He did not feel satisfaction at this either, exactly. He felt the same thing he had felt on the courthouse steps: a quiet confirmation that the record was accumulating, and that it was accumulating in his favor, one stamped page at a time.
Sam Okonkwo's auto shop sat next door to Juniper Crossing, separated from the station lot by a low concrete curb and a chain-link fence that had seen better decades. The shop was a working place: lifts, toolboxes, a radio playing low, the smell of oil and hot metal. Sam himself was a large man in his early fifties, with grease permanently settled into the lines of his hands and a manner that suggested he had stopped being surprised by people a long time ago.
Caleb walked over on a Tuesday afternoon, after the contractors had left, carrying two coffees from the gas station down Route 17, because he did not yet have coffee to offer at his own store and because a man who brings coffee is easier to talk to than a man who arrives empty-handed.
Sam accepted the coffee, looked at the boarded window next door, and shook his head. "I saw the police cars that day," he said. "I didn't see the throw. I heard it, though. Glass makes a sound you don't forget."
"I know," Caleb said.
They stood for a moment in the doorway of the shop, watching the road. Then Sam began to talk, not in a rush, but in the steady way of a person who has been waiting for someone to ask.
"She's been at that station for months," Sam said. "Not weeks. Months. Since not long after your uncle passed, if you want the truth. First it was letters. I saw the envelopes in the station mailbox when the mail carrier left them. Then she started coming by in person. Always dressed like that — the suit, the sunglasses, even in winter. She'd walk the lot, take photographs with her phone, measure things with her eyes. She'd leave notes tucked under the door. Violation this, violation that. The grass. The sign. The paint. The pumps, which weren't even running."
Caleb listened without interrupting. Interrupting a witness, even an informal one, was a good way to lose the second half of what he knew.
"Did she ever try to get in?" Caleb asked, when Sam paused.
"She tried the doors, once that I saw," Sam said. "Side door, back door. Locked, both of them. She stood there for a while, like she was deciding whether locked doors applied to her. Then she left another note. I kept one of them, actually. She left one on my shop door by mistake once, or on purpose — I never figured out which. It said the auto shop was also in violation for storing vehicles visible from the street. My shop. Which has been here since 1989, and which is not in Sagewood either."
Sam went inside and returned with a folded sheet, yellowed slightly, in the same association letterhead Caleb recognized. The language was familiar: violation, compliance, fine, thirty days. Sam had not paid it either.
"She came by in the spring and told one of my mechanics that the station was abandoned and would be seized," Sam continued. "Seized by whom, she didn't say. She said the neighborhood couldn't have an abandoned gas station bringing down property values. I told her the station wasn't abandoned, it was in probate, and she told me I didn't understand how associations worked. I told her I understood how property worked, and she left."
Caleb smiled, briefly, at that. Sam Okonkwo, it turned out, had a dry streak of his own.
"After that, she came less often, but she didn't stop," Sam said. "She'd drive by slowly. She'd park across the street and watch. She'd call the county about the weeds, about the tanks, about anything she could think of. The county came out twice that I know of. Both times they found nothing, because there was nothing to find except a vacant station waiting for its owner to finish probate. The second time, the county man told her — in front of me, because I was out here — that the parcel wasn't in her association. She didn't like hearing that. She said she'd have it looked into."
"She had it looked into by throwing a brick," Caleb said, and immediately regretted the dryness, because it sounded flippant and the situation was not flippant. Sam, however, nodded as if it were an accurate summary.
"That's about the size of it," Sam said. "She ran out of paper, so she used a brick."
Caleb wrote down what Sam had told him that evening, in his notebook, with dates as best as Sam could recall them: the letters in the winter, the door-trying in the spring, the county visits, the note left on the shop. He did not ask Sam to sign anything. He did not ask Sam to testify. He simply thanked him, and Sam said, "If you need me to tell someone else what I just told you, tell me who and when. I'm not hard to find. I'm right here."
Caleb walked back across the curb to his own lot. The station, boarded and quiet, looked less alone than it had that morning, simply because the shop next door was occupied by a man who had been watching, and who had not looked away.
Luis Herrera came to the station on a Friday morning, in his delivery uniform, on his way to a route that would take him through three towns before lunch. He parked his van at pump two, in the same spot where he had stood the afternoon of the brick, and got out holding his phone in one hand and a paper coffee cup in the other.