For a long moment, nobody said anything. Then Jennifer Hale stepped back from the door, and she said, very quietly, "Come in."
The inside of the house was clean and neat and very quiet. There were photographs on the walls in the hallway — not many, but enough to make Mason pause. A young man on a motorcycle. A woman holding a baby. A boy on a bicycle. He did not stop to look at them closely. He followed Jennifer through the house, down a narrow hallway, to a door at the back, and she opened it, and she led them down a set of wooden stairs, into the basement.
And then Mason stopped, and Rafael stopped, and Doc stopped, and even Ethan stopped, and they all stood on the bottom step and stared.
The basement was full of photographs.
Not a few. Not a dozen. A wall full of them. Row after row, frame after frame, covering the whole of one wall from floor to ceiling, and spilling onto the next wall, and the next. Baby photos. Birthday photos. Family photos. A baby in a blanket. A toddler taking his first steps. A small boy on a bicycle, grinning, missing a tooth. A boy a little older, holding a wrench, standing next to a motorcycle. A boy at a table, eating cake, candles burning in front of him. Year after year, laid out on the wall like a life being watched from a distance.
Ethan stepped forward, slowly, as if he were walking into a dream. He looked at the wall, and his mouth opened, and no sound came out, and then he turned to Jennifer, and he said, in a voice that was barely a whisper, "These are all me."
"Yes," Jennifer said. "They are all you."
"How did you get them?" Ethan asked. "How did you — how did you know?"
Jennifer looked at the wall, and her eyes were wet, and she did not answer right away. When she did, her voice was quiet and steady, the voice of a woman who had been keeping a secret for a very long time and had finally decided to stop keeping it.
"I watched you," she said. "From far away. I never came close. I never spoke to you. But I watched you. I kept every photograph I could get. A birthday. A school photo. A picture someone sent me. I kept them all, because you are my grandson, and I could not be with you, and this — this wall — was the only way I had to be near you."
Mason looked at the wall, and he felt something in his chest tighten, and he thought about his own photograph, the one in his pocket, the one of Caleb, and he thought about how a grandmother could watch a grandson grow up from a distance, year after year, and never once step forward, and never once say a word, and how much that must have cost her.
"This isn't surveillance," Doc said, quietly, looking at the wall. "This isn't someone spying. This is a grandmother. This is a woman who loved a boy she couldn't hold, and so she held his photographs instead."
Jennifer nodded. She wiped her eyes with the back of her hand. "I didn't know what else to do," she said. "Caleb was gone. Laura was hiding him. Daniel was raising him. And I — I was the grandmother no one knew about. So I watched. And I waited. And I kept the photographs."
Ethan walked along the wall, slowly, his fingers trailing over the frames, and he stopped in front of one photograph, and he stared at it, and Mason came to stand beside him, and he looked at it too, and he felt the air go out of his lungs.
Chapter 17: The Torn Photo
The photograph was different from the others. The others were whole, and clear, and carefully framed. This one was damaged. It showed Laura, young, holding a baby — Ethan, as a baby, wrapped in a blanket, asleep in her arms — and standing next to her was a young man.
Or rather, standing next to her had been a young man. His face was gone. Someone had torn it away, carefully, along a jagged line, so that only his arm and his shoulder remained, reaching toward Laura and the baby, as if he had been there, and then had been removed, and all that was left of him was the part of him that had been touching them.
On the shoulder, on the skin of the arm that remained, there was a tattoo. A winged piston. A motorcycle tattoo, the kind the Iron Vultures wore, the kind Mason himself had on his own shoulder, the kind that marked a man as one of them.
Mason stared at the tattoo. He knew that tattoo. He had seen it a hundred times, on a hundred different men, in a hundred different places. But on this arm, on this torn photograph, it meant something more. It meant the young man standing next to Laura, holding her baby, had been one of them. One of the Iron Vultures. One of his own.
"Who tore the face away?" Rafael asked, quietly.