She read for twenty minutes. The entries had the terrible cleanliness of tide tables, each consequence a thing with a name or a face. The window card's wording, approved over objections noted and overruled. The training budget's conversion into a hospitality budget. The year the atelier's request for a new timing machine was refused in the same quarter the boutique's marble was re-polished at four times the cost — Ingrid read the two figures side by side, without emphasis, which was the emphasis.
"And the display pieces," Elias said.
For the first time that morning, Ingrid's composure showed its scaffolding. "The display pieces are mine, and I will say it in the room. For three years, the watches that go into the window and the press coffrets come to my bench first. And I finish them. By hand. Beyond specification. The bevels, the screws over flame, the regulation to five positions. Eleven hours a watch, some of them. It is in no instruction and no costing. I did it because I could not stand the thought of your loupe on the window watch, finding the costume first. If the lie was going to wear the name, at least the name in the window would be true. It was vanity and it was cowardice, and it is in my log with the dates."
"How many?" Elias said.
"Two hundred and nine." She turned the notebook around so that he could see the column of dates himself. "I counted them the way I counted the languages."
He looked at the column for a moment. "You kept the standard," he said, "in the window."
"I kept it where it could be seen, Mr. Thorn. That is not the same thing, and I have not confused them. But it is not nothing, either."
"No," he said. "It is not nothing."
Peg Halloran came up the service stairs at eleven with the folder under her arm and laid her three years of protest memos on the bench in a row, the way one lays place settings for guests who never came. There were nine of them, each shorter than the one before, as if protest could be rationalized down to its essentials. The first was four pages and cited the standard by clause. The last was three lines long: The certificate states hand-finished. The watch is not. This office dissents, again, for the record. The replies, where replies existed, were clipped behind: noted, under review, aligned with group strategy, no reply, no reply, no reply.
"You wrote to them nine times," Elias said.
"I wrote to them nine times, Mr. Thorn." Peg stood at the end of the bench, a woman who had run his flagship boutique for nineteen years and sold, for the last three of them, a story she had stopped believing in the first. "Then I sold the watches anyway, because the staff have mortgages, and because I told myself the tenth memo would be the one. There is no tenth memo. There's this morning, instead."
By then the room had changed its air: the young watchmakers worked with their heads down and their shoulders up around their ears, like people in a church where the sermon has finally, after three years of weather reports, mentioned sin. Shame was most of it. Every bench knew what a pressed bevel looked like; every bench had regulated the bought calibre, felt through the tweezers how little of it answered back, and gone home and — in at least four cases Ingrid knew of — apologized to the watch. There is a private liturgy among young watchmakers who chose a great name and found it leased out from under them: you finish what you can, you true what you're given, and you say sorry to the ones you can't, under your breath.
But underneath the shame was the relief: the thing had a witness at last — not a journalist, not a lawyer, but the one man alive whose finding could not be filed under noted.
Elias let the silence do its work and then, at the last bench but one, stopped behind the copper-haired watchmaker, who was regulating a bought calibre with a concentration out of all proportion to the task.
"You chose this house," Elias said.
She did not turn around. "Yes, Mr. Thorn."
"For the name."
"For what the name meant in school." Her hands stayed steady; her voice nearly did. "We were shown a Meridian movement in my second year. The real one. The instructor passed the balance cock around like a relic and said, this is what a signature looks like when a man signs with a file. I came here to learn to sign like that."
He stood a moment longer. "And what did we teach you?"
"To regulate what arrives," she said, "and to keep my initials off it." Then, with the courage of the utterly exhausted: "I'd like my initials back, Mr. Thorn."