The Cowboy Found Water for the Apache...Then the Chief Lined Up 22 Women—His Answer Shocked Everyone

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

 

Corbin rose, smooth as ever. "Your Honor, this is colorful speculation—"

 

"Then let us ask Mr. Sutter," Judge Starr said mildly. "Mr. Sutter. Come forward."

 

What followed took less than ten minutes and undid three months of Cyrus Vane's work. Sutter wept — actually wept, into a handkerchief that had seen better decades — and admitted that Vane had paid him three hundred dollars to write and notarize the affidavit in September, backdating it to March. The surveyor J.T. Marlowe, it emerged, had died of fever in '75 and was therefore unavailable to object to the use of his name.

 

Vane's smile did not move. But something behind it went very still.

 

"Mr. Harlow," Judge Starr said. "Bring in the witness."

 

"Dutch" Harlow came in under guard, his hands manacled, a bandage still wrapped around his head where a falling rock had found him on the night of the guns. He looked smaller than Wade remembered, and tired in a way that had nothing to do with sleep.

 

Corbin was on his feet before Harlow had even taken the chair. "Your Honor, this man is a confessed criminal testifying under obvious duress—"

 

"He is testifying under oath," Starr said, "which is more than can be said for your affidavit, Mr. Corbin. Sit down."

 

The judge turned to Harlow. "Mr. Harlow. Who ordered the attack on the canyon on the night of the twelfth?"

 

Harlow stared at his manacled hands for a long moment. Then he looked across the room at Cyrus Vane — directly at him, the way a man looks at a debt he has decided to stop paying.

 

"Vane," Harlow said. "His orders were to take the cavern or close it. His words." Harlow's voice was flat, emptied out. "He said if we couldn't sell the water, nobody was going to drink it. The dynamite was his idea. The men were his money."

 

The courtroom was so quiet Wade could hear the courthouse bell's rope creaking in the tower.

 

"And the fire at the Broken Spur line camp in August?" Starr asked. "The warning shot at Mr. Merritt in the livery stable?"

 

"All his," Harlow said. "All Vane."

 

Corbin tried once more, weakly, to suggest coercion, but Starr cut him off with a look, and then the judge did the thing that would be talked about in Juniper Flats for twenty years.

 

"Chief Tazlini," Starr said, "this court would hear the testimony of Bekis, brother of the chief, regarding the history of the spring."

 

A cavalry interpreter named Kessler — a tired, decent man the Army had loaned for the occasion — stepped forward. Bekis rose, his sling white against his buckskin shirt, and walked to the witness chair with the measured tread of a man entering a place his grandfather would not have believed existed.

 

Kessler spoke to him quietly in the Deyani tongue. Bekis nodded, and began.

 

He spoke for a long time. Kessler translated in a low, careful voice, and the courtroom leaned forward to catch it.

 

"My grandfather's grandfather drank from that water," Bekis said. "When I was a boy, my father took me to the canyon mouth and showed me where the rock had fallen in his own father's time. The way in was closed. We believed the spring had died with the old world, the way so many things have died." He paused. "For two moons we searched every canyon while our children grew too weak to cry. Then the white tracker came out of the rock with his hands empty and gave us his own water to drink."

 

Bekis looked directly at Wade.

 

"He did not steal the spring. The spring was ours before his people had a name for this land, and it was lost to us. He found it, and he gave it back, and he asked for nothing. When our chief offered him wealth, he refused it, because he said a gift must not be made into a trade." Bekis's voice, even through the interpreter, carried iron. "I have fought white men all my life. This is the first one I would call brother."

 

The silence that followed was absolute. Somewhere in the back, someone wept — and Wade's own eyes were not entirely clear.

 

Judge Starr removed his spectacles and polished them slowly. When he spoke, his voice had the weight of a man carving words into stone.

 

"This court finds as follows. The claim of the Arizona Water & Rail Company to the spring at Coyote Throat is void ab initio — void from the beginning — being founded upon a forged and fraudulently backdated affidavit. The spring, the cavern, and the canyon of Coyote Throat are hereby placed in perpetual trust for the Deyani people, protected by order of this court and of the federal government it serves. No person, company, or agency shall divert its waters, sell its waters, deny its waters to any peaceful traveler, or enter the canyon to do it harm."

 

He looked at Vane.

 

"Cyrus Vane, you are indicted for fraud, conspiracy, and attempted murder, and remanded to federal custody. Mr. Sutter, you are under arrest for forgery and the destruction of the integrity of this Territory's records."

 

The gavel came down like the crack of a rifle, and Juniper Flats exhaled all at once.

 

It was over by noon. Outside, the crowd spilled into the white sunlight blinking like people surfacing from deep water. Hank Lowry was shaking everyone's hand, including people he had never met. Joli had somehow acquired a piece of horehound candy and was explaining the entire proceeding to Will Marsh in great and largely inaccurate detail.

 

Wade found himself standing apart from it for a moment, the borrowed coat suddenly too warm, watching Tazlini speak quietly with Mother Sanna. Then a shadow fell across him, and he turned to find Captain Rourke — stiff, gray, every inch the officer — standing at something like attention.

 

"Mr. Merritt," Rourke said. Then, with visible effort: "Chief Tazlini." The chief turned. Rourke met his eyes. "My orders regarding the upper trails — and the reserve — were wrong. I have written to headquarters recommending that the Deyani be left unmolested in their movements, and the patrols are withdrawn as of this morning." A pause. "I am sorry."

 

Tazlini studied him for a long moment. Then he extended his hand, and Rourke — to his evident surprise at himself — took it.

News in the same category

The Cowboy Found Water for the Apache...Then the Chief Lined Up 22 Women—His Answer Shocked Everyone

20 Part