The next week the children filled a shelf with small things. Annie brought the tin cup she had used at the muddy seep. Daniel brought a wooden whistle his father had carved during a summer when there was no work. Rusk's daughter, who had arrived after the creek returned, brought a blue ribbon from the journey west. She said it reminded her that people could come to a new place and begin again. Elise placed each object beside a card bearing the child's words, written exactly as spoken.
Some memories were funny. A boy recalled trying to wash his dog with sand and being bitten for his trouble. Some were painful. One girl said she had pretended not to be thirsty because her baby brother cried whenever the family bucket was empty. Elise had to step outside after hearing that one. Caleb followed her but did not speak until she was ready.
'I thought I knew what they had lived through,' she said. 'I was there every day. I handed them water. And still I didn't know.'
'You knew your part of it,' Caleb answered. 'Nobody can know every room in another person's house.'
The shelf became a small exhibit for the town. Parents came in the evenings and stood before the objects in silence. Some wept. Others began talking to neighbors they had avoided since the trial. Mrs. Henderson brought a photograph of her family before the drought, and the widow whose bucket Caleb had paid to fill on his first day brought the knotted handkerchief in which she had once carried her coins.
Elise placed the handkerchief beside Annie's cup. On the card she wrote: We remember what thirst cost us, so that we will not ask anyone else to pay it.
When Caleb read the sentence, he thought of the dime he had laid on the wagon's tailgate. At the time it had seemed a small act, almost nothing. Now he saw that the town's history was made of such moments as much as it was made of trials and broken dams. People had survived because they had shared what little they possessed, and the story of that sharing deserved to be kept where children could see it.
A Visit from Prescott
In April, Colonel Hargrove's replacement at the territorial office sent an investigator to Copper Creek to review the public water agreement. The man's name was Felix Warren, and he arrived with a polished valise, a stiff collar, and an alarming number of questions. He was not unfriendly. He was simply convinced that every local arrangement concealed a defect that a properly trained official would discover.
He inspected the well first. He measured the shaft, checked the cover, and asked whether the town possessed a written record of every person authorized to draw water. Bissett produced the maintenance ledger. Warren read it and asked where the list of users was kept.
'We don't keep one,' Bissett said.
'How do you know who is entitled to draw?'
'If they're thirsty,' Hiram answered, 'that's usually a good indication.'
Warren did not smile. He asked about water rights, the council's authority, and the legal status of the Hartwell cistern. By afternoon he had filled twelve pages of notes. By evening half the town believed he had come to shut the well, and the other half believed he intended to put a tax on it. Caleb had seen this sort of panic before. It began with a stranger carrying papers and ended with everyone remembering the worst thing papers had ever done to them.
Elise invited Warren to the schoolhouse the next morning. She showed him the children's exhibit and the records of the drought. He stood for a long time before the knotted handkerchief, reading the card beneath it. Then he asked to see the original agreement.
She laid the pages on the desk. 'You can tell us if the language is weak,' she said. 'But please understand why it says what it says.'
Warren read the first clause twice. It declared that no resident or traveler could be denied drinking water for lack of money. The second established a maintenance fund. The third required public accounts and annual election of trustees. The fourth barred any single person from selling exclusive rights to the well or creek.
'You wrote this?' he asked.
'The council did. Mr. Mercer proposed part of it. I kept the minutes.'
'It is unusually direct.'
'We had an unusually direct lesson in what happens when it isn't.'
He looked up. 'My office is concerned about agreements that cannot survive a dispute. Good intentions are not a substitute for legal standing.'