The response came a few minutes later.
Yes. You will be shown the relevant recordings during the meeting.
Celeste looked at her mother.
“I think I want Daniel to come.”
Lorraine nodded.
“Ask him.”
At 10:30 that morning, Samuel Avery entered the foundation's conference room carrying a thick folder.
Miriam Hale was already there.
Jonathan Reeves sat beside her, while a woman with short silver hair and a black leather portfolio occupied the chair nearest the window.
Samuel knew her professionally but had never worked with her directly.
“Samuel,” Miriam said. “This is Dr. Evelyn Shaw. She will lead the independent review.”
Samuel shook her hand.
“Thank you for taking this on.”
Dr. Shaw nodded.
“I've reviewed the initial incident report and the preservation request. I understand the importance of keeping this process separate from the foundation's management.”
“That's why we appointed you.”
She placed her portfolio on the table.
“I also want to clarify something before we begin. I am not here to determine whether the foundation is a good organization or whether its intentions were honorable. I'm here to establish what happened, who made which decisions, and whether existing procedures were followed.”
Samuel nodded.
“That's exactly what we need.”
Dr. Shaw opened her portfolio.
“The first recording is from the hotel's western ceiling camera.”
She connected her laptop to the conference screen.
A grainy image appeared.
The exhibition hall was visible from above. The camera covered the entrance, the registration table, and most of the demonstration mat.
Dr. Shaw moved the recording to 3:12 p.m.
The hall filled with movement.
Volunteers carried equipment.
Spectators entered.
Nolan Price and his teammates stood near the mat, speaking with the event coordinator.
Dr. Shaw paused the recording.
“Do you recognize this person?”
Samuel leaned forward.
The man wore a black polo shirt and held a clipboard.
“That's Travis Sloane's manager, isn't it?”
“According to the event records, yes. His name is Victor Hale.”
Jonathan looked at the schedule.
“He was listed as a guest representative, not as a demonstration supervisor.”
Dr. Shaw nodded.
“Yet he appears to be giving instructions.”
She resumed the recording.
Victor approached the registration table and spoke to a young woman wearing a blue volunteer shirt.
The woman pointed toward the equipment area.
Victor shook his head.
Then he pointed toward the demonstration mat.
The volunteer looked uncertain.
She said something.
Victor responded.
After several seconds, she walked toward the mat.
Samuel leaned closer.
“Who is that?”
Miriam checked the volunteer list.
“That's Celeste.”
Samuel watched the recording.
He could see her carrying a folded white jacket.
She approached the mat, spoke to Victor, and appeared to gesture toward the equipment area.
Victor pointed toward Nolan.
Celeste shook her head.
Then she looked toward the registration table.
Victor stepped closer.
The camera had no audio, but the body language was clear enough to raise questions.
Dr. Shaw paused the recording.
“Do you know what was said?”
“No,” Samuel replied.
“Can you tell whether Celeste agreed to participate?”
Samuel watched the frozen image.
“No.”
“Neither can I. We need the audio from the ballroom recording.”
She changed files.
A second recording appeared.
This camera was mounted above the main stage and captured most of the mat.
The image was clearer.
The audio was also available.
Dr. Shaw moved to the beginning of the demonstration.
Nolan's voice came through the speakers.
“Come on. Don't be nervous. It's easy.”
Celeste stood near the center of the mat.
“I was told I was helping with equipment.”
A few spectators laughed.
Nolan responded:
“That's what you're doing. Helping us demonstrate.”
Celeste shook her head.
“I didn't agree to be part of it.”
Travis stepped into the recording.
“It's a charity event. Relax.”
Celeste looked toward the coordinator.
“Can someone else do it?”
The coordinator said something that could not be heard clearly.
Nolan laughed.
“Don't tell me you're afraid.”
Celeste answered:
“I'm not afraid. I just don't want to do that.”
The room became quiet.
Samuel stared at the screen.
The footage continued.
Nolan moved closer.
He reached for Celeste's arm.
She stepped away.
He grabbed the front of her jacket.
Then the sound came.
A sharp rip.
The spectators reacted.
Nolan held up the torn panel.
“Guess they don't make uniforms for charity cases.”
Travis laughed.
Bryce laughed.
Several people in the audience followed.
Dr. Shaw stopped the recording.
No one spoke.
Samuel sat very still.
Miriam looked down at the table.
Jonathan removed his glasses.
Dr. Shaw turned toward Samuel.
“Do you recognize the moment when she asks to leave?”
“Yes.”
“Let's continue.”
The recording resumed.
Celeste moved toward the western side of the mat.
Bryce stepped into her path.
Nolan said something.
The audio was clearer now.
“You can leave after you say you misunderstood.”