The Delivery She Threw Away on Chestnut Ridge Lane

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

As the trial date approached, I thought often about Diane, not with hatred, though hatred would have been understandable, but with a kind of puzzled sadness. I had known her for years, in the superficial way neighbours know a board president: at meetings, at the mailbox, at the annual picnic where she organised the tables with a precision that was almost admirable. I had never thought of her as a criminal. I had thought of her as rigid, and image-obsessed, and difficult to argue with, but not as a woman who would steal from her neighbours or throw away a sick woman's food. The trial would force all of us to hold two ideas at once: that Diane had been, for a long time, an effective organiser of a tidy neighbourhood, and that she had also used that effectiveness to enrich herself and her cousin and to punish people who could not fight back. Holding two ideas at once is hard, but it is honest, and honesty, I was learning, was the only way through a story that had begun with a lie about a porch rule and ended, as all such stories must, in a room where the truth is told under oath. The week before the trial, Emily moved into my spare room, not permanently, but for the duration, because she said I should not be alone the night before testifying, and because she wanted to be there in the morning to drive me, masked, to the courthouse, and to sit in the corridor with water and a blanket in case the waiting was long. She cooked soup in large batches and froze it in labelled containers, the way I had once cooked for her when she was a student, and the reversal of that care, daughter cooking for mother, felt both strange and right, like a story coming full circle without anyone having planned it. We talked late into the evening, not about the trial, but about ordinary things: about the library, about Richmond, about the grand-niece who had finally had her birthday cake, late and small and with sprinkles, because Emily had baked it herself when my cake mix had gone into the dumpster. The cake, Emily said, had been a little lopsided, and the child had loved it anyway, which seemed to me a good summary of how families survive disappointment: not perfectly, but with sprinkles, and with love that does not require a mix from a box.

News in the same category

The Delivery She Threw Away on Chestnut Ridge Lane

45 Part