Nine weeks after we moved in, a certified letter arrived from a law firm representing the HOA. It notified us that the association had recorded a lien claiming $2,800 in unpaid fines and enforcement costs.
I called an attorney that afternoon. Her name was Rebecca Dunn, a veteran of real-estate and association disputes. I sent her our meticulous paper trail. She called the next morning.
“The association may have authority to levy fines if it follows the declaration, bylaws, notice requirements, and applicable state law,” Rebecca said. “But, Thomas, they have completely bypassed their own due process. Margaret Bell has essentially weaponized the HOA’s legal counsel by feeding them fraudulent violation reports.”
Rebecca outlined our strategy in three distinct steps:
-
Demand a formal hearing: Force the board to present their evidence on the record.
-
Request all communications: File a formal demand to inspect all board emails and meeting minutes regarding 18 Crestfield Drive.
-
Prepare a countersuit: Draft a lawsuit for selective enforcement, breach of fiduciary duty, and civil harassment.
"We don't just want to remove the lien," Rebecca advised. "We want to make it legally impossible for her to do this to anyone else."
We submitted the hearing demand. Margaret, sensing a loss of control, panicked. Instead of consulting the HOA's law firm about our attorney's letter, she decided to escalate unilaterally.