“Did he approve the changes personally?”
“According to the minutes, the committee approved them unanimously.”
Benjamin nodded.
“Then we examine the committee's decision. We don't assume we know why it was made.”
Helen closed the spreadsheet.
“I recommend an independent review of all foundation payments above a defined threshold, along with a sample of smaller transactions. We should also examine related-party disclosures and verify the beneficial ownership of the vendors.”
“Do it,” Benjamin said.
Helen glanced toward Daniel.
“I'll need authorization.”
Daniel nodded.
“You'll have it.”
Benjamin looked at Patricia.
“Are you comfortable cooperating with the review?”
She nodded, though she still looked worried.
“Yes.”
“You can be honest about anything you saw, even if it reflects badly on someone senior.”
Patricia hesitated.
“There were times when I was asked to process payments without the normal supporting documents.”
“Who asked?”
“The chief financial officer's office.”
“Did you comply?”
“Sometimes.”
Benjamin did not look away.
“Why?”
“Because I was told the documentation would follow. And because I was afraid of being removed from my position.”
Her voice shook.
“I know I should have pushed harder.”
Benjamin considered her answer.
“Fear is not the same as dishonesty, Patricia. But we still need to understand what happened.”
She nodded.
“I'll tell the review team everything I remember.”
“Thank you.”
Helen began gathering the invoices.
“There's one more thing I noticed,” she said.
“What is it?” Daniel asked.
“Some of the vendor payments appear to have been authorized just below the threshold that requires two independent approvals.”
Benjamin's expression changed.
“How often?”
“Frequently enough to justify examining the pattern.”
Helen showed them a sequence of transactions.
One payment was $24,750.
Another was $24,900.
A third was $24,600.
Each payment fell below a threshold that would have required an additional review.
Together, the payments to one vendor exceeded $170,000.
Daniel stared at the screen.
“That's not a coincidence.”
Helen held up a hand.
“It may not be. But we need the complete records before drawing a conclusion.”
Benjamin nodded.
“Exactly.”
He stood and walked to the window.
Below, traffic moved along the riverfront streets. Headlights formed white and red lines between the buildings. The city seemed indifferent to the small room forty floors above it.
He thought of Michael.
Michael would have been furious.
Not because money had possibly been misused, but because the money had been entrusted to the foundation for a purpose. Children had been promised support. Donors had been asked to contribute. Employees had been expected to act responsibly.
Every unexplained payment represented a question about whether that trust had been honored.
Benjamin rested his hand on the windowsill.
“Daniel, I want the review to cover the past three years, not just eighteen months.”
Daniel nodded.
“That will take longer.”
“Then it will take longer.”
“And if the records show misconduct?”
“Then we act on the evidence.”
Daniel watched him for a moment.
“You know this could affect the entire foundation.”
Benjamin turned.
“If the foundation cannot survive an honest examination of its accounts, then the problem isn't the examination.”
Helen looked up from her laptop.
“I'll prepare the scope tonight.”
“Thank you,” Benjamin said.
She left the room to contact her team.
Patricia gathered her papers.
“Mr. Anderson?”
“Yes?”
“I need to tell you something else.”
Benjamin waited.
She glanced at Daniel, then back at him.
“Craig has been asking employees to attend a private meeting after the gala. He said he wanted to explain how the event would be handled going forward.”
“When?”
“Tomorrow morning.”
Daniel frowned.
“Why?”
“I don't know. But he told the operations supervisors that anyone who discussed tonight's incident outside the management team would be considered disloyal.”
Benjamin's eyes narrowed.
“Did he put that in writing?”
“No.”
“Did anyone else hear it?”
“Two supervisors.”
“Names?”
Patricia provided them.
Daniel wrote them down.
Benjamin remained silent for a moment.
Then he asked, “Patricia, do you believe Craig was trying to prevent employees from speaking about what happened?”
She hesitated.
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because he said the company couldn't afford people spreading stories that would damage its reputation.”
Benjamin nodded.
“Thank you.”
Patricia left the room.
Daniel closed the door behind her.
“Now we have a possible financial problem and a management problem.”
Benjamin looked at the folder.
“We had both before tonight.”
Daniel exhaled.
“You really don't like simple answers.”
“I like accurate answers.”
He returned to the table.
“Tomorrow morning, we'll interview the staff who were present. We'll preserve the footage from the ballroom and service corridor. We'll review the invoices, and we'll make sure no employee is punished for cooperating.”
Daniel nodded.
“And Craig?”
Benjamin thought for several seconds.
“Keep him away from the investigation. He can submit his account through counsel. Until we understand the facts, he should not supervise the employees who witnessed the incident.”
Daniel wrote down the instruction.
Benjamin looked at the clock.
8:47 p.m.
The gala was still underway.
Somewhere in the ballroom, a guest had just bid $80,000 on a painting.
The auctioneer was announcing another pledge.
The foundation's digital display had passed the three-million-dollar mark.
Benjamin wondered how much of the money would ultimately reach the children whose photographs filled the screen.
Then he returned to the documents.