Mara's ward held its meeting two nights later in a warehouse office that smelled of wet rope and diesel. Nessa attended at Mara's request but did not speak until invited. There was a long argument about outstanding road permits. Some people believed Marcus had protected their businesses from unpredictable charges. Others thought he had merely negotiated exceptions that could disappear when he was angry. A warehouse owner demanded a guarantee that his permit would survive a new administration. Mara replied that she could promise a review and a written decision, not a favorable outcome. Nessa watched the man struggle to appreciate a system that offered him less personal assurance and more general fairness. Mara's ward returned authority for the recall by a smaller margin than Nessa's.
Len declined to convene his committee. He said the district preferred stability and that the council rules allowed a captain to exercise judgment without a special return. Nessa checked with Eamon and learned he was correct. She telephoned Len. 'If you're going to vote against me, I want you to say so. If you don't know, I want you to say that.' 'I know I don't want to be the one who brings the building down,' he replied. 'Then perhaps the question is how to keep it standing if Marcus isn't there.' 'That's your question,' Len said. 'Mine is whether my people will still have jobs on Monday.' She could not dismiss that fear. She also could not accept it as proof that one man must govern forever.
As the hearings continued, Marcus became harder to find. He canceled their usual Sunday dinner with a message about a supplier dispute and sent Nessa a parcel containing a scarf she had admired in a shop window. She left it unopened for a day, then unwrapped it and wore it to work. She refused to turn the object into evidence of coercion simply because she was angry. Yet when a clerk from the central office called to ask whether her district had submitted a statement of support for continuity, the scarf seemed suddenly heavy around her neck.
She visited Marcus's office on Monday. It was at the rear of the social club, overlooking an alley where delivery vans blocked the fire exit unless someone moved them twice a day. He was signing checks. 'You sent a request for a statement of support,' she said. 'I sent every captain a request to state a position.' 'Before the recall hearing?' 'People are entitled to know where their representatives stand.' 'Then invite them to ask us in public.' He set down his pen. 'Everything has to be an audience now.' 'Everything has always had an audience. You've just been able to choose who was allowed in it.'
He looked tired. 'I was told you questioned the price I paid for the hall's emergency repairs.' 'I questioned why the repairs depended on your private account when we have a maintenance fund.' 'The fund was empty.' 'Because the money was held centrally.' 'Because three districts asked for more than they could pay for.' 'Then show them the shortfall.' He opened a drawer and placed a set of old ledgers on the desk. 'I have spent half my life showing people how short we are. They thank me for keeping it quiet. You call that secrecy.' 'Some of them don't know what you're keeping quiet.' He laughed once, without pleasure. 'You think knowing will make it easier to pay?'
Nessa sat opposite him and opened the first ledger. The pages recorded genuine costs: heating, equipment leases, reimbursements for families during a flood. She recognized several names. There was a payment for an operation not covered by insurance, another for a worker whose landlord had changed the locks without notice. Marcus had paid from discretionary accounts and expected no public credit, but the recipients had known whom to thank. 'This is real help,' she said. 'I know it is.' 'Then why do you speak as if I keep people hungry to feel powerful?' 'I don't. I think you helped them. I also think you made it impossible for them to tell you no without feeling they were betraying the help.'
He ran a finger along the edge of a page. 'No one gets everything right.' 'No. That's why authority should expire.' 'You say it so casually.' 'I say it because I know what it costs to admit a mistake in front of you.' His face hardened. 'I gave you a place to belong.' 'You did. And I belong here now even when we disagree.' There was a pause long enough for voices from the kitchen to become audible. 'You have become very certain of yourself,' he said. 'I hope not. I'm trying to learn how to make decisions without needing certainty first.'
When she rose, Marcus asked whether she would come for dinner once the petition was over. 'Yes,' she said, before thinking. 'Even if I win?' He stared at her. 'You think winning is the point?' 'Not the only point.' 'You are my daughter.' 'Then we have a reason to eat together that has nothing to do with a ballot.' He said nothing. She left with the smell of old paper on her hands and a sense that the hardest part of the argument was not proving he was wrong. It was accepting he could be right about many things and still have to leave the chair.