The Empty Pool
Karen Whitmore arrived through the side gate like she was stepping onto a runway.
The gate of Michael Turner's backyard β her venue, her production, her Summer Social β swung open at exactly two o'clock, and Karen walked in the way a bride walks into a reception, pausing two steps inside so the moment could arrange itself around her. Her rainbow-striped bikini was new, ordered from a boutique in Charleston because nothing in the mall had been right. Over it floated a sheer white cover-up, long sleeves, open at the front, drifting behind her every time the wind picked up. Her sunglasses were oversized, the kind that swallowed half her face, and her tan heels β real heels, four inches, strapped at the ankle β sank a quarter inch into the soft lawn with every step, which she pretended not to notice. Her beige designer bag hung from the crook of her elbow. She had spent forty minutes on her hair.
She took in the yard the way a general surveys a battlefield she has already won.
Pastel balloons trembled on ribbons tied to the fence posts, thirty or forty of them, rose and peach and mint, swaying in the early-afternoon breeze. Under the cedar pergola, the caterer's crew had arranged the tables exactly as the diagram she had emailed them specified: white linens, low floral arrangements of hydrangeas and eucalyptus so the guests could see each other across them, two silver champagne buckets sweating in the heat beside a stack of flutes. Someone β she would find out who β had hung a string of Edison bulbs across the pergola beams for later, when the light went gold. The music was already playing, a bossa-nova playlist she'd curated herself, and it drifted over the lawn like a perfume.
Thirty-some guests were already here. Denise Park was holding court near the drinks table in a black one-piece, her board vice-president badge nowhere in sight but her authority visible anyway. Tom Alvarez, the board secretary, was flipping burgers at the grill with a beer in one hand and the concentration of a man defusing a bomb. Kids shrieked somewhere near the far fence. The Whitmore Realty photographer β Karen had hired him herself, invoice to the HOA activities budget, approved at the March meeting β was crouched near the rose beds, testing light.
It was perfect. It was hers. This was the photograph that would sit on the Stonebrook Hills community page until October, the one her listings would link to, the proof that under Karen Whitmore's presidency this neighborhood had become somewhere people wanted to be.
"Afternoon, Karen." Michael Turner stepped out from behind the pergola post where he'd been standing with a bottle of sparkling water. "Everything set up the way you wanted it?"
He was the one off-note in the composition. Faded navy polo, khaki shorts, bare feet. He looked like a man who had wandered into someone else's garden party by mistake, and in a sense he had, because in Karen's mental photographs of the Summer Social the host was decorative β a retired engineer who opened his gate, smiled for the group photo, and stayed out of the way of the real program.
"Michael," she said, sweeping off the sunglasses so he could see her eyes β she did that with men when she wanted them to feel noticed. "It's beautiful. You've outdone yourself this year."
He smiled the small, unbothered smile she could never quite read. "All I did was open the gate."
She laughed, touched his arm, and moved past him toward the center of the lawn, heels punching little divots into the grass. A neighbor called her name. Another one waved. The photographer stood and aimed the camera at her as she raised both arms in a little queen's wave β and that was when she turned toward the water.
The pool was empty.
For a full second her brain refused the information. The pool β Michael Turner's big kidney-shaped pool, the centerpiece of every Summer Social photograph since the neighborhood had a camera to take one β was not blue. It was not even wet. Its floor was a pale, chalky expanse of plaster sloping down to a deep end that held perhaps two inches of brown-green water, the color of a swamp, with a curled dead leaf stuck to the drain cover like a bookmark. A single plastic beach ball, deflated, lay collapsed against the far wall. The water line on the tile was a scummy ring of mineral stains. The diving board stood naked over nothing.
The music kept playing. Somewhere a child laughed, oblivious.
Karen's sunglasses were still in her hand. She put them on again, slowly, as though clearer vision would correct the error.
"Michael." Her voice came out level, which surprised her. "Michael, come here a second."
He walked over at his own pace, unhurried, the bottle of sparkling water still in his hand. The photographer lowered his camera. Denise Park stopped mid-sentence. A hush went through the guests in ripples, the way a crowd goes quiet at a ballpark when the crack of the bat doesn't sound right.
"What," Karen said, walking to the pool's edge, her heels clicking on the coping, "the hell is this?"
She didn't wait for the wind to die. She didn't wait for him to answer. Thirty pairs of eyes were on her, and the photographer β she could feel him raising the camera again β and the whole afternoon tilted on its axis. The centerpiece of her Social, the blue heart of every invitation she had mailed, every flyer the board had posted, every promise she had made on her real-estate website about "the lifestyle at Stonebrook Hills" β it was a dry bowl of stained plaster with two inches of filth at the bottom.
She turned on him, and the sunglasses slid down her nose, and what was behind them was not the gracious hostess anymore.
"What the hell is this?" she said again, louder, and this time it wasn't a question about the pool.
It was the beginning of something neither of them had planned.
"No."
"You drained HOA property." Karen's voice carried across the entire backyard. "This pool belongs to the association. Fill it back up."