The oak tree was in the front corner of her yard, near the sidewalk, and it was the easiest thing to find, because it was the only tree on her street that looked like it did not belong there. Everything else in Willowbrook Estates was the same: the same lawns, the same mailboxes, the same trimmed hedges, the same two or three kinds of trees that the landscaping bylaws allowed, planted in the same neat rows. Brenda's oak stood out. It was taller than the others, with a shape to it that did not match anything else on the block, and its leaves had a color to them, a dark green with a red edge in the sunlight, that I had never seen on any tree in this neighborhood.
I had noticed it before, the way you notice a car that does not belong in a parking lot, but I had never thought about it. Now I was thinking about it, because Section 12 of the landscaping bylaws was the section I had spent the second hour of my research reading, and Section 12 had a list in it. The list was long, and it was specific, and it named the species that were banned in Willowbrook Estates, because they were non-native and invasive, because their roots spread too far and their branches grew too fast and they crowded out the trees that actually belonged here.
Brenda's oak was on that list. I knew it the minute I stood underneath it and looked up at the shape of the leaves. It was a non-native species, explicitly banned in Section 12, and she had planted it last spring, right around the time my divorce was being finalized, right around the time I was moving into my house and learning the names of my new neighbors. I remembered the planting, actually. I remembered seeing the truck from the nursery parked in front of her house and the workmen digging the hole and setting the young tree in the ground, and I remembered thinking, at the time, that it was a nice-looking tree. It was a nice-looking tree. It was also illegal, according to the same bylaws she enforced on everybody else.
I measured the trunk. I photographed the leaves, up close, so the shape was clear. I photographed the whole tree from the sidewalk, with her house behind it, so there was no question about whose yard it was in. I photographed the nursery tag, which was still tied to one of the lower branches, faded by a year of sun but still readable, still showing the species name in print. I wrote it all down on the clipboard: oak tree, planted last spring, non-native species, explicitly banned in Section 12 of the landscaping bylaws.
That was violation number three.
I stood there on the sidewalk with my tape measure in one hand and my camera in the other and my clipboard under my arm, and I looked at what I had. A six-foot fence where the cap was five and a half feet. Fourteen inches of driveway on city land. A banned oak tree planted last spring. Three violations, each one documented, each one measured, each one photographed, each one tied to a section number in the same book Brenda had used to fine me two hundred dollars for a van that was not even a commercial vehicle by her own definitions.
It felt like the moment in the shop when you have finally found all three things wrong with a car that came in with a noise nobody else could diagnose. One problem is a repair. Three problems is a pattern. Three problems means the car was never maintained the way the owner claimed it was. Three problems means the person who was supposed to be taking care of it was not taking care of it at all.
I walked home slowly, the way I had walked over, and I went into my garage and I sat down at my workbench, and I spread out everything I had. The photographs. The measurements. The clipboard pages. The printouts from the CC&Rs, with the important paragraphs highlighted in yellow. The citation she had sent me, still sitting on my kitchen counter where I had left it, with her signature at the bottom. I looked at all of it laid out on that workbench, the same workbench where I had rebuilt a 1967 Camaro one bolt at a time, and I understood something that I had not understood before.