"I know what the mine owner paid you," she said, when the silence had gone on long enough. "Four dollars a sack, and your word that you would sell no flour to my bakery. I am not here to ask you to break your word. I am here to make you a different offer."
The miller folded his arms, and his face was closed, the way a man's face closes when he is caught between two debts, and he said, "I have a family to feed, Hester. He paid in coin, and he paid it all at once. I could not turn it away."
"I know," she said. "And I am not asking you to. I am asking you to think about what your family eats."
He frowned. "What does that mean?"
"It means your wife buys my bread every morning," Hester said. "It means your children eat my bread with their supper every night. It means that if my bakery closes, your family eats bread from somewhere else, and there is nowhere else in Iron Springs that bakes bread the way I bake it. You know that. Your wife knows that. Your children know that, because they ask for it by name."
The miller was quiet. He looked at the floor, and he looked at the sacks, and he looked at her, and she could see him doing the sum in his head, the way she had done the sum in her own head that morning: four dollars a sack from the mine owner, paid once, against bread on his family's table every day of the week, and flour at the old price for the woman who baked it.
"I will make you a trade," Hester said. "Not a favor. A trade. I will bake bread for your family, a loaf every morning for your table, and two more on Sundays, fresh from my oven, the same bread I sell to the town. And in return, you will sell me flour at the old price, two dollars and fifty cents a sack, paid in cash, the way I have always paid you. Two sacks now, and the same again whenever I need them. You will not lose a penny on it, because the mine owner has already paid you for the flour you ground, and the flour you grind next will be sold at the price it has always been sold at, to the woman who has always bought it."
The miller shook his head, slow, and he said, "He will hear of it. He hears everything in this town."
"Let him hear of it," Hester said. "There is nothing in it to hide. A baker buying flour from a miller at the price flour has always been sold at is not a secret. It is business. And if he comes to you about it, you can tell him the truth: that your family eats my bread, and that you made a fair trade for it, and that a fair trade is not his to forbid."
She waited then, and the mill wheel turned outside, and the grain dust hung in the light from the door, and the miller stood with his arms folded and his eyes on the floor, and Hester stood still and let him think, because she had said what she had come to say, and there was nothing more to say, and a woman who has said her piece does well to hold her peace and let the other person find his own way to the answer.
At last he lifted his head, and he said, "A loaf every morning, and two on Sundays."
"Yes," she said.
"And two dollars and fifty cents a sack, in cash, the way it has always been."
"Yes," she said.
"And you will not tell anyone I agreed to it before you had to," he said, and there was a crack in his voice when he said it, because he was a man who kept his word, and he did not like the shape of this, even if it was fair.
"I will not tell anyone anything," Hester said. "It is a trade between you and me. It is not a story for the town."
He nodded then, once, hard, the way a man nods when he has made up his mind, and he went to the sacks against the wall, and he took two of them down, and he set them on the floor at her feet, and he said, "Five dollars, then. Two sacks, at the old price. And the bread for my family starts tomorrow morning."