Near midnight, a wind came down from the ridge and shook the windows. Caleb rose to check the latch. Clara gathered the papers into three bundles: one to carry, one to conceal, one to send by a trusted rider. 'Who in Red Hollow can we trust?' she asked. Caleb thought of the men who drank with Tucker, the merchants who owed Vale money, the families whose sons worked for the syndicate. Then he remembered the old schoolmistress who had taught him to read and had once slapped a cattle buyer for cheating a widow. 'Mrs. Bell,' he said. 'She doesn't scare easily.' Clara smiled. 'Then we'll begin with her.'
Caleb stood beside the window, looking at the black shape of the barn. 'My mother would have hated seeing it burn.' Clara joined him. 'She would have been glad the horses lived.' He nodded. 'She wanted me to find somebody who could stand the silence.' Clara waited, uncertain what he meant. He turned toward her. 'I didn't understand that silence can be something two people share. Doesn't always mean one of them has to leave.' For once Clara had no quick answer. She looked at the smoke-stained yard, at the ledger covered in names, and at the man whose life had been overturned by her arrival. 'No,' she said at last. 'It doesn't.' They stood together until the lantern burned low, listening to the night settle around a home that was damaged but not yet defeated.
He surveyed the smoking ruins of the barn with an expression of polite, sorrowful regret.
“A terrible misfortune, Caleb,” Vale said, his voice cultured, resonant, and dripping with venomous sympathy. “A working rancher cannot afford such disasters in an arid country. A dry season, a sudden lightning strike, and thirty years of labor vanishes in smoke.”
“There wasn't any lightning today, Vale,” Caleb said, stepping forward until he stood ten paces from the old man. The Winchester remained leveled at Vale’s waistcoat. “Your dog, Jack Vance, brought the matches. And if you take one more step toward my porch, I’ll put a forty-four slug through that silk tie before your men can clear their scabbards.”
The four riders stiffened, their hands tightening on their rifles, but Vale simply raised his silver-topped cane, signaling them to hold. He smiled—a thin, bloodless stretching of the lips that did not touch his freezing eyes.
“You have your father’s temper, Caleb,” Vale remarked softly. “Nathaniel was always prone to dramatic gestures when he found himself backed into a corner. But temper does not pay taxes, nor does it rebuild timber frames. You have no barn. You have no hay for the winter. Your well water is turning to brine. In two days, the county sheriff will execute a tax sale on this property. You are a pauper standing on dry dirt, boy.”
“He is not standing alone,” Clara’s voice rang out.
She stepped out from the shadow of the cottonwood tree, walking to Caleb’s side. She had washed the ash from her face; her burnished copper skin glowed in the afternoon light, and her two raven braids fell straight over her shoulders. Around her neck, the silver medallion rested like a shield of polished sun.
Vale’s cold smile vanished the instant his eyes locked onto that silver disk.
For a fraction of a second, something resembling raw, naked terror flickered across the old man’s pale features. His hand tightened around the head of his cane until his knuckles turned as white as tallow.
“You,” Vale whispered, his voice losing its cultured polish. “The Whitaker girl.”
“Clara Whitaker,” she said, her voice striking the courtyard like a hammer on an anvil. “Daughter of Samuel Whitaker. True trustee of the Red Hollow Basin under the Sovereign Covenant of eighteen sixty-seven.”
One of the mounted gunmen leaned down toward Vale, his voice low and tense. “Mr. Vale, you want us to drop these two right here? We can bury ‘em in the burn and say the fire took ‘em.”
“Quiet, you fool!” Vale snapped, his eyes never leaving Clara’s face. He stepped closer, leaning heavily on his cane, his chest heaving with shallow breaths. “Samuel Whitaker died in Mexico eighteen years ago. He was a shiftless drunk who abandoned his claims and ran south to escape his debts.”