"It doesn't matter why you did it," Mercier replied, taking a step into the room and leaning his hip against the rough stone wall. "The Apache do not keep a ledger like white men. They do not owe, and they do not forget."
Mercier reached into his coat, pulled out a small horn flask, unstoppered it with his teeth, and took a slow swallow before looking back at Caleb.
"Seven years ago," Mercier continued, "a party of Northern warriors found a wrecked wagon half-buried in a drift at the bend of the Greys River. The horses were dead in their traces. The driverâa white man who had tried to steal the teamâwas frozen solid in the snow."
Calebâs heart hammered against his ribs. "Elizabeth was in that wagon?"
"She was inside," Mercier said. "Her and the little girl. They were near death, frozen to the wood, wrapped in a single wet blanket. The warriors took them south to the summer camps in the mountains to keep them from the winter wind."
"Why didn't they bring them back?" Caleb demanded, his voice cracking with a mixture of rage and agonizing grief. "Why leave a torn scarf on a tree? Why let me spend seven years burying empty boxes in the dirt?"
Mercier looked at Caleb with a cold, unblinking gaze.
"Because when they found her, Caleb," Mercier said softly, "she didn't remember who you were. And she didn't remember her own name."
The words hung in the damp air of the stone room like a heavy weight, crushing the remaining air from Calebâs lungs.
He lowered the Winchester slowly, the tip of the barrel dropping until it rested against his boot. The stone walls around him seemed to lean inward, suffocating and cold.
"What do you mean she didn't remember?" Caleb whispered.
Mercier took another small sip from his flask, his dark eyes never leaving Calebâs face.
"The wagon didn't just break down in the storm, rancher," Mercier explained, his gravelly voice echoing off the damp timber. "The man who took themâa whiskey runner named Vance who had been hiding out near your boundaryâstruck her across the head when she tried to protect her daughter. When the warriors pulled her out of that drift, she had a knot on her skull the size of a fist and a fever that lasted three weeks."
Mercier stepped closer, pointing a thick, calloused finger at the blue scarf in Calebâs hand.
"When she finally opened her eyes in the lodge of Eagle River's mother, the fever was gone, but her past was a blank slate. She knew the little girl was her daughterâthe child never left her sideâbut she didn't know where she had come from. She didn't know the name Morgan. She didn't know the valley."
"And Anna?" Caleb asked, his voice trembling so violently he could barely form the words. "Anna was six years old. She knew her name. She knew her father!"
"Anna was six," Mercier agreed grimly. "And she was terrified. She watched her mother nearly die in the snow. She saw white men with guns take them from their home. When the warriors brought them to the mountains, the child clutched her mother and stayed silent for a year. By the time she started speaking again, the mountain language was the only one that felt safe to her."
Caleb covered his face with his free hand, his fingers digging into his skin.
For seven years, while he had sat alone in his cabin watching the snow fall over empty pastures, believing his family was resting beneath the icy floor of the river, Elizabeth and Anna had been living forty miles away in the timbered hideouts of the high country. They had been breathing, eating, walking under the same Wyoming sky, completely unaware that a man named Caleb Morgan was starving for the sight of them.
"Where are they now, Mercier?" Caleb demanded, dropping his hand, his eyes burning with an intense, desperate light. "Take me to them."
Mercier shook his head slowly. "It's not that simple, Caleb."
"I don't care about simple!" Caleb shouted, the sound shattering the quiet of the trading post. "She's my wife! Anna is my daughter! I have a legal rightâI have a holy right to bring them home!"
"Listen to me!" Mercier snapped, his voice dropping its calm veneer, turning hard as iron. "Eagle River brought them to the high country, but he did not hold them as captives. Over seven years, Elizabeth became part of the band. She healed their sick; she sewed their clothes. The child grew up riding their horses. They are not sitting in a cage waiting to be rescued by a man they do not remember!"
Mercier reached out and touched the hilt of the broad knife at his belt.
"If you ride into Eagle River's camp with a gun in your hand demanding your 'property,' his young men will put ten arrows through your chest before you clear the timber line. Eagle River respects you for what you did for his sister, but he will not allow you to terrify a woman who considers his camp her home."
Caleb swallowed hard, forcing the hot rage back down into his chest. He looked at the tarnished locket in his hand, then at the carefully mended wool scarf.
"Then why give me these?" Caleb asked quietly. "Why bring the locket to my ranch? Why send me to Black Pine Crossing?"
Mercier smiled faintly, a expression that held no humor, only the dry wisdom of a man who had lived his whole life between two worlds.
"Because three months ago," Mercier said, "a fever struck the high camp. Elizabeth fell sick again. And when she woke up from the fever this time... she started calling out for a man named Caleb."
The rain turned to a thick, heavy snow as they left Black Pine Crossing before dawn.
Caleb rode behind Mercier, keeping Bishopâs head close to the tail of the mountain traderâs heavy pack horse. The world had dissolved into a vast, swirling sea of white and dark green, the ancient Douglas firs groaning under the weight of the early mountain blizzard.
Caleb did not feel the cold. His entire body was numb, operating on a raw, electric current of nervous energy that kept his hand glued to his reins and his eyes locked on the narrow trail ahead.
"We go through the Deadman's Pass," Mercier called back over his shoulder, his voice muffled by the thick wool scarf wrapped around his face. "The territorial roads are closed by snow. The military patrols from Fort Washakie won't come up this high until June."
"How far?" Caleb asked.
"Ten miles up. Five down," Mercier replied. "If the snow doesn't slide off the upper rim, we reach the valley by sunset."
They climbed in silence for hours, the trail narrowing until it was nothing more than a two-foot ledge carved into the sheer granite face of the peak. Below them, a canyon dropped three hundred feet into a roaring, invisible torrent of mountain runoff; above them, massive overhangs of blue ice hung suspended like frozen daggers.
Caleb kept his eyes fixed on the horse ahead of him, forcing himself not to think about what he would say when he finally saw her.
What did a man say to a wife who had been dead to him for seven years?
Did he apologize for not finding her sooner? Did he tell her about the empty pine coffins buried beneath the chokecherry bushes by the church? Did he describe the endless, silent nights spent sitting at a pine table with a single plate and a cold cup of coffee?