Derek Vance did not let the silence hold. He laughed again, louder this time, a laugh that was meant to break the quiet Rose had made and to pull the crowd back to his side, and he shook his head as if he had heard something foolish and endearing at the same time. He said that of course Lily could say no, of course she could, that no one was forcing anyone to do anything, that this was all in fun, that this was Brookfield, not a battlefield, and he said it with his hand still around Lily's wrist, with Lily still standing halfway to the mats, with the girl's fear plain on her face for anyone who cared to look. He said that Rose was making a fuss over nothing, that she was turning a friendly demonstration into a lecture, that she was the kind of person who saw trouble where there was none, and he said it in the bright, wounded tone of a man who had learned to make his own discomfort sound like someone else's fault. He looked out at the crowd and spread his arms, inviting them to agree with him, to see how reasonable he was being, to see how unreasonable it was for a quiet woman in a cardigan to stand up in the back and tell a black belt how to run his own class. A few people laughed, because Derek's laugh was contagious in the way that loud laughter often is, and a few others shifted in their seats, their faces tight, their eyes moving between Rose and Derek and Lily, as if they were watching a story unfold and did not yet know how it would end. The light through the high windows had begun to fade, the gold deepening to amber, and the hall felt warmer and closer, the air thick with the smell of bodies and floor polish and the faint, sweet scent of the coffee that had gone cold by the door.
He took a step closer to Rose, and then another, leaving the center of the mats and walking across the wooden floor toward the back of the hall, his bare feet making no sound, his white uniform bright against the darker rows of chairs. Lily, still held by the wrist, was pulled a half-step forward with him, and she stumbled slightly, catching herself, her eyes widening, her mouth opening in a small, frightened gasp that no one but those nearest could hear. Mai Tran rose fully from her chair then, her coat falling to the floor, her hand reaching out, her voice breaking as she said Lily's name again, louder this time, with a mother's urgency that cut through the laughter. Tom Alvarez moved too, finally, his clipboard clattering to the floor as he stepped forward with his hands raised in a placating gesture, his face flushed, his voice unsteady as he began to say that perhaps they should pause, perhaps they should take a moment, perhaps everyone should sit down. Sam Porter, at the edge of the mats, took a full step forward now, his hands open at his sides, his face pale and earnest, and he looked at Derek with an expression that was part loyalty and part alarm, as if he wanted to help and did not know whether helping meant standing beside his teacher or standing between him and the girl. None of them reached Derek in time to stop him, because Derek was already moving with the momentum of a performer who had decided that the only way to win a room back was to make the challenge bigger, louder, more impossible to ignore.