of papers off a clipboard on the trailer's tongue, scattered them on the apron, and one sheet — yellow, he
said, when counsel asked the colour, yellow like the second sheet of a pad book, he saw them a hundred
times a week — one sheet went over the apron's edge and down into the ditch grass on the west side, the
road side, the Pruitt side, and no man went after it, the crew being busy with the rest of the sheaf, and the
sheet lying too far and too small to be worth wet boots. He had written it down, he said, because loose
paper near a scale was a fine from the state if an inspector found it attributed to the quarry, and his book
was his defence against fines, and had been for twenty-three years. He had not known what the sheet was.
He had not gone near it. He had not spoken to the Pruitts in that week or any week about it, except through
the troopers. He had signed his statement on the Tuesday of his own coming-forward, before any lawyer,
insurer, employer, or newspaper had shown him the price of signing it, and the book the statement came
out of had been written on the Saturday, before there was a Saturday to explain.
Meridian's counsel rose at last, courteously, into the wreckage of his nineteen pages, and did the best
that could be done with them, which was to ask whether a sheet of yellow paper in a ditch was not, after
all, a common object in a farming county in harvest season, and whether the witness could swear that the
sheet he saw at 06:52 was the sheet on the clerk's table. “No,” Shaw said. “I can't swear that and I haven't.”
A murmur went round the benches, because the room had expected the state's witness to claim the whole
road and he had claimed a ditch. “What I can swear,” Shaw said, into the murmur, not raising his voice,
because a weighman's whole authority is that he never raises it, “is that a yellow sheet off a clipboard on
that trailer went in that ditch at 06:52 on Saturday and nobody fetched it back. What the sheet was is your
paper people's business — the trooper there has set a white sheet and a yellow sheet side by side and
matched their teeth like a zipper, and that's her book, not mine. I was asked whether anybody but the old
man puts a sheet at that bend that morning. There it is. I put one there. With the wind's help.” And because
the chair had accepted his terms, and because the terms were honest, the counsel asked him two more
questions only — whether anyone had promised him anything for his testimony, to which he said no and
that he had asked for it to be written down that no one had; and whether his employer had encouraged his
attendance, to which he said, “My employer's encouraged a lot of things this week. I'm here on my own
time. I took a day's leave to do it and it's on the roster at work in my name, if anybody's book wants it.”
Then he stood down, and sat in the second row beside his wife, and picked up his good coat from the
bench and folded it over his own knees this time, and became again what he had been at 06:52 on
Saturday: a man who had written down a small true thing in a book, in a county where small true things in
books had turned out to be the heaviest objects in the world.
The custody challenge was not withdrawn. Counsel for Meridian are not paid to withdraw. But when
the chair asked, in the procedural quiet that followed, whether Meridian wished to be heard further on the
provenance of the yellow copy, counsel said that Meridian stood on its filing, and the filing — nineteen
pages, heavy paper, an argument that the sheet had no home — lay on the record beside a scale book that
had just given the sheet a birthplace, a time, a wind, and a trajectory, and it was possible to watch the room
do the arithmetic that no advocate could undo: that the filing had been written in Topeka by men who had
never weighed anything in their lives, against a man who had weighed everything that moved in Harrow
Creek for twenty-three years and had written this down too.
After the recess — fifteen minutes, in which the commission room's windows stood open to a harvest
morning and nobody in the corridor said anything quotable to anybody — Marlene Foster took the witness
chair with the county's own files in a trolley at her elbow, and the hearing turned from the ditch to the
office, from what the wind had done to what had been intended, which is the clerk's territory and always
has been. Marlene did not have a narrative. She had a sequence, and she laid it before the commission in
the order the county's stamps had made it, date by date, each document produced from the county's
custody and identified by its own marks, so that by the end of her testimony the profit in the whole design
stood on the record as plainly as the ditch had.