The air was cold enough to sting. Snow lay over a stone path, though outside the hospital the morning was warm and wet. Bare trees stood along the path. At its end was a white house with blue shutters.
Daniel knew it.
He had never seen it before.
He had always known it.
A wooden swing hung from the porch. A small lemon tree grew beside the steps, its branches heavy with yellow fruit. The front window was painted shut.
The winter house.
Sophie held his hand. “This is where I saw you.”
Daniel looked at the boy beside him. “Is this where you were kept?”
The boy nodded.
Elise stared at the porch. “I thought it had been erased.”
“It was,” the boy said. “But the memory survived.”
Mara checked her radio. Static. She tried again. Nothing.
David stepped onto the path. “How do we get out?”
The boy pointed at the front door. “We go inside.”
“Of course,” Mara muttered. “Every terrible thing in this family starts with a door.”
They approached the house. The porch boards creaked beneath their feet. On the front door hung a brass key shaped like a tree. Daniel touched it, and a memory struck him so sharply that he nearly fell.
A woman laughing.
A boy running down the hall.
A little girl counting to ten behind a curtain.
A man saying, “If they ask, you were never here.”
Daniel withdrew his hand.
“What did you see?” Nora asked.
“My birthday.”
“You were four.”
“No,” he said. “I was twelve.”
The boy beside him nodded. “You came here on your twelfth birthday.”
Daniel looked at him. “Why?”
“Because that was the day they decided which of us would leave.”
The front door opened by itself.
Inside, the house was warm.
A fire burned in the living room. A table was set for dinner. Three plates sat beside three glasses. On the mantel stood a photograph of Nora, Elise, and a man Daniel recognized as his father.
But the photograph was wrong.
Nora was holding a baby. Elise stood beside her with one hand resting on the shoulder of a young boy. The man stood behind them, smiling.
The boy was Daniel.
And beside him stood David.
There was no Sophie. No Anna. No Martin.
Only a family that might have existed before the world was rearranged.
On the table lay a birthday cake.
Twelve candles.
The boy walked toward it. “This was the night.”
Daniel followed him.
“What happened?”
The boy looked at the cake. “They asked us to choose.”
“Choose what?”
“Which one of us would go home.”
Daniel looked at the three plates. “Who else was here?”
The boy pointed to the empty chair at the head of the table.
“Grandfather.”
A floorboard creaked upstairs.
Then a voice called down.
“Daniel? David? Dinner is ready.”
The voice belonged to Daniel’s father.
Nora closed her eyes.
Elise whispered, “He’s still here.”
A man appeared at the top of the stairs. He was not Martin. He was not Daniel Senior. He was younger than both, with dark hair and a narrow face. He wore a white shirt with the sleeves rolled to his elbows.
Daniel recognized him from the family photographs.
His father.
The man descended slowly.
“Hello, boys,” he said.
David stepped forward. “You’re dead.”
The man smiled. “I was.”
Daniel’s throat tightened. “Who are you?”
“Your father.”
“Which one?”
The man looked at him with tenderness.
“The one who loved you before there was a machine to preserve the feeling.”
He stopped beside the table and touched the birthday cake.
“You were both so young,” he said. “You wanted the same thing. You wanted to go home.”
Daniel looked at the boy. “What did we choose?”
The man’s expression grew sad.
“You chose each other.”
“That doesn’t answer the question.”
“No. It explains why the experiment failed.”
He turned toward Sophie.
“And now the choice belongs to her.”
Sophie moved closer to Daniel. “I don’t want to choose.”
The man knelt before her. “You already have.”
He reached into his pocket and withdrew a small silver key.
On its bow was engraved a single word:
BEGIN.
The house gave a deep, settling groan.
Outside, a second sun rose above the winter trees.
Not a real sun. A pale circle of light, suspended low in the sky, illuminating the snow from beneath. Its glow filled the windows. The walls began to tremble.
The boy grabbed Daniel’s hand.
“Don’t let him open the door,” he whispered.
Daniel looked at his father.
“What is behind it?”
The man’s smile disappeared.
“The life we were supposed to have.”
He placed the silver key on the table.
And from the room above them came the sound of someone knocking.
Three times.
A pause.
Twice.
Sophie began to cry.
“That’s me,” she whispered.
Daniel turned toward the staircase.
At the top stood another Sophie.
This one was older—perhaps sixteen. She wore a dark blue dress and held a small notebook against her chest. Her hair was longer, and the crescent scar beneath her chin had faded to a thin white line.
She looked down at the little girl.