He held it up.
"Seven families in this town have relatives who supposedly died at Camp Blackstone."
Several people shifted.
"None received wages owed to those men. None received bodies. None received explanations."
Vane laughed softly.
"Laborers move frequently."
"Dead ones don't."
The room went quiet.
Samuel continued.
"Naya's father kept records. Names. Payments. Missing supplies. Workers who disappeared."
Vane's expression changed almost imperceptibly.
Samuel noticed.
Good.
He had struck something important.
"Those records suggest men were killed and their deaths concealed."
A man near the back shouted, "Lies!"
Samuel turned.
"Then why not investigate?"
No answer.
"Why not send a federal marshal to Blackstone?"
Silence.
"Why not allow the families to learn what happened?"
Vane stepped forward.
"Because these allegations are based on the word of a fugitive."
Samuel looked toward Naya.
"Then let her speak."
The room erupted.
"No!"
"She's lying!"
"Send her back!"
Naya rose.
Samuel turned toward her.
She was trembling.
He could see it in her hands.
But she stepped into the aisle.
"My name," she began, "is Naya Red Willow."
Her voice was quiet.
Several people laughed.
She swallowed.
"My father was Joseph Red Willow. He worked at Blackstone. He read papers for men who could not read."
A woman near the back leaned forward.
Naya continued.
"He helped workers write letters. He counted food. He counted money."
She paused.
"He found numbers wrong."
Vane interrupted.
"This is absurd."
Naya looked directly at him.
"My father asked you why dead men still earned wages."
The church fell silent.
Vane's face hardened.
"I never met your father."
Naya reached beneath her shawl.
Samuel felt sudden alarm.
He had warned her not to reveal the document.
But she removed only a small brass button.
It was engraved with a distinctive letter V.
"My father took this from coat of man who beat him."
Vane stared.
Naya lifted the button.
"I saw that man beside you."
A ripple of whispers moved through the congregation.
Vane recovered quickly.
"Thousands of garments bear my company's mark."
Naya nodded.
"Yes."
Then she said, "And many men wearing them killed people."
The words hung in the air.
Samuel saw something change.
Not in everyone.
But in a few faces.
Doubt.
The first crack in Vane's carefully constructed certainty.
The meeting deteriorated after that.
Some demanded Naya's arrest.
Others wanted an investigation.
Several railroad workers attempted to speak but were shouted down.
Finally, Mayor Price called for a vote.
"All in favor of requesting that Sheriff Mercer detain Miss Red Willow pending transfer to authorized officials, raise your hands."
Hands rose throughout the church.
Samuel counted.
More than half.
The mayor swallowed.
"All opposed?"
Samuel raised his hand.
So did Eleanor.
Dr. Hale.
A few workers.
An elderly widow named Mrs. Collins.
And perhaps a dozen others.
Not enough.
The mayor announced the motion had passed.
Naya closed her eyes.
Samuel stood.
"Thomas."
Sheriff Mercer approached.
"Sam, don't."
Samuel stepped between him and Naya.
"That paper isn't a lawful warrant."
"The town voted."
"The town can't vote someone into slavery."
Mercer's jaw tightened.
"Move aside."
Samuel did not.
Two deputies approached.
The room fell silent.
Vane watched from the pulpit.
Samuel could feel the entire town holding its breath.
He had a revolver.
So did the deputies.
A single foolish movement could leave people dead.
Then Dr. Hale stepped beside him.
"Thomas, I am declaring this woman medically unfit for transport."
Mercer hesitated.
Hale continued.
"She has an infected gunshot wound. Moving her without proper care could kill her."
Vane snapped, "That's ridiculous."
Hale turned.
"Are you a physician, Mr. Vane?"
"No."
"Then kindly remain silent while one speaks."
A few people laughed nervously.
The doctor faced Mercer.
"If you remove her, I will testify that you knowingly endangered a patient."
Mercer looked trapped.
The mayor whispered urgently with Vane.
Finally, the sheriff spoke.
"Miss Red Willow will remain under medical supervision until tomorrow evening."
Samuel exhaled.
"After that," Mercer continued, "we will reconsider custody."
Vane stepped down from the pulpit.
His eyes met Samuel's.
The expression on his face was no longer polite.
It was murderous.
They left the church through a side door.
Eleanor guided Naya toward the wagon.
Dr. Hale followed.
Samuel remained behind for a moment.
Sheriff Mercer approached.
"You should leave town."
Samuel looked at him.
"With Naya?"
"Yes."
"Then Vane will call me a kidnapper."
"He already does."
Samuel sighed.
"Thomas, how long have we known each other?"
"Twenty years."
"Then tell me something."
The sheriff waited.
"Do you believe she's guilty?"
Mercer looked toward the street.
After a long silence, he answered.
"No."
Samuel stared.
"Then why are you doing this?"
Mercer's shoulders sagged.
"Because Vane owns the bank. My brother's farm is mortgaged there. My wife is sick. My deputies have families."