Donnelly understood a great deal, and enjoyed none of it, by all reports. In the week before the regatta he avoided the harbor's eyes with a diligence that had become its own kind of visibility. He took his meals at the motel. He parked behind the office instead of in front. He had put up, on the fence facing the road, a fresh Meridian banner announcing the Heritage Regatta and the marina to come, and the banner flapped all day in the sea breeze like a flag of a country nobody in town wanted to join. Jess said Donnelly had stopped coming down to the shed floor entirely, directing the festival preparations by telephone from the office with the door closed, and that the crew had developed a practice of leaving the office door's threshold uncrossed, as if it were a tide line.
On Tuesday, Carolyn Reyes came to Walter's porch in the evening with a clipboard and the look of a woman carrying arithmetic she had not asked for. She had the fleet list, the full 1988 entry, thirty-four boats with their builders and rebuilders noted in her careful hand. She read it to Walter sitting in his porch chair, and he listened the way he had listened to loft lines for forty years β without interrupting, checking the truth against what his hands knew.
"Twenty-three," Carolyn said when she finished. "Twenty-three of thirty-four. Walter, do you want to hear the names?"
"I know the names," Walter said.
They sat in the quiet a while. A gull complained somewhere over the cove. Carolyn's pencil tapped once against the clipboard and stopped.
"The skippers are meeting Thursday night at the yacht club," she said. "Lindqvist's office confirmed he'll be in town that afternoon. Carolyn β" she stopped, corrected herself; she had been talking about herself in the third person and it embarrassed her. "I want you at the meeting. Not to speak. Just to be there. So they can see you."
Walter looked at her for a long moment. The tiller's glue was setting in the clamps; he would plane it tomorrow. He thought about the stairs of his loft, about the deputy, about the crew at the gate. He thought about standing in a room full of men and women β men he had taught to caulk, women who had raced boats he had built β while they voted on whether he belonged in his own yard.
"I won't do it, Carolyn," he said, gently, because gentleness was the only thing that made refusal bearable. "I won't stand in a room and be voted on like a warrant article. If the boats are mine to have back, they don't need my permission. The boats can speak, or not. I've done my part. I built them."
Carolyn's eyes filled, and she blinked hard, and nodded, and put the clipboard in her lap like something she was setting down carefully.
"He'll be there," she said. "Lindqvist. Abby called him from Gloucester on Saturday. He knows about the tools and the paper. I don't know what he'll do."
"He'll do what companies do," Walter said. "He'll measure. Then the boats will do what boats do."
After Carolyn left, Walter sat on the porch until the light went down over the cove, and he thought about 1963, and Elias, and the *Willet*'s lines drawn full-size on the loft floor in pencil that had lasted until the floorboards wore smooth. He had been thirty-eight then, and sure of everything, and Elias had been sixty-one and sure of Walter, and the two of them had argued for a week about the sheer of the *Willet*'s bow β Elias wanting it sweeter, Walter wanting it working β until Grace had come up the loft stairs with a pie and settled it by saying the boat would have whatever sheer got it home. Grace had been twenty-nine that spring, quick and laughing, the kind of woman who could end an argument between two shipwrights with a pie and a sentence. She had died in 1985, in the winter, and the loft had been colder ever since, though Walter had never said so to anyone, not even Denise. They had laughed, and the boat had gotten home, year after year, for a quarter of a century. Abby's tiller was drying in the clamps. The yard was quiet across the water. Walter went inside and oiled a plane iron at the kitchen table, because his hands needed work, and because work was the only prayer he had ever trusted.
Wednesday, the thirteenth, Jess came by at dusk with the day's report and stayed for supper. The crew, Jess said, had finished staging the ways. The banner was still flapping. Donnelly had received a telephone call in the afternoon that had kept him in the office with the door shut for an hour, and had come out of it looking, in Jess's phrase, "like a man who'd been told the tide schedule had changed and nobody had consulted him."
"That was Lindqvist's office," Walter said.
"Probably," Jess said. "He's flying in tomorrow. Everybody knows. Nobody's saying it."
They ate in the companionable silence of two men who had worked wood together. After supper, Walter planed the tiller smooth, and Jess watched, and Walter showed him how to read the grain at the throat so the break wouldn't find the weakness again β a small lesson, given without ceremony, the way Elias had given them to Walter. Elias had taught in the loft on winter afternoons, when the yard was closed and the light came thin through the skylight, and he had never lectured; he had handed Walter a tool and corrected the hand until the hand knew. Walter could still hear him: "Don't argue with the grain, Walter. Argue with the weather." He said it to Jess now, and Jess grinned, and for a minute the kitchen was the loft, forty years folded into one room.
"It'll hold," Jess said, holding the finished tiller up to the light of the kitchen window, turning it, his hands careful in the way Walter's had been at twenty-six, learning. "She'll feel the difference."
"She'll feel her age, same as the rest of us," Walter said. "But she'll steer true."
Wednesday morning brought Denise's call from Portland β his daughter, thirty-eight, a teacher, who had been calling every Sunday since June with the same offer, lawyers, and the same frustration at his refusals. This time she had read about the auction in the Maine papers β Jess's catalogue find had traveled β and her voice had the particular edge of a daughter who has decided her father is being noble at his own expense.
"Dad, the codicil is ironclad. Abby's lawyer said so. You could have Donnelly personally liable β"
"Paper's doing what paper does, Denny," Walter said, using the childhood name he had not used in years, and heard her soften in spite of herself. "Abby stopped the auction. The lawyers have the papers. Now it's the boats' turn."
"The boats don't have lawyers," Denise said.
"No," Walter agreed. "That's why they need Thursday."
She was quiet, and then she said what she always said at the end of these calls, which was that she loved him and that she was coming down for the regatta whether he liked it or not, and he said he loved her and that the spare room was hers, and they hung up, and Walter stood in the kitchen with the tiller drying in its clamps and thought about how a man's life gets decided, in the end, by a granddaughter of his master, a twenty-six-year-old apprentice, a daughter in Portland, and a fleet of boats he had built with his own hands. It was, he decided, as good a jury as any man had ever faced.
"It's a good piece," Jess said.
"It's ash," Walter said. "Ash forgives, if you ask it right."
They carried the tiller down to Abby's mooring in the skiff at first light on Thursday, the fourteenth, before the town was properly awake. The cove lay flat and silver, and the fleet at anchor β the regatta boats come in from up and down the bay β rode easy on the flood. Walter counted them without meaning to, the way he had always counted boats, and stopped counting at twenty, because counting was a kind of hope and he had promised himself he was done with hope as a practice. Abby was on deck in a sweatshirt, coiling a line, and she saw the skiff and straightened, and her face did the complicated thing it had been doing since June β gratitude and anger and something like apology, all at once.
Walter handed up the tiller. Abby took it, turned it in her hands, ran a thumb over the planed throat.
"You lofted her," she said. It wasn't a question.
"In '63," Walter said. "Your grandfather argued with me about her bow for a week. Your grandmother settled it with a pie."
Abby laughed, and the laugh broke something in her face, and for a moment she was just a young woman with her grandfather's boat and a mended tiller, and not the person who had driven to Gloucester and stopped an auction.
"The meeting's tonight," she said. "Seven o'clock. The yacht club."
"I know."
"Walter." She held the tiller with both hands. "Whatever they decide β"
"You race your boat," Walter said. "That's what tonight's for, and what Saturday's for. You race the *Willet* the way she deserves."
He rowed back in the skiff, and the cove was waking now, halyards ringing against masts, gulls quarreling over the fish house scraps, the whole working harbor going about its business on a Thursday in July. On shore, Meridian's banner flapped. In the office behind it, Donnelly was somewhere, not coming out. Walter beached the skiff and walked home up the hill, and the day stretched ahead of him, long and ordinary and his own, and he spent it the way he had spent every day since June 17: working wood at his own table, in his own house, with his own hands, waiting to see what the boats would say.