The signature belonged to Daniel Bennett.
Ortiz read it twice.
“When was this issued?”
“Yesterday afternoon.”
“Yesterday afternoon, this building was supposedly an abandoned property with no records worth securing.”
“Circumstances changed.”
“What circumstances?”
Renshaw looked directly at Marcus.
“Someone started playing an old song.”
Marcus reached for the cassette recorder.
Renshaw's face changed.
“Don't touch that.”
The warning came too quickly.
Ortiz noticed.
“What is on the cassette?”
“Nothing relevant.”
“Then you won't mind if we examine it.”
“I absolutely will mind.”
Ortiz smiled without humor.
“That's unfortunate.”
He motioned toward the staircase.
“Turn around. Hands behind your back.”
Renshaw hesitated.
Then, from above, we heard a sharp crash.
A second later, the lights went out.
The room plunged into darkness.
Someone shouted.
I stumbled backward and struck the filing cabinet. Papers spilled around my feet. A hand grabbed my wrist.
For one terrible second, I thought Renshaw had reached me.
Then Marcus's voice sounded beside my ear.
“Rebecca, stay close.”
A flashlight flickered on.
Ortiz stood at the base of the stairs, breathing hard.
Renshaw was gone.
So was the document bearing Daniel Bennett's signature.
But the cassette recorder remained on the desk.
Marcus picked it up.
He looked at the old machine as though it were a living thing.
Then he pressed PLAY.
Static filled the room.
A woman began to sing.
Four notes.
Four more.
Then a lower note, trembling softly before fading away.
Marcus closed his eyes.
When the melody ended, a woman's voice whispered from the speaker.
“If you've found this, Sparrow, then the little girl has come home.”
Marcus dropped into the chair.
I knelt beside him.
“Marcus?”
He opened his eyes.
“Caroline was alive,” he whispered.
Ortiz switched on his radio and called for backup.
Marcus barely seemed to hear him.
For twenty-three years, he had believed he had failed the woman he loved. He had carried the guilt through prison, through years of loneliness, and through nights when he woke convinced he could still hear her calling for help.
Now he knew she had left him a message.
And the message had been waiting beneath the hospital all along.
But it contained something else.
A name.
Not Caroline's.
Not Marcus's.
The name of the child who had been taken from the maternity ward.
Anna Mercer
Anna Bennett arrived at my office shortly after noon.
She had not slept. Her hair was tied back carelessly, and she wore a dark coat over a blouse that looked as though she had pulled it from the first drawer she opened.
She carried a small suitcase.
“I need to see Lily,” she said.
“She's safe.”
“I know. But I need to see her before Daniel finds out where I am.”
I closed the office door.
“Anna, we need to talk about your mother.”
She sat down slowly.
“My mother?”
“Caroline Mercer.”
Anna stared at me.
For a long time, she seemed unable to understand the words.
Then she covered her mouth.
“No.”
“We found a recording beneath Saint Agnes Hospital.”
“No.”
“It contains a message for a girl named Anna Mercer.”
She stood abruptly.
“Stop.”
I fell silent.
Anna walked to the window and stared at the street below.
“My father told me my biological mother died during childbirth. He said she was young, unmarried, and unable to care for me. He said he and Eleanor adopted me because they wanted a child.”
“That may be part of the story.”
“He showed me a certificate.”
“The original records were altered.”
Anna shook her head.
“Eleanor would have told me.”
“Perhaps she tried.”
Anna closed her eyes.
“I remember the box.”
She spoke so quietly that I almost missed it.
“I was seventeen. Eleanor had been acting strangely for weeks. She kept asking me whether I remembered anything from when I was little. I thought she was worried about my grades or my friends.”
She sat again.
“One night, she came into my room with a cardboard box. Inside were photographs, letters, and a hospital bracelet. She said she wanted me to know the truth before someone else used it against me.”
“What truth?”
“That my name had once been Anna Mercer.”
I listened without interrupting.
“She told me that I had been born at Saint Agnes, and that Daniel had arranged the adoption through a private legal office. She didn't know all the details, but she believed the paperwork had been falsified.”
“Why would Eleanor have participated in the adoption if she knew something was wrong?”
“Because she didn't know at first. She thought the adoption was legal. Daniel told her the birth mother had signed the necessary forms. It was only years later that she discovered the signatures were forged.”
Anna's fingers twisted together.
“She said she wanted to go to the police. Daniel threatened to have her committed. He told her that if she accused him publicly, he would make sure nobody believed her.”
“Did she keep the documents?”
“Yes.”
“Where are they now?”
Anna shook her head.
“I don't know. Three days after she gave me the box, she died in a car accident.”
The room fell silent.
“Do you believe it was an accident?” I asked.
Anna's eyes filled with tears.
“I don't know what to believe anymore.”
She described the years that followed.
Daniel became increasingly protective. He monitored her friendships, discouraged her from traveling, and insisted that she attend a university near home. When she announced that she wanted to study nursing, he argued that the profession was too demanding.
When she met David Bennett, the man who would become her husband, Daniel approved immediately.
David was an attorney who had worked briefly in Daniel's office. He was polite, ambitious, and deeply impressed by the older man's reputation.
Their marriage was happy at first.
Then Lily was born.
And Daniel changed.
“He insisted on choosing her pediatrician,” Anna said. “He wanted copies of every medical report. When Lily was six months old, he asked whether she had a birthmark behind her ear.”
I felt a chill.
“What did you tell him?”
“That she did. He looked relieved.”
“Did he explain why?”
“He said he wanted to make sure she had no inherited skin condition.”
She wiped her eyes.
“Later, when Lily was three, he began asking me questions about my childhood. He wanted to know whether I remembered Saint Agnes. Whether Eleanor had ever mentioned Caroline Mercer. Whether I'd found any other documents.”
“Did you?”
“Yes.”
She reached into her suitcase and removed a small notebook.
The pages were filled with handwriting.
“I copied everything I could remember from the letters Eleanor showed me. Names, dates, hospital numbers. I didn't understand most of it at the time.”
I turned to the final page.
A sentence had been underlined three times.
The child must never be allowed to hear the song.
Below it was a list of names.
Paul Renshaw.
Daniel Bennett.
Dr. Leonard Shaw.
And, in a different hand, a name that made my blood run cold.
David Bennett.
Anna's husband.
“Where is David now?” I asked.
She stared at the notebook.
“He died four years ago.”
“How?”
“An accident on the interstate.”
“Was Daniel involved?”
“I don't know.”
I looked at the names again.
David had been a lawyer. He had worked for Daniel. He had died before Lily's disappearance.
Could he have known about the illegal adoption?
Could he have tried to expose it?
Anna seemed to be reading my thoughts.
“The night before he died, David came home late. He told me he had discovered something about my adoption. He said he was going to meet someone the next morning.”
“Who?”
“He wouldn't tell me.”
“What happened the next morning?”
“He never arrived at his office. His car crossed the median during a rainstorm. The police said he had fallen asleep.”
“Was he tired?”
“No.”
“Had he been drinking?”