The Doctor Remembers Too
Danny Reyes knew that he needed one more voice before he could tell Enzo Castellano the truth about Carlo Venti. He had a name in an old ledger, the memory of Rosa Delgado, and the confession of Marco Bellini, the rival family's cook. Danny wanted a voice that no one in Bay City could doubt, a voice that spoke of medicine and facts. That voice belonged to Dr. Henry Walsh, the family doctor, who had been called to the house on the night Elena died. Danny decided to visit him, and to ask him what he remembered.
Danny found him sitting on his porch in the morning, reading a newspaper and drinking tea. The doctor looked up, smiled, and invited Danny to sit beside him. Danny thanked him, and he spoke slowly, telling the doctor about the ledger, about Rosa, and about Marco, and asking if the doctor remembered anything from the night Elena died. Dr. Walsh put his newspaper down, and his face grew serious, and he looked out at the bay for a long time before he spoke. He told Danny that he remembered that night very well, because he had never forgotten the look on Enzo's face.
The doctor said that when he had arrived at the Castellano house that night, Elena had already been very sick, and her symptoms had been strange. She had eaten fish, and then she had grown weak, and her hands had shaken. Dr. Walsh had known at once that it was poison, because the symptoms were not like food that had gone bad, and they were not like a sudden illness. He had asked what Elena had eaten, and he had been told about a special oil that Carlo Venti had brought into the kitchen. Dr. Walsh had wanted to test the oil, and to test the fish, but Carlo had told him that the bottle had been thrown away, and that there was nothing left to test. The doctor had felt that something was wrong, but he had been afraid to say it, because Carlo was powerful, and because Enzo was broken with grief.
Dr. Walsh told Danny that he had kept his own notes from that night, notes that he had written in a small book, and that he had kept those notes hidden for fourteen years. He went inside his house, and he came back with the small book, and he opened it to a page from fourteen years ago. On that page, in his neat handwriting, he had written the symptoms he had seen, the time Elena had eaten, and the name of the oil that Carlo had brought. He had also written a note in the margin, a note that said he did not believe the chefs were to blame, because the poison had been too careful, too exact, and too well hidden to be the work of a careless cook. Danny stared at the page, and his hands shook, because the doctor's notes gave him the last piece of proof he needed.
The doctor looked at Danny, and his eyes were sad and tired, and he said that he was sorry he had stayed quiet for fourteen years. He said that he had been afraid, like everyone else, and that he had told himself that Enzo would not believe him, and that Carlo would hurt him if he spoke. But now, hearing Danny's story, and seeing the ledger and the memories of Rosa and Marco, Dr. Walsh knew that the time had come to tell the truth. He promised Danny that he would speak to Enzo himself, and that he would show him his notes, and that he would stand beside Danny when the truth was told. Danny thanked the doctor, and he felt a great weight lift from his shoulders, because he was no longer alone.
Danny walked back to the Castellano house with the doctor's promise in his heart, and he knew that the time to tell Enzo was near. He had found the truth, piece by piece, and now he had a name, a memory, a confession, and a doctor's notes. Carlo Venti had poisoned Elena, and he had blamed five innocent chefs, and he had caused fourteen years of fear and guilt. Danny knew that telling Enzo would be painful, but the truth was the only way for the family to heal. The doctor remembered too, and now, at last, the truth was ready to be spoken.