The wounded clerk’s confession came in broken pieces. He had copied the deeds for Rourke’s lawyer and later discovered that several signatures had been pasted into the records from unrelated contracts. He planned to expose the fraud, but someone warned him that his children would be taken away if he spoke. When he finally decided to cooperate, he had already been followed.
After the shot shattered the window, Daniel carried the clerk behind a heavy desk. Maeve pressed cloth to the wound, but she knew from the man’s fading voice that there was little she could do. His last effort was to point toward the empty cabinet. The evidence had not vanished by accident; it had been removed by someone who knew exactly where it was kept. As the storm covered the town, Daniel understood that their enemy had an informant close enough to anticipate every move.
“Find the records,” she said. “Then make Rourke answer for every grave he filled.”
The old mission stood in a canyon where wind had carved the stone into strange shapes. They reached it the next afternoon, only to discover fresh hoofprints and a broken lock. Someone had searched the building before them.
Inside the chapel, dust covered the benches. Clara found a loose stone behind the altar, but the cavity beneath it was empty except for a brass key and a scrap of paper bearing the words “Room Twelve.”
Vale recognized the phrase. The mission had once operated a boarding house for survey crews, and Room Twelve had been used to store sealed documents. The building had burned decades earlier, but its stone foundation remained near the railway depot.
They returned to Mercy Creek after dark. A storm was building, and the town’s streets glistened beneath the first rain in weeks.
Daniel stopped outside the depot. The door to the abandoned boarding house had been forced open.
Inside, a man lay unconscious on the floor. His pockets had been turned out, and blood ran from a wound above his ear. Maeve knelt beside him and recognized the clerk from the county land office.
When he regained consciousness, he clutched Daniel’s sleeve.
“They have the original deeds,” he whispered. “Rourke’s men are taking them to the county seat tomorrow. After the auction, the valley will belong to the railroad.”
“Who gave them the documents?” Clara asked.
The clerk looked at the door, terrified.
“Someone inside your circle.”
Before he could say more, a shot shattered the window. Daniel threw himself over the clerk as glass rained across the floor.
When he looked up, the clerk was dead.
The storm broke over Mercy Creek, washing blood from the boards but leaving the truth untouched. Somewhere among their allies, a traitor was helping Rourke destroy the evidence.
Vale’s map was more than a drawing of water channels. In its margins, the surveyor had recorded the dates when the creek’s flow changed and the names of men who had ordered him to revise his measurements. Several entries were crossed out, but the pressure of the pencil had left grooves in the paper. Clara held the map near the lamp and traced the indentations with a fingertip.
“He erased the names, not the orders,” she said.
Daniel turned the page toward the light. One name appeared repeatedly beside a series of payments: Harlan, the sheriff. Another entry referred to a company agent who had visited the valley before the first land claims were altered. The agent’s signature was not complete, only a looping initial that looked like a K.
Vale admitted that he had made a second copy of the survey and hidden it in a place no railroad clerk would think to search. He refused to reveal the location until Daniel promised that the widows would be protected.
“I can promise we will try,” Daniel said. “I won’t lie to you and call that safety.”
Vale studied him for a long moment. Perhaps he had expected a grand oath. Instead, he received an honest account of how difficult their position had become. At last he described an old stone culvert beneath the abandoned mill, where he had wrapped the duplicate map in oilcloth.
Before they could leave, a shot struck the window frame. Everyone dropped. Daniel pushed Vale behind the table while Eleanor extinguished the lamp. Another shot followed, then hoofbeats retreating toward the creek.
No one had been hit, but the message was unmistakable. The attackers knew where Vale was hiding, which meant the secret had already escaped the room. Clara gathered the map while Maeve checked the back door.
“We have an enemy inside our circle,” Ruth said.
“Or an enemy watching every road into it,” Daniel replied. “Until we know which, we trust evidence, not suspicion.”
It was the only rule that could keep fear from doing Rourke’s work for him.
Suspicion spread faster than wildfire. Eleanor accused no one, but she began locking the ranch office and sleeping with her shotgun beside the bed. Clara copied every page twice. Maeve kept watch over the injured and refused to leave the group alone with any stranger.