The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Karen saw us come in. I watched her face do a complicated thing — surprise, then something like satisfaction, as if our presence confirmed that this was a real fight and not just her shouting into the void. She wore a blazer. She had printed an agenda. At the head table with her sat four other people I recognized from the neighborhood in the vague way you recognize people you've waved at while getting your mail: Todd Brennan, the vice president, a big man with a golf tan; Susan Adeyemi, the treasurer, who ran the bookkeeping with an iron hand; and Pat Kowalski and Luis Herrera, board members at large. Five people at the head table, one empty chair at the end. The whole government of Willow Bend, population one hundred and twenty homes, assembled to decide the fate of my gate.

Karen called the meeting to order at seven sharp, with a little gavel she had apparently brought from home. A gavel. I glanced at Marsh, who kept her face perfectly still, but I saw one corner of her mouth move.

"Thank you all for coming on short notice," Karen said. She had a realtor's voice — warm, projected, trained to fill a room without shouting. "We're here tonight because of a situation affecting our entire community. As you know, a gate has been installed across what has historically served as a community access route — Cedar Hollow Road — and the board has taken enforcement action. Mr. Sullivan is here tonight, along with his attorney, and in the interest of fairness, we're going to hear from both sides before the board deliberates."

In the interest of fairness. I sipped the bad coffee. It tasted like it had been filtered through a gym sock, but it gave me something to do while Karen opened her binder.

Her case, as it turned out, had three pillars, and she presented them the way she'd present a house: emphasizing the features, glossing over the foundation.

First, community reliance. "For years," she said, "residents of Willow Bend have relied on Cedar Hollow Road as a secondary access route — for commuting, for emergency access, for school buses. This isn't some abandoned track. It's part of how this community functions." She had printouts — a map with the lane highlighted in yellow, a list of addresses. She did not, I noticed, have dates. For years is a phrase that does a lot of work when you don't want to say for two.

Second, historic access. "This road has been open and in use for decades," Karen said. "Long before any gate appeared. You can't just —" she paused, searching for the phrase, "— you can't just close off something the community has always used. There's a principle here."

Third, and this was the one she clearly thought was her ace, the fines. "The board has acted entirely within its authority," she said, "under Section 14.2 of our covenants — obstruction of community access routes. Mr. Sullivan has been notified, by certified mail, and the fines are accruing at fifty dollars per day until the obstruction is removed. We are prepared to place a lien if necessary."

She closed the binder. The room was very quiet. Somebody's chair creaked.

"Thank you, Karen," Todd Brennan said. "Ms. Marsh? Mr. Sullivan? The board will hear your response."

Marsh stood. She didn't bring notes to the front of the room — she brought the folder, and she opened it on the head table like she was laying out exhibits, which is exactly what she was doing.

"My name is Ellen Marsh," she said. "I represent Mark Sullivan. I'll be brief, because the facts here are brief."

She held up the first document — a certified copy of the 1962 deed.

"This is the deed to the Sullivan parcel, recorded in 1962 — six years before Willow Bend was platted. Eight acres, more or less, together with the private lane thereon. The lane you are calling a community access route has been private property, deeded and recorded, since before this subdivision existed."

She laid it on the table. Then the second document — the recorder's certification.

"This is a certification from the county recorder's office, following a complete search of the grantor-grantee indexes, the tract books, and the subdivision plats. It states, and I quote: no easement of any kind has ever been recorded against the Sullivan parcel. Not in 1962. Not when Willow Bend was built. Not ever. No right-of-way. No access agreement. Nothing."

A murmur moved through the folding chairs behind me. I didn't turn around.

"And this —" Marsh unrolled the survey map, and Pat Kowalski actually leaned forward to look at it, "— is a boundary survey completed last week by Carter & Sloane Surveying, licensed surveyors in this county. The orange flags are still in the ground, if anyone would like to walk it. The survey shows the lane lying entirely — wholly, without ambiguity — within the Sullivan parcel. It does not straddle a boundary. It does not touch Willow Bend land. It is, in every legal sense, Mr. Sullivan's driveway."

She let that sit for a moment. The fluorescent lights hummed.

"Now. The board has fined my client fifty dollars a day under Section 14.2 of the Willow Bend covenants, for obstructing a 'community access route.' There are two problems with that. The first is that the route is not a community route. It is a private lane on private land, and no easement — recorded or prescriptive — gives the community any right to it. A prescriptive easement requires twenty years of continuous, hostile use. The use in question spans approximately two years, and it was use my client actively and repeatedly objected to. The claim fails on every element."

Karen's face had gone very still.

"The second problem," Marsh said, "is more fundamental. Mr. Sullivan is not a member of the Willow Bend Homeowners Association. His land predates the subdivision. It was never annexed. Your covenants —" she nodded at Karen's binder, "— do not apply to him. They cannot apply to him. You have fined a non-member, for violating rules that don't cover him, on land you have never owned, over a road burdened by no easement whatsoever. You have no jurisdiction here. None."

The murmur behind me swelled into something louder — voices, overlapping, a chair scraping. Somebody said, clear as a bell, "She's right, you know. He's not in the HOA." Somebody else said, "Then what are we even doing here?"

Karen stood. "This is — the community has relied on that road —"

"For two years," Marsh said evenly. "By your own account, Mrs. Prescott. Two years of weekday mornings. That is not reliance the law recognizes, and it is certainly not twenty."

"We have a responsibility to our residents —"

"Your responsibility to your residents does not extend to my client's property. It can't. That's what property lines are for."

Todd Brennan raised a hand — a big, golf-tanned hand — and the room quieted, reluctantly, like a dog being told to sit.

News in the same category

The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

20 Part