The gate.
I went out in the dark with a flashlight and looked at it again. Beckett's people had already photographed everything, dusted the latch for what it was worth, which wasn't much. The padlock I'd put on that morning β a good lock, not hardware-store theater β was gone. Not cut and left. Taken. Dale Ferro had taken it with him, or Linda had. Either way it was a detail and I filed it the way I'd filed details for twenty years: write it down, don't interpret it yet.
Beckett called at 0557.
"You up?" he said.
"I'm up."
"Course you are." A pause, paper moving on his end. "I ran Dale Ferro and Ferro Animal Removal LLC like you asked. Like I was going to anyway."
"And?"
"And it's thinner than it looks on that truck door." I could hear him reading. "Sole proprietor. LLC formed four years ago out of a PO box in Millerton. Business license lapsed in March. He had a county contract β nuisance wildlife, stray pickup assist, that kind of thing β for two years. County didn't renew. According to the contracting office, there were complaints. Nothing criminal. Sloppy paperwork, a couple of animals logged wrong, one dog that ended up at the wrong facility and a family that made noise about it."
My hand tightened around the phone. "Wrong facility."
"That was 2023. Dog was recovered. I'm not drawing you a line that isn't there, Alex."
"I know."
"Ferro works out of a rented yard off Route 9," Beckett went on. "Gravel lot, chain-link, a pole barn with no real office. County assessor has it listed under a holding company. He rents month to month. One truck registered to the LLC β that white Ford you and Mrs. Higgins both described β and an older personal pickup. No employees on file. When he needs a second set of hands he hires day labor and pays cash, near as I can tell."
"Financials?"
"Don't have a warrant for that, and I won't get one on what we have yet. What we have is trespass, theft of an animal, and your neighbor's photographs. That's real, Alex. It's enough to bring him in and ask questions. It is not enough to kick his barn door down at dawn, which is why I'm calling you before you decide to drive out to Route 9 and look at that yard yourself."
He knew me well enough for forty-eight hours' acquaintance. Or he'd read people for a living long enough that I wasn't a new type to him.
"I wasn't going to," I said.
"Uh-huh."
"I thought about it," I admitted. "At about three this morning I had the route planned."
"That's the most honest thing you've said to me." Another pause. "Let the law work, Alex. I mean that as more than a line. If you go out there and Ferro sees you, or Linda hears you were out there, everything gets lawyers and denials stacked on top of it and the dog gets further away, not closer. People who do something like this for cash, they panic and they tidy up. I don't want anybody tidying up."
The dog. He said it plain, the way men who work around loss learn to. Major had a name and Beckett used it when he was talking to me in my kitchen, in a manner of speaking. In reports he would be property and an animal and a German shepherd, male, eight years old. Both things were true. I had lived long enough to hold two true things without needing one to cancel the other.
"Have you talked to Linda again?" I asked.
"Called her house at eight last night. She said her attorney had advised her not to discuss an ongoing HOA matter. Her words. Ongoing HOA matter."
"She stole my dog under color of an HOA rule that doesn't exist."
"That's what the report says. Your report, Mrs. Higgins's statement, Dr. Nair's records. I'm building it, Alex. Building takes hours, not minutes."
I stood at the window. Across the street, Mrs. Higgins's house was still dark, but I knew she'd be awake soon. Older people in that neighborhood kept early hours as a point of pride. Her porch light had been on all night. I wondered if she'd left it on deliberately, a kind of watch kept. I decided she had. It steadied me in a way I didn't examine too closely.
"There's the traffic camera," I said. "End of yesterday. You said his truck was caught near the interstate on-ramp Tuesday evening."