"Much better," she whispered, her voice husky. "Thank you, Gabriel."
He nodded, rose to his feet, and placed an iron mess tin filled with water onto the embers, dropping a handful of dried chicory into it. He set out the cold bread and sliced the dried beef into thin strips.
They ate in silence, the simple food tasting miraculous in the warmth of the fire while the storm rattled the chimney above them like an angry fist. When they had finished, Gabriel poured the hot chicory coffee into a single tin cup and handed it to Clara. Their fingers brushed around the warm metal. Neither pulled away immediately.
"You keep looking at the door," Clara said softly, holding the tin cup in both hands. "Do you think Tolliver is out there in that blizzard?"
"No man rides in this storm unless he has an iron death wish," Gabriel said, leaning back against the fieldstone hearth, his knees drawn up. "He’ll have holed up at the timber camp three miles back. But he’ll be on the trail at first light. He knows the surveyor’s office opens at eight o'clock tomorrow morning."
Clara took a slow sip of the bitter coffee. The warmth spread through her chest, untying knots that had been wound tight for months. She looked at the cracked blue bowl that Gabriel had brought from his mantle, which now sat upon the plank table holding their matches and salt.
"Gabriel?" she asked quietly.
"Yeah?"
"Tell me about Caleb," she said. "And the woman who left."
The silence that settled over the cabin was not cold or awkward. It was deep and spacious, holding the heavy weight of memories that had been kept locked behind stone walls for years. Gabriel stared into the red heart of the fire, his jaw clenched, the muscles of his throat shifting as he swallowed. For a long time, the only sound was the crackle of a pine knot and the distant wail of the wind across the timberline.
"Her name was Sarah," Gabriel said finally, his voice rough, as if dredging words from the bottom of an abandoned well. "Sarah Vance. Her father owned the livery in town before he sold out to Vane."
Clara watched him, her hands cradling the warm tin cup. "She was pretty?"
"She was like those girls at the dance last night," Gabriel said, a faint, bitter edge in his tone. "Lace collars, delicate laugh, skin that never saw the noon sun. I was twenty-two, full of pride, and I thought having a pretty girl on my arm meant I had made something of myself. We were engaged for six months."
He reached down, picked up a dry pine twig, and tossed it into the embers, watching it curl into gray ash.
"Then the hard winter of eighty-six hit," he continued. "The blizzard that killed half the cattle from here to the Yellowstone. We lost three hundred head in two days. My father got pneumonia hauling hay out to the drifts and died before spring thaw. The bank called in the note on the lower pasture, and suddenly the Shaw ranch wasn't a prosperous estate anymore. It was two brothers, an empty barn, and four thousand dollars in debt."
He looked over at Clara, his eyes dark with the lingering sting of ancient betrayal. "Sarah came out to the ranch once after my father’s funeral. She stood on the porch in her velvet cloak, looked at the mud, looked at my chapped hands, and told me that she couldn't live in a house where every penny had to be counted twice. She said a man who couldn't guarantee a parlor and a carriage wasn't ready to take a wife. Two months later, she married a banker’s clerk in Laramie."
"And Caleb?" Clara asked gently.
"Caleb tried to carry the whole load on his shoulders," Gabriel whispered. "He worked twenty hours a day. He stopped sleeping. He became obsessed with finding out why the county taxes on our water rights had doubled while Vane’s holding company paid nothing. He told me he was going to Cheyenne to see the original surveyor’s field notes. The night before he was supposed to leave, he got into that brawl with Vane’s men at the saloon. The next morning, his horse came back to the barn alone, the saddle cinches cut halfway through with a dull knife."
A chill passed through Clara that had nothing to do with the freezing draft. "They murdered him."