"Why?"
"The contract ended three years ago."
Benjamin looked at the date.
Exactly the same year Leonard had retired.
"Who replaced them?"
"Several smaller contractors."
Benjamin leaned back.
"Let's look at the payments."
Maria opened a financial summary.
The first few pages contained ordinary figures.
Monthly service charges.
Emergency repair costs.
Equipment replacement expenses.
Annual maintenance fees.
Then Olivia entered carrying another folder.
"I found something."
Benjamin gestured toward a chair.
"Tell us."
Olivia placed a document on the table.
"Northbridge Asset Services was incorporated eighteen years ago. It was registered under the name of a man named Peter Lang."
"Who is Peter Lang?"
"Former financial consultant. He worked with several commercial property groups."
Benjamin looked at the document.
"And?"
Olivia hesitated.
"Three years after Northbridge received its first contract from Pinnacle Holdings, the company changed ownership."
"To whom?"
"A holding company registered in Delaware."
Benjamin studied the paperwork.
"Who owns that?"
Olivia opened another page.
"That's where things become complicated."
She placed a second document on the table.
"The holding company has three listed beneficiaries. One is Peter Lang. Another is an investment trust. The third is a company called Meridian Strategic Partners."
Benjamin looked toward Maria.
"Have you heard of Meridian?"
Maria nodded slowly.
"Yes."
"Where?"
"Some of the company's old investment reports. They were involved in several property acquisitions during the early 2000s."
Olivia continued.
"Meridian Strategic Partners was established by a man named Victor Hale."
Benjamin went still.
He knew that name.
Victor Hale had been a senior executive at Pinnacle Holdings for almost fifteen years.
He had served as chief investment officer and had been considered one of the most influential people in the company's history.
He had left in 2018 after a disagreement with the board.
Benjamin remembered him.
Victor had been intelligent, ambitious, and extremely persuasive.
He was also one of the people Benjamin had distrusted during the final years before leaving the company.
"What was his role in Northbridge?" Benjamin asked.
Olivia answered carefully.
"According to the corporate records, Meridian held an indirect financial interest."
"How much?"
"We haven't established that yet."
Benjamin looked at Maria.
"Did anyone disclose this relationship?"
Maria shook her head.
"Not in the records I've reviewed."
Benjamin's expression hardened.
"Then we need to find out why."
At noon, Richard Coleman joined the investigation.
He entered Benjamin's office carrying a large folder.
"I heard you wanted to speak with me."
Benjamin nodded.
"Sit down, Richard."
Richard took a chair.
Olivia placed the Northbridge documents in front of him.
He examined them.
His face changed.
"I haven't seen these in years."
Benjamin watched him.
"Do you remember approving the Northbridge contract?"
Richard nodded.
"Yes. Leonard recommended them."
"Did you investigate the company's ownership?"
"Of course."
"Did you know Meridian had an interest?"
Richard looked confused.
"No."
Olivia pointed to the document.
"The relationship appears to have existed at the time."
Richard removed his glasses.
"That can't be right."
"Why?"
"Because if Meridian had an ownership interest, it should have been disclosed."
Benjamin folded his hands.
"Was it?"
Richard studied the document.
"Not that I remember."
Benjamin leaned forward.
"Richard, I need you to be very clear with me."
Richard looked up.
"All right."
"Did you knowingly approve contracts that benefited a company connected to Victor Hale?"
Richard answered immediately.
"No."
Benjamin held his gaze.
"Did you receive any financial benefit?"
"No."
"Did you ever receive gifts, payments, or favors from Leonard Price?"
"No."
Richard looked genuinely offended.
"Benjamin, I have worked for this company for more than thirty years."
"I know."
"I would never steal from it."
Benjamin nodded.
"I hope you're telling the truth."
Richard's expression softened slightly.
"Of course I am."
Benjamin looked toward Olivia.
"Then let's establish the facts."
Richard nodded.
But when he stood to leave, Benjamin noticed something.
The financial officer had taken longer than usual to gather his papers.
And he had avoided looking at one particular document.
Benjamin did not comment.
He simply made a note.
That afternoon, Craig Holloway arrived at Benjamin's office.
He was carrying a maintenance report.
"Mr. Anderson?"
Benjamin looked up.
"Craig. Come in."
Craig placed the report on the desk.
"I thought you should see this."
"What is it?"
"An equipment inspection report from the twenty-third floor."
Benjamin opened it.
The report described several ventilation units that had been marked as recently serviced.
Craig pointed toward the second page.
"I was checking the building's service records because we're preparing the winter maintenance schedule."
Benjamin nodded.
"What did you find?"
"These units were supposedly replaced four years ago."
"And?"
Craig hesitated.
"They weren't."
Benjamin looked up.
"How do you know?"
"I spoke with the maintenance technician who worked here at the time. He remembers repairing the original units, but he says they were never replaced."
Benjamin examined the report.
The recorded replacement cost was nearly two hundred thousand dollars.
Craig continued.
"I checked three more buildings. The same thing appears to have happened."
Benjamin sat back.
"How many?"
"At least eleven invoices."
"How much money?"
Craig opened his notebook.
"Approximately three million dollars."
Benjamin looked at him.
"Three million?"
"Possibly more. I haven't finished checking."
Benjamin stared at the documents.
Then he looked at Craig.
"Why did you bring this to me?"
Craig seemed surprised.
"Because something isn't right."
Benjamin nodded.
"Good."
Craig hesitated.
"I also wanted to tell you something else."
"Go ahead."