Rebecca sat beside the flames, holding her hands toward the warmth.
Her borrowed blue dress had dried unevenly after their escape through the flooded tunnel. Mud stained the hem, and a long tear ran along one sleeve.
Nathaniel removed his coat and placed it around her shoulders.
"You'll need that," she protested.
"I've got another blanket."
"You said something similar when you found me."
"And I survived."
She smiled faintly.
He returned the smile, but his thoughts remained elsewhere.
The copper container lay on the table between them.
Inside were documents capable of destroying the Blackthorn Land Company—or so they hoped.
Yet among those documents was a record suggesting that Samuel Cole had accepted money from the very men he had spent years opposing.
Nathaniel could not stop thinking about it.
Rebecca noticed.
"You've been quiet since we left the mine."
"I've been thinking."
"About your father?"
He nodded.
She moved closer to the table.
"Then perhaps we should examine the documents properly."
Nathaniel hesitated.
"You're exhausted."
"So are you."
"That doesn't mean we should stay awake all night."
Rebecca gave him a determined look.
"My father used to say that when a question frightens you, the worst thing you can do is leave it unanswered."
Nathaniel sat opposite her.
"Your father sounds like a difficult man to argue with."
"He was."
She smiled sadly.
"I miss arguing with him."
Nathaniel looked at her for a moment, then opened the copper container.
They spread the documents across the table.
There were land deeds, survey diagrams, payment records, and letters written in several different hands. Some were copies of official documents. Others appeared to be private notes, preserved carefully beneath layers of oilcloth.
Rebecca began arranging them by date.
Nathaniel watched her work.
She possessed a remarkable ability to recognize patterns in complicated records. Numbers that appeared meaningless to him became part of a larger story when she placed them beside the right documents.
After nearly an hour, she stopped.
"Nathaniel."
He looked up.
"What?"
"Come here."
She pointed to the payment record bearing Samuel Cole's name.
"Look at the date."
He leaned closer.
"June seventeenth, eighteen sixty-eight."
"Now look at this letter."
She handed him a folded sheet.
It was written by Edmund Price and addressed to Jonathan Hartwell.
Nathaniel read the first paragraph.
Samuel has agreed to receive the funds under his own name until the original claimants can be identified. We must not allow the company to retain the money without a record of its destination.
Nathaniel stopped breathing for a moment.
He read the sentence again.
Then he looked at Rebecca.
"What does that mean?"
She pointed to another document.
"Blackthorn transferred money to your father. But according to this letter, Samuel was holding it for families whose land had already been taken."
Nathaniel stared.
"Why would Blackthorn agree to that?"
"He may not have known the money was being diverted."
Rebecca turned another page.
"These records suggest that several payments were made through a settlement fund administered by the territorial land office. Your father may have been appointed to distribute compensation."
Nathaniel looked down at the document.
"So he wasn't taking a bribe."
"Not according to this evidence."
A strange pressure formed behind his eyes.
For years, Nathaniel had carried anger toward his father.
Then guilt.
Then doubt.
Now, for the first time, he felt something resembling relief.
Rebecca touched his hand.
"He was trying to help them."
Nathaniel nodded slowly.
"My father never told me."
"Perhaps he couldn't."
"Why not?"
She handed him another letter.
This one was unsigned.
The witnesses must remain separate. If one is discovered, the others must be protected. No complete copy of the evidence shall remain in a single location.
Nathaniel frowned.
"Witnesses?"
Rebecca searched through the remaining papers.
Near the bottom of the container, she found a narrow strip of parchment.
Four names had been written across it.
Samuel Cole.
Edmund Price.
Jonathan Hartwell.
The fourth name had been scratched away.
Rebecca held the parchment toward the firelight.
"Someone deliberately removed the last name."
Nathaniel examined the damaged surface.
"Can you read any of it?"
"Only the first letter."
She tilted the parchment.
It looked like an M.
Nathaniel stared.
"M."
Rebecca nodded.
"Do you know anyone whose name begins with M?"
"Half the valley."
He leaned back.
"But I know someone who might remember the men in that photograph."
"Who?"
"An old railroad engineer named Amos Bell."
Rebecca frowned.
"Railroad engineer?"
"He helped build the original line through Piedra Valley. My father trusted him."
"Where is he now?"
"In Ashford."
Rebecca looked troubled.
"Isn't that where Blackthorn has his headquarters?"
"Yes."
They sat silently.
Outside, the wind moved through the pine trees.
Rebecca folded the parchment.
"If Amos knew the fourth witness, we have to find him."
Nathaniel studied the fire.
"Walking into Ashford would be dangerous."
"Everything is dangerous now."
"That's not a reason to be careless."
She looked at him.
"Then we make a plan."
He smiled faintly.
"You always have an answer."