The Cowboy Found 200 Horses Stolen from the Tribe... 20 Apache Women Whispered, “Now We Are Yours”

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Certainly not."

A few people smiled.

The attorney continued.

"Then what qualifies you to determine who owns these animals?"

Caleb considered.

"Nothing."

The attorney appeared pleased.

Then Caleb added, "That's why I didn't decide ownership. I helped identify and care for them while the owners provided their records."

Judge Fletcher nodded.

"An appropriate distinction."

The attorney changed direction.

He questioned Caleb about the herd's condition.

Could animals have been injured before arriving at Blackstone?

Yes.

Could some have been ill beforehand?

Possibly.

Could Caleb determine the exact cause of each injury?

No.

He answered carefully.

He refused to embellish.

The facts were serious enough without pretending certainty he did not possess.

Then Elena testified.

She described her visit to Mercy Crossing.

Her attempts to examine the corridor records.

Her detention at Blackstone.

And the documents she discovered there.

She distinguished what she personally witnessed from what she overheard or inferred.

When asked about the suspicious survey amendment, she explained why several entries were inconsistent with the meetings she knew had occurred.

One purported authorization bore her name.

She denied signing it.

The date corresponded to a period when she was confined at the ranch.

The opposing attorney asked whether she could be mistaken.

Elena looked directly at him.

"No."

He tried again.

"Perhaps someone signed on your behalf?"

"Not with my permission."

"Could you have forgotten?"

Elena's expression hardened.

"I remember being locked inside a room while your client's employees decided when I was allowed to eat. I also remember not authorizing a land transfer."

Silence fell across the courtroom.

The attorney lowered his papers.

Judge Fletcher instructed everyone to remain orderly.

Elena continued answering.

She did not shout.

She did not exaggerate.

She simply refused to let the lawyer transform uncertainty about other records into uncertainty about her own actions.

Caleb watched from the back bench.

He felt pride.

But also something deeper.

Respect for the discipline required to tell a painful story under hostile questioning.

Later, Deputy Charles Mercer's financial records were introduced for examination within the relevant proceedings.

The payments did not settle every allegation against him.

But they raised questions about possible conflicts of interest and why complaints about the horses had not been investigated promptly.

A former employee of Rourke's freight office testified that some acquisition entries were prepared after the animals arrived.

Other witnesses described being instructed to avoid ordinary livestock documentation.

Gideon Rourke denied ordering theft.

He argued that his company relied on intermediaries who represented themselves as authorized to transfer the animals.

The judge heard that argument.

Then requested proof of the intermediaries' authority.

The records were incomplete.

Several contradicted one another.

Others had been prepared under circumstances requiring further scrutiny.

At the end of the hearings, the court recognized the established ownership claims for the horses supported by sufficient evidence and ordered additional examination of the remaining contested cases.

The disputed corridor amendment was not accepted as reliable proof of the claimed approvals.

Further review would be needed to determine the underlying access rights, including interests that could not be resolved simply through the company's private documents.

The businessman's larger plan was no longer certain.

His company still possessed wealth.

But it could not rely on the questionable amendment to claim uncontested control over the northern route.

Outside, a crowd gathered beneath the courthouse steps.

Some people cheered.

Others remained cautious.

Rosa stood beside Tomas, looking toward the mountains.

Caleb approached.

"How do you feel?"

She considered.

"Glad the records were examined."

He nodded.

"And?"

"Angry that it took so much."

Caleb understood.

The families had lost animals.

Time.

Money.

Peace.

Several horses had died.

Elena had been imprisoned.

The hearings could recognize claims and expose misconduct.

They could not restore everything.

Tomas joined them.

"My sister did well."

Caleb smiled.

"Very."

The older man looked toward Elena, who was speaking with Rebecca Vale.

Then back at Caleb.

"She's difficult to intimidate."

Caleb laughed softly.

"I noticed."

Tomas smiled.

For a moment, the two watched the courthouse doors.

Then Caleb said quietly, "I think my father would've liked today."

Tomas studied him.

"Why?"

"He used to say powerful men only lost when someone more powerful came along."

Caleb looked toward the people gathered outside.

"Turns out sometimes they have to answer to records and witnesses too."

Tomas nodded.

"Sometimes."

The distinction mattered.

Justice was not guaranteed.

But neither was defeat.

And for Caleb, that was a truth worth carrying into whatever came next.

By the middle of December, most of the recovered horses had returned to their families.

The final numbers were painful but carefully documented.

Of the approximately two hundred animals taken, one hundred eighty-seven had been recovered alive and identified through the investigation and subsequent search. Seven were confirmed dead. Six remained missing.

Some survivors required extended care.

Others recovered more quickly.

The families maintained records of what had been returned, what was still owed, and which questions required further investigation.

Caleb helped with the final movements.

But he could not stop thinking about the six missing horses.

One belonged to a boy named Daniel.

The animal was a small gray gelding called Smoke.

Daniel was eleven, thin and serious, with a habit of standing beside Caleb whenever the cowboy worked.

He loved asking questions.

How did a horse know when a rider was nervous?

Why did one shoe wear faster than another?

Could Sombra recognize Caleb from far away?

Caleb answered patiently.

One afternoon, Daniel approached carrying an old halter.

"Mr. Morgan?"

Caleb looked up.

"Yes?"

"Do you think Smoke is dead?"

The question struck him.

He looked toward the boy.

For a moment, he considered offering reassurance.

Saying the gelding was surely alive.

That someone would find him.

That everything would be all right.

But Caleb knew better than to promise something he did not know.

He took a breath.

"I don't know."

Daniel looked down.

Caleb continued.

"But we haven't found proof he's dead."

The boy nodded.

For several seconds, neither spoke.

Then Daniel looked up.

"Would he remember me?"

Caleb smiled faintly.

"If you've been good to him, probably."

The boy swallowed.

"I raised him from a foal."

Caleb nodded.

"Then he's got plenty of reason to remember."

Daniel looked toward the mountains.

For a moment, Caleb saw himself at seventeen.

Standing beside the Texas farm.

Wondering whether things taken from his family would ever come back.

He placed a hand on the boy's shoulder.

"We'll keep looking where there's reason to look."

Daniel nodded.

"Thank you."

The following morning, Jonah Bell arrived with new information.

A freight driver had seen a small group of loose horses near Eagle Rock Canyon.

One was gray.

Another black.

Several wore damaged halters.

The sighting was uncertain.

But recent enough to investigate.

Caleb spoke with Tomas and Rosa.

They agreed that a small experienced search party could examine the area without disturbing the wider herd movements.

Elena joined them.

"You'll need someone who knows the eastern waterholes."

News in the same category

The Cowboy Found 200 Horses Stolen from the Tribe... 20 Apache Women Whispered, “Now We Are Yours”

25 Part