Valerie went once. Then she went again. Then she kept going, on Tuesday afternoons, after her teaching shifts, sitting in the deep chair with a mug of tea in her hands, talking to a man who listened the way Ingrid watched: carefully, without interrupting, without trying to fix anything before he understood it.
What are you afraid of? he asked her, on the third visit, leaning forward slightly, his elbows on his knees.
Valerie thought about it. She thought about the fall, and the clip, and the comments, and the judges at their charcoal table, and the phone in the third row, and the hundreds of faces in the stands. She thought about the way her knees went loose and her breath came too fast and her hands shook when someone stopped to watch her skate.
I'm not afraid of falling, she said at last, slowly, because she was only just understanding it herself, as the words came out. "Falling doesn't scare me. I've been falling since I was six. I know how to fall. I know how to get up. What I'm afraid of is being seen falling. I'm afraid of all those eyes on me, and of what they're thinking, and of the clip, and of the comments, and of everyone knowing, forever, that I fell. I'm afraid of being watched while I fail."
Dr. Pierce nodded. He did not write anything down. He did not look surprised.
That makes sense, he said. "And it is also a story you are telling yourself. Let me ask you something. When Sophie, the little girl you teach, falls down, what do you think?"
Valerie blinked. "I think she's learning. I think she's brave for trying."
Do you think she is a failure?
No. Of course not.
And when you fell at the nationals, do you think the audience thought you were a failure? Some of them, perhaps. The ones who left comments. But most of them? Most of them were watching a young woman get up and finish her programme with a strained ankle and her heart breaking, and they were holding their breath for her. You cannot control what they thought. You can only control what you do next.
He taught her breathing, then. Not the shallow, panicked breathing she did when her name was called, but slow breathing, in through the nose, out through the mouth, counting to four, feeling her feet on the floor, feeling the weight of her own body, solid and real. He taught her to notice the fear without obeying it, to say to herself, "I am afraid, and I am going to skate anyway," the way she might say, "It is raining, and I am going to walk to the rink anyway."
On their fourth visit, Dr. Pierce suggested something that made Valerie's stomach tighten just hearing it.
I want you to skate in front of people, he said. "Not hundreds. Not yet. A small audience. People you trust. Five or six of them. Ingrid. Emma. Your mother. Two of the children you teach, if you like. You will skate your thirty-second passage, the one Aurora on Ice wants to see, and you will let them watch you, and you will notice what happens in your body, and you will breathe through it."
Valerie stared at him. "That's the thing I'm afraid of."
I know, he said. "That is why we are going to do it in a place where the stakes are low and the people love you. Fear does not go away by avoiding it. It goes away by meeting it in small doses, again and again, until your body learns that being watched is not the same as being in danger."
She agreed, though her hands shook when she said yes, and Ingrid arranged it for a Saturday morning, after the children's class, when the rink was quiet and the light was soft through the high windows. Emma sat in the front row with a flask of tea. Her mother sat beside her, still in her nurse's uniform, her hands in her coat pockets. Ingrid stood at the boards with her notebook. Sophie and Jack sat on the bench, swinging their legs, whispering to each other, utterly unaware that they were part of a psychological experiment.
Valerie stood at the far end of the rink, her heart hammering, her palms damp inside her gloves. She could feel every eye on her. She could feel her knees going loose. She took a breath, in through her nose, out through her mouth, counting to four, feeling her feet on the ice, feeling the weight of her own body, solid and real. "I am afraid," she said to herself, "and I am going to skate anyway."
She pushed off. She skated into the passage, her blades whispering, and for the first few seconds she could hear nothing but her own breathing, loud in her ears. Then she jumped. She turned. She landed, one foot, clean, steady, and she kept going, through the footwork, through the spin, and when she finished, she stopped at the boards, breathing hard, and looked up.
Sophie was on her feet, clapping so hard her mittens made a soft thudding sound. Jack was shouting, "Again! Do it again!" Her mother was crying, quietly, wiping her eyes with the back of her hand. Emma was smiling, her eyes bright. Ingrid nodded once, and wrote something in her notebook, and Valerie knew, without being told, what she had written.
It had not been perfect. Her arms had been a little tight on the landing, and her spin had travelled further than it should have. But she had done it. She had skated in front of people, and she had not fallen, and even if she had fallen, she thought, looking at Sophie's beaming face, she would have gotten up, and Sophie would have clapped anyway, because Sophie had seen her get up a hundred times, and Sophie knew that was the important part.