*No.* He cut the thought off like a rope. It couldn't be. There were a thousand chestnut mares with white stars in the mountain West, and a fence scar was hardly a fingerprint. Coincidence. Wishful thinking. The mind playing tricks on a lonely man.
And yet his hand was already rising, moving of its own accord, toward the star on her forehead. The mare stood perfectly still — *perfectly* still, the way a horse stands when it has decided to trust you with something — and let him touch it. Her skin was warm under his palm. Her pulse beat against his fingers, fast and strong and *alive*, and the feeling of it went through him like a current, like putting his hand on a live wire.
For three years he had touched nothing living except firewood.
"Please," he whispered. He didn't know he was going to say it. "Whatever it is — please don't make me feel this."
The mare turned her head and looked at him — one dark eye, depthless, holding his — and then she walked to the treeline, stopped at the exact spot where the trail dropped into the pines, and looked back.
Waiting.
Danny looked at the woodpile, half-split rounds scattered around the stump like unfinished sentences. He looked at the cabin, smoke still braiding up from the chimney, the rocking chair creaking empty on the porch, Rosa's unopened letter lying on the table inside like an accusation. He looked at the axe leaning against the stump — his meditation, his forgiveness, his excuse.
Then he looked at the mare, standing at the edge of the pines like a question he didn't want to answer and couldn't ignore.
"I'm an idiot," he said out loud, to the mountain, to Elena's empty chair, to no one.
He started toward the lean-to out of habit — a lead rope, at least; you didn't go anywhere with a strange horse without a rope — but the mare cut him off, swinging her hindquarters into his path with a neat sidestep that nearly took his knees out. When he tried to go around her, she sidestepped again, ears flat now, and bared her teeth at the lean-to door.
"All right! All right, no rope," Danny said, holding up both hands. "I get it. No time. You're the boss."
She wheeled and headed for the treeline without looking back, as if his agreement had been a foregone conclusion. Danny grabbed his coat from the woodpile, shrugged into it, and followed her into the trees — a man with no rope, no plan, and no good explanation, trailing a horse who clearly had all three.
She didn't wait for him to catch up.
The moment Danny's boots hit the trail, the mare broke into a trot — not the amble of a tired animal but the purposeful, ground-eating trot of a horse with somewhere to be and no time to waste. Pine needles and frost crackled under her hooves. Danny, coat half-buttoned and flapping, axe left behind on the stump like an abandoned crutch, broke into a shambling run after her.
"Slow down!" he shouted, immediately feeling ridiculous — a forty-four-year-old man yelling at a horse on an empty mountain. "Hey — *slow down!*"
She didn't slow down. If anything she quickened, her tail streaming behind her, and Danny understood with a sinking feeling that this was not going to be a short stroll to a neighboring pasture or a quick check on a cast shoe. The trail she was following dropped away from the cabin in a series of steep switchbacks, descending the north face of the ridge toward the ravine country — rough, trailless land he hadn't set foot in for years, land he'd always given a wide berth because it was good for nothing but breaking legs.
His knees protested within the first hundred yards. Forty-four years old, three years of chopping wood but no real running, lungs full of woodsmoke and mountain cold, and the mountain didn't care about his excuses. The trail pitched down between granite outcrops, loose scree sliding treacherously under his boots, and twice he nearly went sprawling before he learned to lean back, dig his heels in, and let gravity do the arguing. His breath sawed in his throat. Sweat broke out under his flannel despite the cold, and a stitch took up residence under his ribs like an unwelcome tenant.
The mare, meanwhile, flowed downhill like water finding its level — sure-footed, economical, beautiful in the way of all working animals doing what they were made for. Every fifty yards or so she would stop — ears up, head high, tail flagged — and look back at him. *Are you coming? Are you still with me?* And then she'd move on, never quite out of sight, never quite waiting long enough for him to catch his breath. It was a herding behavior, he realized dimly. She was *herding* him. The thought would have been funny if he'd had any breath left for laughing.
The pines closed around them, and the world narrowed to green shadow and gold light falling in shafts between the trunks. The air smelled of pitch and cold earth. A jay screamed somewhere overhead, scolding them both. Danny's boots found the rhythm of the trail, and for a strange suspended minute the absurdity of it fell away entirely — a man following a horse through the high country because she'd asked him to — and what was left felt oddly, terrifyingly *right*, like a door opening in a house he'd thought was empty.
*Am I following a horse into the wilderness like a fool?* The thought arrived with complete clarity somewhere around the third switchback, stepping neatly over the stitch in his side, along with its companion: *Yes. Yes, I am. Certifiably.*