"Cook the supper, Phoebe," she said. "Cook it in the street, where we can all see you do it, and sit down and eat it with us, the way you should have done years ago. I am too old to wait for another wedding to teach this town what it should have learned already."
Phoebe poured her a cup of water, and the older woman drank it, and she stayed a while, and she talked about the town as it used to be, and about the feasts Phoebe had cooked when she was young, and about the way the town had always taken her cooking and never once asked her what she wanted, and Phoebe listened, and she did not interrupt, because the older woman was saying what Phoebe had never said herself, and it was easier to hear it from someone else, and harder, too, because hearing it made it true in a way that thinking it had never quite done.
The third knock came before noon, and it was a farmer, a big man with dust on his boots and a hat in his hands, and he stood in her doorway and shifted from one foot to the other, the way a man shifts when he is not used to asking for things in a kitchen, and he said that he would bring two sides of beef if she would cook them, and that he would bring potatoes from his own field, and that he would carry the tables himself, and that his wife would bring the pies, and that he hoped she would say yes, because his wife had said that if Phoebe said no, there would be no supper at all, and he did not want to be the man who had to tell his wife that. Phoebe smiled at that, the first smile of the morning, and she told him to thank his wife, and she told him that she had not yet said yes, and that she had not yet said no, and that she was still thinking, and he nodded, and he went away, and he looked back once from the gate, the way a man looks back when he is hoping for something and does not want to show it.
The fourth knock came in the afternoon, and it was the schoolteacher, who came with a list written out in her neat hand, of the things the town would bring, and the people who would bring them, and the times they would bring them, and Phoebe looked at the list, and she saw bread and pies and beans and pickles and cheese and butter and apples, and she saw the names of a dozen women beside them, and she saw that someone had written, at the bottom of the list, in the schoolteacher's own hand, "Phoebe cooks, Phoebe eats," and she looked at those four words for a long time, and she felt her throat close, and she thanked the schoolteacher, and she folded the list, and she put it in her apron pocket, and she kept it there for the rest of the day, the way a woman keeps a letter she does not want to lose.
The fifth knock came in the evening, and it was a young mother with a child on her hip, and the child was small, and the mother was tired, and she said that she had no money to bring and no food to spare, and that she was afraid to come to a supper where everyone brought something and she had nothing to bring, and Phoebe took the child from her, and she held the child while the mother sat down, and she said that the child was something, and that coming was something, and that no one would be turned away, and that the supper was for the whole town, and that the whole town meant everyone, and the young mother cried a little, and then she laughed a little, and then she went away with the child, and Phoebe stood in her doorway and watched her go, and she thought about a supper where no one was turned away, and about a table where everyone could sit, and about the twelve years she had spent cooking for people who never asked her to sit down, and she knew, then, that she would say yes, and that the yes would be hers, and that it would be said on her terms, and that her terms were simple, and that they were not too much to ask.