"That was Evelyn Markham's attorney on my other line," she said. "Formal call, counsel to counsel. He says his client has given him instructions that surprised him, and he used the word 'instructions' twice, so I believe him."
Isaiah set the tea down. "What does she want?"
"She wants to talk," Bec said. "To you. In a room, with counsel present, no cameras, nothing prepared for the press. In twenty years of practice, defendants in her position ask to talk for exactly two reasons. They want to perform, or they want to stop performing. I don't know which one this is yet."
Across the street, behind the closed blinds of 291, a single lamp came on in an upstairs room.
"What do I do?" Isaiah said.
"You sleep on it," Bec said. "And then you decide what kind of man is going into that room. But Isaiah. She's asking. That's the first new thing she's done."
Evelyn Markham had rehearsed the apology in her kitchen, in her car, and once, quietly, to the bathroom mirror, where the woman looking back had seemed unconvinced by all three drafts.
The first was the one she had given the reporter. Protecting the neighborhood. Frightened. Confused. It sounded like a statement read off a card. The second was built around the word misunderstanding, a word she had begun to hate, because nothing about that afternoon had been a misunderstanding. She had understood everything, wrongly, willfully, in the wrong order, but she had not misunderstood. The third she abandoned at the sink, because it began with the words "If I offended," and some new, unwelcome faculty in her refused to let the sentence finish.
David flew in from Ohio on Friday without telling her he was coming. She opened the door on its chain, out of a habit three weeks old, and found her son on the step with a carry-on bag and the face of a man who had driven a long way inside his own head.
"You didn't have to come," she said.
"I know. Let me in anyway, Mom."
He made tea, then set his phone on the table between them, and Evelyn understood what the visit was.
"I've heard pieces," David said. "The news pieces. Your piece, mostly. I want to hear the whole call. I'm not leaving this table on pieces."
"It won't tell you what you think it will."
"Mom." He was not unkind. That was the terrible part. He was gentle the way people are gentle with the very ill. "Play it."
So she played it. Her own voice filled her kitchen, crisp and frightened and escalating, the dispatcher asking his patient questions, and then the pause. The pause lasted a hundred years. She could hear the deciding in it, and knew David could hear it too, because he closed his eyes.
"I think he has a gun in his waistband," said the woman on the phone, who was her. "You need to send everyone before he starts shooting."
The recording ended. The kitchen ticked back into its ordinary sounds.
"Was there a gun?" David asked at last.
"No."
"Did you see anything that looked like a gun?"
"He had a sander, and a pry bar on the steps. He wasn't holding anything when the police came. He was drinking water." "David, I was frightened. Truly frightened. That part is not a lie."
"I believe you were frightened," David said. "That's not the question I came with." He turned the phone face down, carefully. "The question is what you did with being frightened. There's a whole pause on that tape where a dispatcher is basically begging you to describe what you see, and you came out of it with a gun that doesn't exist. People get killed on that sentence, Mom. That man has a mother. She could have gotten a phone call because you were frightened of a man drinking water in his own yard."
Evelyn put her hands flat on the table to stop them shaking. "I understand it now."
"Now," David repeated, weighing the word, not cruelly. "Okay. Then what are you going to do about it? Not the lawyers' version. Yours. And after you tell me, I'll help you with whatever comes next. I'm your son. That's not conditional."
She told him about the call her attorney had made, the room, the counsel, the no cameras. She had no fourth draft, she said, and was afraid of going in without one.
"Then don't bring a draft," David said. "Bring the truth. It's the only thing you haven't tried on him yet."
The meeting took place on a gray morning in a conference room at her attorney's office. Evelyn wore the blue suit she had worn to Harold's funeral, because it was the most honest clothing she owned. Isaiah Grant arrived with Bec Lawson, taller than she remembered from across the street, occupying only his own space.