THE HOA FLOODED MY YARD FOR THREE YEARS—SO I SENT THE WATER BACK TO THEIR CLUBHOUSE

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Stormwater and Access Easement Agreement.

Recorded twelve years before the clubhouse renovation.

The easement ran through the common area.

But it contained a limitation.

I read it three times.

Then I called Paul.

"Paul, can you come over?"

"What did you find?"

"I think I found the part they forgot to tell me."


The Forgotten Easement

Paul arrived the next morning.

I had printed the easement and highlighted several paragraphs.

He read silently.

Then he looked up.

"Where did you get this?"

"County register of deeds."

"When was it recorded?"

"Eleven years before Constance became president."

He read again.

The document granted Millbrook Pines an easement for stormwater management through the common area.

But it also contained a restriction.

The HOA could maintain existing drainage infrastructure and could construct improvements necessary for the common property, provided those improvements did not materially increase stormwater discharge onto neighboring private parcels without additional authorization.

Paul leaned back.

"That's important."

"How important?"

"Potentially very."

The word potentially irritated me.

I had learned that legal problems were full of words like potentially.

I wanted something definite.

Paul pointed to the map.

"The original drainage system appears to have dispersed water across this low area."

"And the new system?"

"Concentrates it."

"Which is what your report already says."

"Yes."

"Then what does the easement change?"

"Everything depends on whether the HOA exceeded the scope of the easement."

I stared at him.

"How do we know?"

"We compare the original conditions to the new system."

That afternoon, I hired a land surveyor.

Then I hired an attorney.

Her name was Rebecca Sloan.

She had handled property disputes, HOA cases, easement litigation, and construction conflicts.

When I walked into her office, I brought three binders.

She looked at them.

"How long have you been dealing with this?"

"Three years."

She smiled slightly.

"Good."

"Good?"

"Most people come to me with three screenshots and a story."

She opened the first binder.

"You have records."

"Is that good?"

"Very."

She spent two hours reviewing everything.

At the end, she leaned back.

"I think you have a viable claim."

I exhaled.

"What kind?"

"Potentially several."

She listed them.

Trespass by stormwater.

Nuisance.

Damage to property.

Breach of easement limitations.

Potential statutory violations.

And possibly something else.

"What's that?"

"Improper use of association funds."

I frowned.

"How does that connect?"

"The clubhouse drainage project."

She pointed to a financial statement.

"You said the project cost around $185,000?"

"That's what the HOA newsletter said."

"Where's the rest?"

"What do you mean?"

"The loan."

She showed me a line item I had never noticed.

Capital Improvement Loan — $420,000.

My stomach tightened.

"Four hundred twenty thousand?"

"Yes."

"For what?"

"I don't know yet."

Rebecca turned the page.

"Your HOA borrowed $420,000."

I stared at the document.

The clubhouse renovation couldn't possibly have cost that much.

At least, not based on the publicly disclosed work.

I went home and started digging.

The HOA's financial records were incomplete.

Some invoices were missing.

Several payments were categorized as "infrastructure."

There were checks to a company called Drewry Property Solutions.

I recognized the name.

Drewry was Constance's last name.

I called Rebecca.

"Rebecca."

"Yes?"

"I found payments to a company connected to Constance."

There was a pause.

"Send me everything."

I did.

The company was technically owned by Constance's brother.

But it had been contracted by the HOA for "project coordination."

More digging revealed something worse.

The company had received more than $78,000 in consulting and project management fees over two years.

Rebecca's voice changed when she saw the documents.

"This is no longer just about your yard."

I sat quietly.

"What does that mean?"

"It means we may be dealing with a governance problem."

I thought about all the homeowners who had complained about rising assessments.

The special assessment for the clubhouse.

The notices about "unexpected infrastructure expenses."

The new security cameras.

The decorative landscaping.

The expanded parking.

Suddenly, the numbers looked different.

But I wasn't interested in revenge.

I wanted my yard back.

Rebecca understood.

"Don't accuse her publicly."

"I wasn't planning to."

"Good. Let me investigate."

For the next month, we gathered documents.

Rebecca sent formal requests.

The HOA's attorney began responding.

Some records arrived.

Others didn't.

Then something unexpected happened.

A former HOA treasurer contacted Rebecca.

Her name was Linda Carver.

She had resigned eighteen months earlier.

She agreed to meet us.

We sat in a small coffee shop.

Linda looked nervous.

"I don't want my name in this."

Rebecca nodded.

"You won't be identified without your consent."

Linda took a sip of coffee.

"The clubhouse project wasn't supposed to be that expensive."

"How much was the original estimate?" Rebecca asked.

"About $190,000."

"And the loan?"

"$420,000."

"Why?"

Linda shook her head.

"I asked."

"What happened?"

"Constance told me the difference was for future infrastructure."

"Which infrastructure?"

"I never got a straight answer."

She reached into her purse.

"I kept copies."

She handed Rebecca a flash drive.

My heart started beating faster.

The files included meeting minutes.

Emails.

Invoices.

Contractor bids.

Payment records.

And one spreadsheet.

At the bottom of the spreadsheet was a list of project expenses.

There was the drainage contractor.

The landscaping company.

The paving company.

And Drewry Property Solutions.

The consulting company had billed the HOA for project oversight.

But the invoices contained no detailed work descriptions.

Rebecca stared at the screen.

"Garrett."

"What?"

"There's something else."

She scrolled down.

A payment had been made to a private engineering company.

The description said:

Drainage compliance review.

I recognized the company.

It was the same firm whose engineer had signed the original drainage plan.

Rebecca opened another document.

Then another.

The HOA had received a drainage compliance letter before construction.

The letter warned that the proposed discharge point could create concentrated runoff toward adjacent private property.

I read the sentence.

Then I read it again.

"They knew."

Rebecca nodded.

"They were warned."

"Did they ignore it?"

"It appears so."

I leaned back.

For three years, Constance had told me the flooding was natural.

News in the same category

THE HOA FLOODED MY YARD FOR THREE YEARS—SO I SENT THE WATER BACK TO THEIR CLUBHOUSE

7 Part