No inspection occurred.
No one examined the roots.
No one approached the foundation or fence.
At 6:18, Brenda photographed the tree.
At 6:21, she ordered the first cut.
Officer Ross asked how she obtained the gate key.
Brenda claimed the HOA maintained emergency copies for all properties.
Martin stared at her.
“The association has never had a key to my gate.”
“You may have forgotten submitting it.”
“I installed that lock six months ago.”
“Then a previous key may still function.”
“It is a new cylinder.”
Brenda looked toward the officer.
“This is becoming an unreasonable argument over a landscaping correction.”
“You destroyed a mature tree,” Officer Ross said.
“Under board authority.”
“Show me the rule.”
Brenda produced a printed page titled Landscape Harmony Amendment.
There was no board vote attached.
No homeowner notice.
No county filing.
Officer Ross read it.
“This says fruit-bearing trees may be removed when they interfere with visual uniformity.”
“Yes.”
“Who decides interference?”
“The appearance committee.”
“Who chairs that committee?”
“I do.”
“Who signed the removal order?”
“I did.”
“Who owns Carlisle Landscape Management?”
“My brother.”
Martin laughed once from disbelief.
Brenda turned toward him.
“You should have maintained the tree responsibly.”
“My father maintained that tree for twenty-five years.”
“Your father is no longer the owner.”
The sentence struck harder than Martin expected.
Before he could answer, two dark vehicles entered the cul-de-sac.