and over, and I could see her hand trembling, just slightly, in the cold air.
"I remember," she said at last. "And I meant it then, and I mean it now. But happiness built on a lie is not happiness, Verity. It is a house built on sand, and it will fall, and when it falls, it will hurt him more than the truth ever could."
Verity laughed, a short, sharp laugh that did not sound like laughter at all. "You are an old woman," she said. "You do not understand what it takes to build a life in this world. You think the truth is enough. It is not. The truth is a luxury, Miriam, and you cannot afford it any more than I can."
Miriam turned toward the door then, as if she had decided that the conversation was over, as if she had said everything she had come to say, and she took a step toward me, toward the warm light of the corridor, toward safety, and I thought, for a moment, that it was over, that she was going to walk past me and back into the ballroom and that Verity was going to let her go.
She did not.
Verity reached out and grabbed Miriam's arm, her fingers closing around the thin fabric of the dark blue dress, around the thin arm beneath it, and Miriam stopped, and turned, and looked at her, and I could see the shock in her face, the shock of a woman who had not expected to be touched, who had not expected that a conversation would become something else.
"Let go of me," Miriam said, quietly.
"No," Verity said. "Not until you listen to me. Not until you understand."
Miriam tried to pull her arm away, and as she did, her silver bracelet, the one on her left wrist, caught against the edge of the railing, and the clasp cracked against the metal with a bright, sharp sound, a sound that seemed too loud in the cold, quiet air, a sound like a small bell breaking. I saw the bracelet slip, just slightly, and I saw Miriam glance down at it, and I saw Verity's eyes follow hers, and I knew, in that moment, that something had changed, that the conversation was no longer a conversation, that it had become something dangerous.
I was about to speak. I was about to step forward from beside the service planter and say, "Mrs. Whitcomb, is everything all right? Can I help you?" I had the words in my mouth, I had my foot raised to take a step, and then Verity moved, and everything happened too fast for me to stop it.
She put both hands on Miriam Whitcomb's shoulders, both hands, flat against the dark blue dress, against the thin, elderly shoulders beneath it, and she pushed. She pushed hard, with all her strength, with the strength of a young woman in a pearl-white silk dress who had decided, in that moment, that an old woman standing near a railing was an obstacle, and that obstacles could be removed.
For a moment, Miriam seemed to hang against the skyline.
I will never forget that moment, not as long as I live. She did not fall immediately. She seemed, for a single, terrible second, to be suspended in the air, her dark blue dress billowing around her, her white hair catching the light, her hands reaching out, her mouth open, and behind her was the city, the lights, the dark sky, and she looked, in that moment, like a woman who had been lifted up by the wind and was about to be carried away.
Then the bracelet fell.
It fell to the floor of the terrace, the silver catching the light as it fell, landing with a small, bright sound on the cold tiles, and then Miriam disappeared from view.
She did not scream. That is what I remember most, even now, even after everything that happened afterwards. She did not scream. She made a small sound, a gasp, a breath caught in her throat, and then she was gone, over the railing, into the dark, into the cold air below, and the terrace was suddenly empty, except for Verity and me and the bracelet on the floor and the city lights far below.
Verity looked down.
She did not look down with horror. She did not clutch at her mouth, or cry out, or run to the railing to see if Miriam was all right. She looked down with calculation, her head tilted slightly to one side, her eyes narrowed, her face calm, as if she was checking a figure in a ledger, as if she was making sure that something she had planned had gone according to plan. She stood there for a moment, looking down into the dark, and then she turned, slowly, and she saw me.
She saw me beside the service planter, the linen tablecloth still over my arm, my hands shaking, my mouth open, and her face changed, just slightly, becoming smooth and composed, the face she wore in the ballroom, the face of a woman at her own engagement party, a woman who had just witnessed a terrible accident and was about to do the right thing.